The Promised Messiah
Testimony of the Holy Qur’an
A gentleman named ‘Ata Muhammad enquires of me through his letter, published in August 1893, as to what is the proof of my being the Promised Messiah and whether we are obliged and duty-bound to wait for any messiah.
In this context, we must first bear in mind that the critic holds the belief that Hadrat ‘Isa [ Jesus], peace be upon him, has indeed died, as is mentioned clearly in the Holy Qur’an. But he denies that someone bearing the name of ‘Isa will appear in this ummah. He accepts that ahadith [pl. hadith] do, indeed, record this prophecy, but considers the reports of such ahadith to be unreliable. He argues that the ahadith were collected after a long period and most of them are ahad [solitary traditions, not supported by others] therefore, they lack certainty. That is why he does not regard the prophecy about the Promised Messiah, which is confirmed by ahadith, as an established fact. In his view, prophecies based on ahadith alone are worthless and unfounded and, therefore, cannot qualify as substantial proof. So, it seems necessary that I answer his queries in keeping with his way of thinking. Let it be clear that in this matter there are three issues calling for investigation:
First: Whether the prophecy regarding the advent of the
Promised Messiah, which is recorded in the ahadith, is unreliable because the accounts of ahadith are far from and entirely outside the level of certainty;
Second: Whether or not this prophecy finds any mention in
the Holy Qur’an;
Third: If this prophecy is a proven fact, what proof, then, is there that it has been fulfilled in the person of my hum-
Let me begin with addressing the first of these three issues. Let it be clear that no one denies that the ahadith contain an explicit prophecy about the Promised Messiah. Rather, there is a consensus among almost all the Muslims that, as per ahadith, a person is sure to come who will be named ‘Isa ibn Maryam [ Jesus Son of Mary]. And this prophecy finds such repeated mention in the books of Hadith—Bukhari, Muslim, Tirmidhi, etc.—that it is enough to satisfy a fair-minded person and compels us to believe in their common theme that a Promised Messiah is to come. It is true that most such ahadith, taken individually, are no more than ahad, yet it cannot be denied that all the ahadith, assembled from various sources regarding this issue, when collectively examined, establish categorically and conclusively that the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, has certainly prophesied the advent of the Promised Messiah. Moreover, when we read the ahadith possessed by Ahl-e-Sunnat wal-Jama‘at, along with those ahadith on which other sects of Islam, such as Shias, rely, the strength of such ahadith having tawatur [multiple narrators] is even more firmly established. Additionally, hundreds of books of the sufis also testify to this fact. And when we consult the literature of the People of the Book, that is, the Christians, we find this prophecy in their books as well.
The verdict of Hadrat Masih as [ Jesus] in the Gospels regarding the descent of Ilyas [Elijah] from heaven demonstrates that such prophecies can never be taken literally. However, the prophecy about the advent of the Promised Messiah appears so extensively in every age that it would be gross ignorance to deny that it possesses tawatur. I say truthfully that if all Islamic books in which this prophecy is recorded were to be collected in chronological order, their number would definitely run into the thousands. But it is difficult to make someone understand who is unfamiliar with the corpus of Islamic literature. In fact, such critics are unfortunately so ignorant that they simply do not understand how strongly and forcefully the veracity of a certain event is established.
This critic simply heard from someone that most of the ahadith are at the level of ahad and he has immediately concluded that, with the exception of the Holy Qur’an, all other authorities in Islam are baseless and doubtful and are completely devoid of certainty and conclusiveness. But in reality, this is a great mistake, the first result of which is to destroy faith and religion. If it were true that with the exception of the Holy Qur’an all other documentary sources are a bundle of falsehood, imposture, deceit, conjectures, and imagination, then, perhaps only a little would be left of Islam; for all the details of our Faith have come down to us through the ahadith of the Holy Prophet s (as). For example, the requirement of the formal Prayer—which we offer five times a day—is established by the Holy Qur’an, but nowhere does the Holy Qur’an lay down that the morning Prayer comprises two obligatory rak‘at [units of Prayer] and two rak‘at of sunnah; Dhuhr [Prayer] comprises four rak‘at of fard and four and two rak‘at of sunnah; Maghrib [Prayer]comprises three rak‘at of fard; and ‘Isha’ [Prayer] comprises four rak‘at. In the same way, we have to depend entirely upon ahadith to learn the details of zakat.
Moreover, there are thousands of details relating to worship, dealings, covenants, and so on; they are so well known that writing about them would be a waste of time and needless prolongation. Besides, the primary and principal source of Islamic history is ahadith. If the reports contained in ahadith are not relied upon, then we should also not take it as certain that Hadrat Abu Bakr, Hadrat ‘Umar, Hadrat Uthman, and Hadrat ‘Ali , may Allah be pleased with them, were the Companions of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, who became the Khulafa’ [successors] of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, in this order and also died in this order. If the accounts related by ahadith are not trusted, there would be no reason to believe with certainty in the existence of these great personalities. It might be possible to infer that all these names are fictitious and that there was no Abu Bakr, no ‘Umar, no Uthman, and no Ali; for, according to our critic, Miyan Ata Muhammad, all these ahadith are ahad and the Holy Qur’an nowhere mentions these names, so how can these ahadith be considered authentic in light of this principle.
In the same way, shall we deny that the name of the father of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, was ‘Abdullah, and his mother’s name was Aminah; and the name of his grandfather was ‘Abdul Muttalib and one of his wives was named Khadijah and another ‘A’ishah, and another Hafsah, may Allah be pleased with them; and that the name of his wet-nurse was Halimah; and that the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be on him, used to withdraw to the Cave of Hira for worship; and that some of his Companions migrated to Abyssinia; and that for ten years after his advent, the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, resided in Makkah. Moreover, there were all those battles that the Noble Qur’an does not even mention. All these matters are established by ahadith alone. Can we deny the occurrence of all these events on the alleged basis that ahadith amount to nothing?
Were that so, it would not be possible for the Muslims to relate any portion of the biography of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. It should be observed that the events of the life of our lord and master, the kind of life he led in Makkah before his advent, the year he called people to his Prophethood, the order in which people embraced Islam, how the disbelievers persecuted them in the ten years in Makkah, how and why battles began, and in which of them the blessed person of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, himself took part, and to which regions the rule of Islam had extended in the lifetime of his holy and honoured personage, and whether the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be on him, addressed letters to the rulers of the time, inviting them to Islam, and if he did so, what was the result, and after the death of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be on him, what were the victories achieved during the time of Hadrat Abu Bakr Siddiq, and what difficulties came about, and in the time of Hadrat [‘Umar] Faruq which countries did Islam achieve conquests—all these matters are known only through ahadith and the statements of the Companions. Hence, if ahadith amount to nothing, it would not just be difficult, but rather quite impossible, to learn of the events of that time, and in such a case the opponents of Islam would be free to invent whatever lies they like concerning the events of the life of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and of the lives of his Companions, may Allah be pleased with them. We would thus provide to the enemies of Islam a great opportunity to make baseless attacks against Islam, and we would have to admit that all the events and incidents related in ahadith are baseless and imaginary, so much so that even the names of the Companions are not known with certainty. To suppose that we cannot derive any certain and conclusive truth from ahadith amounts to destroying a great portion of Islam with our own hands.
The true and correct position is that it is necessary to accept what is stated in the ahadith unless the Holy Qur’an contradicts it in clear and explicit terms. For, it is established that it is natural for man to tell the truth and that he resorts to falsehood under some compulsion, for falsehood is unnatural for him. Therefore, doubting the conclusiveness and reliability of those ahadith that had—through becoming a consistent practice or collective belief—developed into a characteristic of different groups of Muslims, is really a type of insanity and madness. For instance, if anyone were to contend that the number of rak‘at the Muslims perform in the five daily prayers is a doubtful matter, inasmuch as there is no verse in the Holy Qur’an prescribing two rak‘at for the morning Prayer and two for Jumu‘ah, and two each for the two Eid prayers, and that most ahadith are ahad and thus unreliable, would such a one be in the right? If such views were accepted about the ahadith, then the first thing to be lost would be prayer itself, for the Holy Qur’an has nowhere prescribed the method of offering prayers; rather, they are offered only on the basis of our reliance that the [relevant] ahadith are correct.
Now, if an opponent raises the objection that the Holy Qur’an does not teach how to offer prayer and the way the Muslims have adopted for offering prayer is to be rejected because the ahadith are unreliable—and if we, too, adhere to the same principle, that the ahadith are worthless—how could we respond to this objection, except to accept it? Indeed in such a case, Islam’s funeral prayer would also become utterly futile, because nowhere does the Holy Qur’an mention any prayer without prostration and bowing. Now ponder and see what is left of Islam if the ahadith are discarded.
Besides, the very notion that the sayings of the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, are considered authentic merely because of the supposed authenticity of the reports of one or two narrators is a matter resulting from a lack of reflection. The fact is that the ahadith constitute a branch of the ta‘amul [continued practice] and were collected and compiled after those practices became established. For example, the muhaddithin [hadith scholars] observed that millions of people offer three rak‘at of fard in Maghrib, and two in Fajr, and always recite Surah al-Fatihah in every rak‘at, and say amin either loudly or silently. Likewise, they observed them offering [supplications like] at-tahiyyat, durud, and many prayers in the last sitting position, and concluding their Prayer by offering salam to their right and left. Seeing this manner of worship, the muhaddithin became eager and interested to verify this matter by tracing this method of prayer back to the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be on him and to confirm it through ahadith that are sahih [authentic], and marfu‘ and muttasil [i.e. whose chains of narration reach up to the Holy Prophet s (as) and are uninterrupted].
It is true that the muhaddithin have not provided chains of a thousand or two thousand narrators for every single hadith. But would it be right to assume that it was the muhaddithin who established prayer in the first place, and before them people did not offer prayer and were totally unaware of it, and that it was only after many centuries that people, relying on one or two ahadith, began to offer prayer? Hence, I declare emphatically that it would be a grave misconception to believe that the manner and rak‘at of prayer were proven solely on the basis of a handful of ahadith that appear to be ahad. If that were to be true, then, first of all, Islamic observances would suffer an irremediable setback—which would be of grave concern for any Muslim with a sense of honour. But remember that only those people labour under such misconceptions who have never attentively studied Islamic chronicles, history, traditions, rites, and worship, and who are unaware of how and with what process these matters were authenticated.