A Review of the Debate between Batalavi and Chakrhalavi
Maulavi Abu Sa‘id Muhammad Hussain Batalavi and Maulavi ‘Abdullah Chakrhalavi by the Promised Messiah, the Divine Arbiter, and a Word of Advice for his Community Judging from the writings of the two parties involved, it appears that the basis for the aforementioned debate was Maulavi ‘Abdullah’s contention that the hadith of the Holy Prophet (saw) ought to be discarded entirely. Similarly, he was guilty of such foul utterances that even to mention them is disrespectful. Conversely, Maulavi Muhammad Hussain articulated the proposition that if the hadith were considered to be so worthless, inauthentic and unreliable, then the vast majority of [Islamic modes of ] worship and fiqah [Islamic Jurisprudence] would be rendered invalid, for it is the hadith alone that shed light on the precise details of the commandments of the Holy Qur’an. If the Holy Qur’an is considered sufficient what evidence from the Holy Qur’an alone can be furnished to support that the obligatory morning prayer consists of two rak‘at, maghrib [prayer] comprises three and the remaining three [prayers] compose of four rak‘at each.
Although inherently flawed, this rebuttal was still overpowering and this is why ‘Abdullah Sahib was unable to provide any satisfying reply and only responded with absurdities which are not even worth mentioning. However, the objection raised by Maulavi Muhammad Hussain Batalvi consequently forced ‘Abdullah Sahib to invent a new form of salat which was completely incongruous with anything practiced by all the sects of Islam. He removed the attahiyyat , durud and other customary prayers of the Holy Prophet (saw) from the salat and only verses in the Holy Qur’an were incorporated in their stead. He further proposed numerous other innovations in the salat which need not be mentioned here, and perhaps he even sought to ordain changes in the practices of the hajj and zakat. Is it true that the hadith are really as worthless and futile as Maulavi ‘Abdullah Sahib suggests. God forbid, not at all.
The fact of the matter is that of the two parties, both have verged on opposite extremes. Firstly, Maulavi Muhammad Hussain is correct in enunciating the argument that authentic hadith which can be traced back to the Holy Prophet (saw) cannot be rejected absolutely. In his unmindfulness of the demands of etiquette, he has placed the hadith on a pedestal so lofty that is perforce an affront to the Holy Qur’an and one is forced to reject its truth. He gives little thought to whether the position he has endorsed puts him at odds with the Holy Qur’an; for he has given precedence to the narrations of the hadith over the clear accounts of Allah’s Book and believes that these narratives are superior to the Word of Allah. Allah Almighty says in the Holy Qur’an:
That is, what word will they believe in after [rejecting] the word of Allah and His signs. In this verse, the word hadith is used in the singular and generic form to establish that any type of tradition or discourse which contradicts and opposes the Holy Qur’an and cannot be reconciled with its teachings ought to be rejected. The verse is also a prophecy for it alludes to the future fate of the ummah, amongst whom some would neglect the Holy Qur’an in favour of conflicting hadith. Thus, the Ahl-e-Hadith tilt towards an extreme position in emphasizing the hadith over the testimony of the Holy Qur’an. If they had remained just and God-fearing, they could have easily reconciled the hadith with the Holy Qur’an.
Instead, they have come to gladly reject and discard the absolute and infallible Word of God, but cannot bring themselves to either deny those hadith which contradict it or seek to understand them in light of God’s Book. This is the extreme viewpoint of Maulavi Muhammad Hussain.
Meanwhile, his opponent, Maulavi ‘Abdullah Sahib, has positioned himself on the other extreme and rejects the hadith in its entirety. In one sense this is tantamount to rejecting the Holy Qur’an itself for Allah the Exalted says:
Thus, since the love of God is linked with following the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and the hadith are also a means by which the practical example of the Holy Prophet can be known, an individual who rejects the hadith also rejects a modality of following him. Maulavi ‘Abdullah Sahib states that all the hadith are tainted by doubt and suspicion. However, this notion has come about due to a lack of reflection. The root cause of this view is the flawed and deficient manner in which hadith scholars have prioritized [the scriptural texts].
Their tendency to ascribe greater authority to the hadith than the Holy Qur’an has led many people astray. According to this perspective, they believe that both the book of Allah and the hadith are on hand when needed. They go on to suggest that the latter stands as an authority over the former, as if the hadith is a judge seated upon the bench and the book of Allah stands at its behest as a plaintiff in its court. Anyone could be mislead by such a view. After all, it was approximately one hundred to one hundred and fifty years after the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, that the hadith were collected and they are not free from human interpolation.
Further, the hadith are victim to doubt and conjecture and are comprised of so few narrations which may be deemed highly authentic that almost no reliable narrations exist at all. Hence, if the hadith were considered a judge over the Holy Qur’an this would inevitably mean that Islam is nothing more than a heap of conjecture and obviously mere suppositions are of no value. An individual who follows mere conjecture is far below the elevated station of truth.
Allah the Exalted says:
That is, mere conjecture is incomparable with absolute certainty. Hence, this would necessarily imply that the entire text of the Holy Qur’an is useless and obsolete and it is not worthy of following without the edicts of a judge, that is to say the hadith. Yet the hadith themselves are ill-clad in the garb of conjecture and are not completely free from falsehood. For the naturally inherent aspect of conjecture is that it is never truly free from fabrication. In this way, not only does one have to dispense with the Holy Qur’an, one is also unable to adequately rely on the hadith.
Both sources are thus rendered suspect. Such error has been the ruin of many.
I have penned this treatise in order to reveal the right path. Muslims have at their disposal three means by which they can establish themselves on the teachings of Islam.
(I.) The Holy Qur’an: the Book of God and there is no word available to us which is as absolute and certain. It is the Word of God and untainted by doubt and speculation.
(II.) Second is the sunnah: Here I differ from the Ahl-e-Hadith with regard to their application of the term for in my estimation the hadith and sunnah are not one and the same thing as is held by traditional scholars of hadith. As a matter of fact, the hadith and sunnah are two separate things. By sunnah I refer only to those actions of the Holy Prophet (saw) which possess continuity and go
and perhaps only a couple of lines remained, I was overcome by sleep. Thus, I had no choice but to put away my pen and sleep. In my dream I saw Maulavi Muhammad Hussain Batalavi and Maulavi ‘Abdullah Chakrhalavi. Addressing both of them, I said: , which means, the moon and the sun have already been eclipsed in the month of Ramadan, then why do you both gentlemen deny the favour of your Lord. I then said to Akhwim Maulavi ‘Abdul-Karim in my dream: ‘The favour’ in this context means me. Then I looked up at a veranda where a lamp was burning as if it was night time, and some people were copying this revelation from the Holy Qur’an with the help of the lamp, and I had a feeling that this revelation was to be found in the Holy Qur’an in the sequence just mentioned. I recognized one of those people to be Miyań Nabi Bakhsh darner of Amritsar. (Author)