Cover Page
Relationship between Religion and Politics in Islam, Part 3
speak the truth and to appear as witness in court—or wherever you appear as witness—honestly and truthfully. A society where robbery has become the order of the day; where there is disorder, chaos, usurpation of others rights, where the courts seldom witness a person who is truthful, where filthy language is a commonplace mode of expression, where there is no decency left in human behaviour—what would you expect Shariah to do there? How would the law of Shariah genuinely be imposed in such a country? This is the question.
Suitable Atmosphere Required for the Imposition of Shariah Law
I have given a different form to this question and this was raised of course, and so far, I have not heard of any answer which really could resolve the issue. The question is that every country has a climate and not all the flora can flourish in that climate. Dates flourish in deserts but not in the chilly north. Similarly, cherries cannot be sown in the desert; they require a special climate. Shariah also requires a spe- cial climate, if you have not created that climate, then Shariah can- not be imposed. Every prophet—not only Prophet Muhammad sa—first cre- ated that healthy climate for the law of God to be imposed, will- ingly not compulsorily. And when the society was ready, then the laws were introduced and stiffened further and farther, until the whole code was revealed. That society was capable of carrying the === PDF-Seite 24 === 14 The Relationship Between Religion & Politics
burden of the law of religion, whether you call it ‘Shariah law’ or any other law. In a society, for instance, where theft is commonplace, where telling falsehood is just an everyday practice, if you enact Shariah law and sever the hands of those who steal, what is going to hap- pen? Is that the purpose of Shariah? It’s not just a question of sen- timentality about religion. God’s will be done no doubt, but it will be done in the orderly way as God wishes us to do.
Shariah Law Used as a Pretext to Seize Power
I have suggested to certain political leaders that they should invite all the Muslim scholars to reform one small city of Pakistan first, and then have the Shariah imposed there. For Instance, Faisalabad is a small city—or a big town—of mainly traders, famous for its corrupt practices. I proposed that the ulema should be invited from all over Pakistan to first reform the society of that single town. When the people of that town have become capable of carrying the burden of Shariah, then the government should be invited to come in and take over the administration of the law of Shariah. But it will not happen. They don’t care. They are not con- cerned. It is not the love of Islam which is urging them on to demand Shariah law. It is just an instrument to reach to power, to capture power and to rule the society in the name of God. Society is already ruled by corrupt people, by cruel people, but that is done in the name of human beings. That is tolerable to a degree, === PDF-Seite 25 === The Relationship Between Religion & Politics 15
but when atrocities are committed in the name of God, it’s the worst possible—the ugliest thing—that can happen to man. So as such, we must think many, many times before we can even begin to ponder over the question whether anywhere in the world, the law of religion can be imposed as a legal tender. Personally, I doubt it. Now, that is where I rest the case for a while. If you think there is time to turn to the second question, then I will do so. Otherwise, we will sit and discuss this—what I have already said. === PDF-Seite 26 === === PDF-Seite 27 === QUESTION & ANSWER Session
After the speech many questions were put to the speaker and below are the answers to some of them. Unfortunately, as will be noticed, some questions were not recorded properly, however the answers do indicate what the question was about.
Question—There is a particular confusion in the Western world about Shariah…
Answer—Thank you for this pointed question. But I thought that such questions were outside the realm of discussion. What we are discussing is whether it is possible to adopt religious law as the law of the country by any state, or any other religion for that matter. I believe it is not possible. It is not possible even if you genuinely and fervently so desire; in the name of God, even then it’s not possible. We have gone so far away from religion. We have become hypocrites. The whole human === PDF-Seite 28 === 18 The Relationship Between Religion & Politics
society has become hypocritical. There is hypocrisy in politics and society everywhere. And hypocrisy does not permit honesty to flourish. It does not permit the word of God to take root. That is the main problem.
Question—I feel that we cannot really apply a law that came for older times to the modern times. Please explain.
Answer—I have studied this question in depth. I believe that religion can be permanent and universal provided its principles are deep-rooted in the human psyche. The human psyche is unchangeable. And that is exactly what the Holy Qur’an claims. It says it is deen-ul-fitrah, meaning a faith or a law based on human nature. And also laa tabdeela li khalqillah, mean- ing that the creation of God and whatever He has created in you, the dispensation, the dispositions, etc. and the basic propensity to do something or not to do so, all these remain the same. Consequently, any law which is rooted in human psy- che, must also be universal and permanent. But, the Holy Qur’an does not stop there. It does not monopolise this truth. It goes on to say that all the religions, at their nas- cent stages and at the stages of their development, were fundamentally the same and they all carried such basic truths as were related to human nature. This is referred to by the Holy Qur’an as deenul-qayyimah. It says there are three fundamental features in every religious teaching: === PDF-Seite 29 === The Relationship Between Religion & Politics 19
Firstly, to mend your relations with God; to be honest and devoted to Him. Secondly, to worship Him. In the sense in the Holy Qur’an, wor- ship does not mean just to pay homage by lip service, but to try to acquire God’s attributes. And thirdly, to do service to mankind and spend in the cause of the needy. These are the three fundamental branches, according to the Holy Qur’an, which are common to all religions. However, with the passage of the time and through inter- polations they were changed later on. So, what is needed is rectification of the change, not a new faith. And that is what has been happening with the advent of every prophet. So, it is a highly complex question and also not directly related to the issue we are discussing. I hope this much should suffice. As far as the question of whether Islamic law, or any other religious law, can be imposed perforce, I say ‘no’ because it is against the spirit of religions themselves! The Holy Qur’an says:
1ۤاَلَهاَرْكِايِفِنْيِّدلا Laa lkraaha fiddeen (al-Baqarah, 2:257)
This is a statement of the Holy Qur’an of course, but it is
1. There should be no compulsion in religion (Surah al-Baqarah, 2:257). [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 30 === 20 The Relationship Between Religion & Politics
a universal statement which can never be changed. It is an example of how laws can become permanent and univer- sal. It says there is no coercion in faith or in matters of faith. No coercion is possible and no coercion is permitted. So, here is the question: If one religion imposes its law on a society where people of other religions and denom- inations also live, how will this verse stand against your attempt to coerce? Not only vis-à-vis the people from other religions, but vis-à-vis people from the same religion who are not willing. So, this is the fundamental question. Therefore the conclusion is that coercion is not an instrument in reli- gion, and certainly not a valid instrument in religion. The only authority in Islam, which was genuinely capable of being given the right to coerce, was the founder of Islam, Prophet Muhammad sa. Why? Because he was a living model of Islam and because when enquired about his character, his holy wife, Hazrat Ayeshah, said he was the living Qur’an. So, the only person who could be genuinely entrusted with the faith of others, and be permitted to use coercion also where he felt that rectification was to be made by force, was the Holy Prophet sa. Yet, addressing him, Allah says in the Holy Qur’an: