The Promised Messiah
Testimony of the Holy Qur’an, Part 2
Let it be clear that the continuous practice of people establishes the certainty of these matters with utmost satisfaction. For example, let us suppose that there are only two or three such ahadith which relate that the number of rak‘at in the Fajr Prayer is X and the rak‘at in the Maghrib prayer is Y, and it is granted that these ahadith are no more than ahad. Now, did the people not offer the prayer prior to this research and investigation? Was it only after authenticating the ahadith and learning of their narrators that the daily prayers were initiated? Nay, millions of people offered prayer in the prescribed way. Let us assume that the study of the chain of narrators of ahadith had not even existed, even then the continuous practice would definitively and categorically have established that Islamic teachings regarding prayer has remained the same generation after generation, and century after century. The existence of uninterrupted chains of narrators culminating with the Holy Prophet s (as) serves to reinforce the continuous practice. In light of this principle, it would be an egregious mistake to pronounce most of the ahadith—which are corroborated and supported by the chain of continuous practice—as no better than ahad.
As a matter of fact, this is the egregious mistake that has drawn the followers of nature in this age far away from Islam. They imagine that all Islamic practices, ceremonies, worship, biographies, and histories—which cite ahadith as references—are established only on the basis of a few ahadith. But this is a clear error on their part. The ta‘amul [continuous practice] that our Holy Prophet s (as) established through his personal example had become so common among millions of people that had there been no trace or mention of the compilers of ahadith, even then no harm would have come to it.
Everyone has to admit that the Holy Teacher and Messenger, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, had not so confined his teaching as to train only a few people in it and to leave all others unaware of it. Had that been so, Islam would have been so corrupted that it could not have been reformed through the efforts of any muhaddith etc. Granted that the Imams of Hadith compiled thousands of ahadith relating to religious instruction, but the question is, what hadith is there that was not already being acted upon, and of which the world was wholly unaware, prior to their having written it down. If there is any teaching, or event, or doctrine, the foundation of which has been laid only by the Imams of Hadith on the basis of some report, and no sign of it is discoverable from continuous practice—of which millions of people are convinced—nor is it mentioned in the Holy Qur’an, then, without doubt, such a solitary report that became known a century or a century-and-a-half later, would be far removed from a level of certainty, and would deserve whatever condemnation might be directed at it. However, in reality, such ahadith have no great connection to the religion or history of Islam. If you study carefully, you will find that the Imams of Hadith have very seldom mentioned those ahadith for which no trace or mention is found in continuous practice. It is, therefore, absolutely wrong, as some ignorant ones imagine, that the world has learnt of hundreds of matters relating to the religion, even fasting and prayer services, only from the ahadith compiled by Imam Bukhari and Muslim and others. Were the Muslims without faith for a century or a century-and-a-half ? Did they not offer the daily Prayers? Did they not pay zakat? Did they not perform the hajj? Were they unaware of all the matters pertaining to Islamic doctrines mentioned in the ahadith? Certainly not! Never!
The ignorance of any person who entertains such a thought is beyond belief. Islam was as verdant and thriving before the era of the Imams of Hadith—namely Bukhari, Muslim, etc.—as it was after their compilations; therefore, how unreasonable and unfair is it to believe dogmatically that Islam flourished only on the basis of what is known today as ahadith, which were compiled in the second century. It is a pity that not only opponents but also ignorant Muslims labour under the misconception that the Muslims were made to believe in many matters pertaining to Islam after a long time through the reports of ahadith; and that they were utterly unaware about them before those compilations.
On the contrary, the plain truth is that if the Imams of Hadith have done any favour to the people, it is only that they researched and investigated the chain of narrators to confirm the continuous practice that a world of people accepted since the beginning. They demonstrated that the beliefs and practices of the Muslims of their time were not innovations that were later intermixed with Islamic teachings; rather, they were the same practice and verbal teaching that the Holy Prophet s (as) imparted to his Companions, may Allah be pleased with them.
It is a pity that, by misconstruing this correct and factual matter, short-sighted people fell prey to an egregious error, due to which they have intensely looked down upon ahadith to this day. True, those ahadith that are outside the chain of oral tradition or practices, or which the Holy Qur’an does not verify, cannot be considered completely authentic. But how can the authenticity of those ahadith that have always been sustained and preserved in the continuous practice of millions of people from the very beginning, be held in suspicion and doubt? The authenticity of such ahadith cannot be doubted at all, for the overwhelming majority put them into practice and were known from generation to generation and were clearly traceable to their original source. In fact, one cannot help but consider this continued practice to be amongst the most established truths. Moreover, the Imams of Hadith buttressed this continued practice by establishing another practice, whereby they traced the chain of truthful and righteous narrators right up to the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. So, to criticize it now is the work of only those who totally lack the insight of faith and human rationality.
After this preamble, let it also be clear that the prophecy regarding the advent of the Promised Messiah is not such as was recorded by the Imams of Hadith on the basis of only a few riwayat [reports]. Rather, it has been established that the Muslims adopted this prophecy as part and parcel of their faith since the early days. In other words, there were as many testimonies to the validity of this prophecy as were the number of Muslims at that time, as right from the beginning they regarded the prophecy as part of their faith.
If the Imams of Hadith, such as Imam Bukhari and others, discovered anything about this prophecy by their own effort, it is only that—when they found this prophecy widespread and oft-mentioned among millions of Muslims—they, according to their practice, searched for and provided the traditional isnad [chains of narrators] of this well-established saying and supported it with riwayat [reports] that were sahih, marfu‘, and muttasil, and which are found abundantly in their books. Besides, there seems to be no plausible reason for why, if—God forbid—it were a fabrication, the Muslims had any need for it, why they came to a consensus about it, and what compelled them to fabricate all this? On the other hand, we also see that there are many such ahadith as contain the prophecy that in the Latter Days, the ulema of this ummah will resemble the Jews, and become devoid of integrity, fear of God, and inner purity, and at that time the religion of the cross will have gained ascendancy in the world and the authority and rule of the Christian religion will have spread nearly all over the world. The fact that all these prophecies have undoubtedly been fulfilled in this age proves the authenticity of these ahadith even more clearly. Indeed, in this age, these ‘ulema’ of ours have become like the Jews and the dominion and the rule of the Christians has spread in the world today in a manner without any precedent in history. Since one part of this prophecy has been fulfilled so clearly and manifestly, why should the authenticity of the other part be called into question. Every sane person agrees that even if a hadith is ahad and has not been widely acknowledged but contains a prophecy that is fully or partly fulfilled at its appointed time, there remains no doubt about the authenticity of such a hadith. For example, the hadith recorded in Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih al-Muslim that a fire will break out in the Hejaz is undoubtedly among the ahad. But after the passing of nearly 600 years, this prophecy was fulfilled clearly, and even the British admit it. This prophecy was fulfilled hundreds of years after the compilation and publication of the books in which it was recorded. Can we now declare such ahadith to be absolutely unacceptable on account of their being ahad? It is extremely vile and abhorrent ignorance to entertain such a thought after the authenticity of such ahadith has been established so clearly.
Think about the prophecy regarding the Promised Messiah in the same way. Its wording states—at places explicitly, and at other places implicitly—that the Promised Messiah will appear at a time when the rule and power of the Christians will have spread over the entire world and railway trains will be running. Moreover, most of the land will have come under cultivation, people will take keen interest in agriculture so much so that the oxen would become expensive, and there will be an abundance of canals in the world, and in terms of worldly life, it will be the time of peace.
We now find that this prophecy has been fulfilled in our time, for the Christian empire has reached such a height as if all other regimes and states are non-existent before it, and we have witnessed with our own eyes the emergence of trains, canals and widespread agriculture.
Think about it! Does not this prophecy contain such news regarding the unseen as transcends human power? Could anyone imagine the present decadent state of Islam at a time when the Islamic sword was striking the disbelievers like lightening? Can any human being possess such knowledge of the unseen as would predict a new form of transport which was previously non-existent? Look around and reflect! Is this prophecy not one of those grand prophecies whose reality and fulfilment could be encompassed only by the knowledge of God Almighty, and which cannot be suspected to be the work of human artifice and poor designs of the creatures?
Let it be clear that there is a whole series of such prophecies as are characterized by perfect order and exceptional eloquence and contain subtle and fine points, and matters related to the unseen and whose magnificence cannot be equalled by any human being at all. For instance, first, there are prophecies about the time of Islam’s progress in connection with which it was foretold that Chosroes will perish and there will be no Chosroes after him; and that Caesar will perish and there will be no Caesar after him. And Islam would thrive, flourish, and spread to every nation.