A Review of the Debate between Batalavi and Chakrhalavi
Part 2
hand in hand with the revelation of the Holy Qur’an. They shall always be preserved until the end of time. In other words, it may be said that the Holy Qur’an is the Word of God Almighty and the sunnah is the practice of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.
Since the remotest ages, it has been the practice of Allah that when the Prophets, peace be on them, communicate His Word to mankind for its guidance, they also illustrate it through their conduct and practical example, so that the people are able to comprehend it more clearly. Thus, the Prophets not only follow the Word [of God] themselves but exhort others to do the same.
(III.) The third source of guidance is the hadith, by which I mean those traditions that were related in the form of anecdotes by various narrators and were later collected and compiled approximately a hundred and fifty years after the life of the Holy Prophet (saw). Thus, the difference between the sunnah and the hadith is that the former refers to the practical example of the Holy Prophet (saw) which was demonstrated by him and which possessed continuity. In terms of its authenticity, the sunnah is second only to the Holy Qur’an. Just as the Holy Prophet (saw) was raised to propagate [the teachings] of the Holy Qur’an, he was also commissioned with establishing the sunnah. Therefore, just as the Holy Qur’an is absolute, so too is the established practice known as the sunnah. Both these tasks were personally discharged by the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and he considered himself duty-bound to fulfil both. For example, when the obligatory prayers were enjoined, the Holy Prophet (saw) demonstrated this commandment of God Almighty and illustrated through his practice the number of rak‘at for fajr, maghrib and all the other Prayers as well. He also demonstrated the hajj and taught this practice to thousands from among his Companions, thereby ensuring its continuity. As such, this practical example [of the Holy Prophet (saw)] which is clearly evident in the ummah even until now, is known as the sunnah. Conversely, the Holy Prophet (saw) did not have the hadith recorded in his own presence nor did he make any provisions for their compilation. Some hadith were collected by Hadrat Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, but on account of his fear of God, he had all these hadith burned because he was not a witness to them himself and therefore could not be certain of their truth. When the age of the Companions, Allah be pleased with them, passed, God inspired the taba‘ tabi‘in with the desire to collect the hadith, and it was then that these narrations were gathered.
There is no doubt that a majority of the compilers of the hadith were righteous and God-fearing, and insofar as was within their ability they critiqued [the accuracy of ] narrations; they rejected those which they felt were inauthentic and refused to accept narrations from any narrator of questionable character. Despite their superb efforts, this pursuit was undertaken many years after [the life of the Holy Prophet (saw)] and was therefore heavily subject to speculation. Yet, in spite of all this, it would be most unfair to suggest that all of the hadith are unworthy, inauthentic, useless and false. For such immense caution has been exercised in recording the hadith and such a phenomenal effort has been expended in critiquing and evaluating this corpus as is unparalleled in the history of religion. The Jews also had their own anecdotal records, and the Jewish sect that opposed Jesus was particularly known for adhering to them, but there is no evidence to suggest that Jewish scholars exercised the same diligence in collecting them as their Muslim counterparts.
It would be incorrect to think that until the hadith were compiled, people were unaware of the [number of ] rak‘at in the obligatory Prayers or the rites of hajj. For the sunnah, which had taken root in them through a method of practice, had to all intents and purposes, taught every obligation and injunction laid down by Islam. Therefore, it is absolutely correct to state that if the hadith which were collected well after [the Holy Prophet (saw)] had never even surfaced, there would be no deficiency in the fundamental teachings of Islam, for they had already been fully established by the Holy Qur’an and through a system of practice. The hadith served only to enhance this light, illuminating Islam as though it were
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[light upon light]. Further, the hadith came forth and testified to the truth of the Holy Qur’an and sunnah. After Islam split into numerous sects, those among them who were truthful derived great benefit from authentic hadith.
Hence, a most appropriate view is that while one should abstain from the belief that where narratives of hadith clearly contradict those of the Holy Qur’an such narratives should be given preference and the Holy Qur’an should be abandoned, as is held by the Ahl-e-Hadith of the age, by the same token one should not consider the hadith worthless and of no value as is held by Maulavi ‘Abdullah Chakrhalavi. Rather, the Holy Qur’an and sunnah should be considered to possess authority over the hadith. However, it is also true that those hadith which do not contradict the Holy Qur’an ought to be followed with heart and soul, for this is the right path. Blessed are those who follow this way, and most unfortunate and ignorant is the one who does not follow this principle and denies the hadith.
It is incumbent on my Jama‘at to follow any hadith which does not oppose and contradict the Holy Qur’an and sunnah, regardless of its authenticity and give preference to it over manmade jurisprudence. And if they are unable to find [elaboration on] a certain matter from the hadith, the sunnah or from the
delicious and beautiful fruits, and that some people were trying to train a creeper onto the tree. The creeper had no root and simply appeared to be attached to the tree, like a parasite. As the creeper spread on the tree, it damaged its fruits and the tree was losing its beauty and becoming unattractive. Some of its expected fruits were likely to be lost and some had even been ruined. My heart was greatly moved and troubled by this and I asked a good and holy man who was standing near: What tree is this and what kind of a creeper has taken such a nice tree into its grip. He answered: This tree is the Holy Qur’an, the Word of God, and this creeper is symbolic for those hadith and commentaries which are opposed to the Holy Qur’an or are believed to contradict it. The largeness of their number has the tree in its grip and is damaging it. Then I woke up. I have been writing this treatise since that moment, which was the night just gone, and I am nearing the end. It is now late into the small hours of Saturday night and the clock has just struck forty minutes past one. [And all praise belongs to Allah for this]. M.G.A. [Author]
Holy Qur’an, in such a case, they should follow the Hanafi school of jurisprudence, because this school constitutes the majority [among the Muslims] and this is an indication of God’s will. If, because of modern developments, the Hanafi school of jurisprudence is unable to provide an adequate judgement, the scholars of the community ought to determine such issues in accordance with their God-given reasoning. However, at the same time they must exercise caution, lest they unjustly denounce the hadith like Maulavi ‘Abdullah Chakrhalavi. Nonetheless, they ought to reject any such hadith which is at variance with the Holy Qur’an and sunnah. Bear in mind that our Jama‘at is closer to [the doctrines] of the Ahl-e-Hadith and has no relation whatsoever with the absurd ideas of ‘Abdullah Chakrhalavi. Everyone who is from among my Jama‘at ought to view his doctrines regarding the hadith, with a deep sense of aversion and revulsion.
Wherever possible they ought to eschew the company of such persons, for this sect is far more misguided than others. My Jama‘at should neither overly emphasize the hadith, like those who belong to the class of Maulavi Muhammad Hussain, nor should they reject them completely like ‘Abdullah. Rather, they ought to adopt a middle way as their guiding principle. That is to say, they ought not to consider the hadith the final authority on all matters of religion, and reject and abandon the Holy Qur’an. Nor should they consider the hadith redundant and worthless to the point that all the traditions of the Holy Prophet (saw) are laid to waste. In similar vein, they ought not to deny the Khatm-e-Nubuwwat [finality of the prophethood] of the Holy Prophet (saw), nor interpret it in a way that would close the door of divine discourse and revelation on the ummah. Remember, our belief is that the Holy Qur’an is the Final Book and the Final Law, and until the Day of Judgment, no Prophet can appear who brings a new law or who receives revelation without having followed the Holy Prophet (saw). In fact, this door is firmly closed until the end of time; however, the door to revelation received through obedience to the Holy Prophet (saw) is open until the Day of Judgement. That revelation which is the result of following the Holy Prophet (saw) can never be terminated. But law-bearing or independent Prophethood has now come to an end.
To further explain, where God Almighty has revealed that the Holy Prophet (saw) is Khatamul-Anbiya’, [the Seal of the Prophets] He has also indicated that he is the spiritual father of those who are righteous and only by following him can they achieve self-fulfilment and be blessed with divine discourse and revelation. For, in the Holy Qur’an God Almighty says:
That is, the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is not the father of any of your men, but he is the Messenger of Allah and Khatamul-Anbiya’. Quite clearly the Arabic word lakin is applied here as an adversative particle or to compensate for what has been expressed in the previous clause. In the first part of this verse the fact of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, physically fathering any male offspring is negated and the word lakin compensates this negative clause with the declaration that the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is Khatamul-Anbiya’. This means that after him the blessings of independent Prophethood would be terminated, and henceforth the excellence of Prophethood would only be bestowed on such a person whose deeds were testified to by the seal of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and this person would thus become his spiritual son and heir. Hence, where the fact of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, being the physical father of [male]