Surah 26: Ash-Shu'ara
The Holy Qur’an with English Translation and Short Commentary, Part 2
He said, ‘My Lord. [a]I fear that they will reject me;
[a] 20:46; 28:35.
‘And my breast is straitened[2098] [b]and my tongue is not fluent; so [c]send word to Aaron also;
[2098] Moses seemed to feel that he was not quite equal to the great task with which he was being entrusted. The responsibilities of Prophethood are indeed very heavy. At the time of the first revelation the Holy Prophet himself felt overwhelmed with anxiety.
[b] 20:28.
[c] 28:25, 20:30-33.
[d]‘And they have a charge[2099] against me, so I fear that they will kill me.’
[d] 28:34.
[2099] The words show that the people of Pharaoh had charged Moses with the murder of an Egyptian. This incident is mentioned in Exod. 2: 11-15 and also in the Holy Qur’an in 28:16-21, where it is stated that it was not intentional or deliberate murder. Moses was defending an Israelite whom an Egyptian was beating and in the scuffle the latter happened to be killed.
[e]God said, ‘That shall not be, go both of you with Our Signs; We are with you hearing your prayers.’
[e] 28:36.
‘So go to Pharaoh and say, “We are the Messengers[2100] of the Lord of the worlds,
[2100] The word Rasul in the verse is in the singular while the subject inna and the verbs used are in dual. In Arabic, it is permissible sometimes to use the singular predicate for a subject in the dual or plural number (Bayan). See also 26:78.
‘To tell thee to send the Children of Israel with us.”
Pharaoh said, ‘O Moses, did we not bring thee up among us as a child? And thou didst stay among us many years of thy life;
‘And thou didst do that deed which thou didst, and thou art one of the ungrateful.’[2101]
[2101] The reference in the verse seems to be to an Egyptian having been killed by Moses. Pharaoh regards himself and his people, the Egyptians, as the great benefactors of the Israelites and accuses Moses of gross ingratitude for having killed an Egyptian.
Moses said, ‘I did it then inadvertently, and I was in a perplexed state of mind;[2102]
[2102] Dall is derived from Dalla which means, he did not know what to do; he was in a perplexed state of mind; he was lost in love (Lane). When the Israelite called him for help against the Egyptian, Moses did not know what to do, and being anxious to help the poor, helpless Israelite (28:16-21) gave the Egyptian a blow with his closed fist which caused his death. The death was accidental because ordinarily a blow with the fist does not cause the death of a person. Or the verse may mean that on account of his great love for his oppressed people he came to the help of the Israelite and gave a blow to the Egyptian, which resulted in his death. Or it means that he did it being unaware of the consequences.
[a]‘So I fled from you when I feared you; then my Lord granted me right judgment and made me one of the Messengers.[2103]
[a] 28:22.
[2103] The fact that after he had killed the Egyptian and fled. God made him a Prophet—a great Divine favour indeed—is proof positive of the fact that what Moses did was an inadvertent act done on the spur of the moment.
‘And this favour of bringing me up as a child with which thou now tauntest me, dost thou put forward against thy having enslaved the Children of Israel?’[2104]
[2104] To Pharaoh’s impudent remark, Moses is described as saying to him that he himself should be ashamed of referring to any good that he thinks he had done to his (Moses’s) people as he (Pharaoh) had kept them for generations under the most debasing and degrading form of bondage which had killed in them all sense of dignity, initiative and ambition to rise to their full stature.
Pharaoh said, [a]‘And what is the Lord of the worlds?’[2105]
[a] 20:50.
[2105] Moses’s reply to Pharaoh, as mentioned in the preceding verse, seemed to have utterly confounded him and he at once changed the subject, seeking to involve Moses in a metaphysical discussion about the existence and person of the Divine Being and the nature of His attributes.