Part I
Revelation, Rationality, Knowledge & Truth, Part 22
“Yes, what the inspired poet puts into his poem is a wonderful, god-given thing; but it isn’t knowledge — it can’t be knowledge for it is mindless.’!
His criticism that ‘it is not knowledge — it can’t be knowledge for it is mindless’, is absolutely in accordance with the common practice of poetic expressions. No doubt there is a sort of magic in some poetry as though God were speaking through the poet’s tongue, but a sensible man would not take this too seriously. For Socrates to speak of a poet as ‘god-possessed,’ may also have referred to the Athenians’ superstitious views of people being possessed by ‘gods’. Such expressions are poles apart from the language which Socrates uses for himself. He is never God-possessed but is only addressed by Him as a humble servant of His.
He makes it clear that the poetic experiences which may seem Divine are certainly not so. Whatever their import, they can at best be described as inspiration, not Divine Revelation:
‘I soon perceived that it is not through knowledge that poets produce their poems but through a sort of inborn gift and in a state of inspiration...’'
However, the conclusion drawn by Vlastos from the same passage drives the reader out of his mind, rather than the poet he refers to as being driven ‘out of his mind’:
‘...when the god is in him the poet is “‘out of his mind,” &kopov...’”?
Again he absolves Socrates of irrationality by declaring:
‘Socrates has disarmed the irrationalist potential of the belief in supernatural gods communicating with human beings by supernatural signs.’
We respectfully yet strongly disagree with him when he assumes that the same applied to Socrates’ own experiences. Only two pages after what he has concluded about the nature of the supernatural commands of others, the author has to admit that the God of Socrates was different:
‘Because, as we saw earlier, unlike their gods, Socrates’ god is invariantly good, incapable of causing any evil to anyone in any way at any time. Since to deceive a man is to do evil to him, Socrates’ god cannot be lying.’*
Further, in the same chapter, he rightly attributes a concept of worship to Socrates which was distinctly opposed to the so-called worship of the Athenians. The worship of Athenians according to him was:
‘...an art of commercial exchanges between gods and men.”"
Their worship had to be rebuffed because they, the Athenians, make gods appear dependent on them by whatever is offered at their altar, but the God of Socrates — who is wrongly referred to as “gods” by the author:
‘... stand in no need of gifts from us, while we are totally dependent on their gifts to us...°'
Evidently, Socratic treatment of Athenian worship is with reference to their polytheistic godhead which may be referred to in plural, but it should be remembered here that the word ‘god’, whenever used in plural by Socrates, does not always indicate the Athenian gods which were just a product of their fancy. A careful study of Socrates reveals that by the term ‘gods’, he sometimes refers to angels or any other spiritual form of life above men and under God.
However when he speaks of his own experience, he totally discards the plurality and begins to refer to one God.
‘I believe that no greater good has ever come to you in the city than this service of mine to the god.””
(Note the singleness of God in relation to the mission bestowed to him.)
His religio-political philosophy was always at one with the universal trend of Divine teachings. No prophet of God is recorded in history to have risen in revolt against the law of the land, but when the state interfered with his obedience to God, he unhesitatingly rejected the state power without fear and followed the dictates of God.
The same was the philosophy of Socrates. He was absolutely loyal to the state but when loyalty to the state contradicted his loyalty to God, the only conclusion he drew for himself was to discard the lesser loyalty for the sake of the higher one which was due only to the Creator. Addressing the senate which was about to convict him to death, he spoke of this with unperturbed composure and dignity:
‘... Men of Athens, I honor and love you; but I shall
obey God rather than you, and while I have life and
strength I shall never cease from the practice and
teaching of philosophy ...’
(Note that Jowett always writes ‘God’ with a capital ‘G’ when he relates Him to Socrates.)