Foreword – Glossary 33
The Truth About Salvation, Part 2
Christian preachers strive to draw people towards salvation with all the force at their disposal, whereas the Holy Qur’an says:
Those who follow the commandments of Islam are among the rightly guided who thrive in all the distinct stages of spirituality. Moreover, they are the ones who achieve their goals and aspirations. They occupy a status which is beyond that of a mere release from sorrow. It is true that Christianity also speaks of the attainment of pleasure, but it is not accorded the same importance, nor given any value beyond a minor detail. Salvation is considered the ultimate goal, implying that either the authors of the Bible were limited in their ideas or that perhaps those who came after them interpolated their original words. Therein lies the chief point of departure [between Christianity and Islam].
Moving the discussion forward, Islam like Christianity also asserts the importance of salvation, but it is considered inferior to well-being. For example, colleges provide MA, BA, FA and entrance levels which differ in their eminence and status. Similarly, Islam also defines various stages of human life of which salvation is one, albeit it is accorded a lesser value [than others]. Both Islam and Christianity agree that salvation is part of the [cycle of life], however, Islam considers it of lesser worth, while Christianity sees it as the highest goal.
Another difference between Islam and Christianity is that the latter propounds the view that salvation can only be achieved through God’s grace and not by virtue of one’s deeds, since it is impossible for an individual to follow God’s commandments in their entirety. For this reason, God took the life of His son to redeem humankind for their sins. Islam too accepts that the attainment of salvation is dependent on divine grace. However, it also avers that everything has a cause from which it is derived and brought into existence. It is not possible for something to exist without a point of origin. Though in many instances people are not always aware of all of these causes, but their presence is irrefutable.
It is also the case that sometimes the cause of something is another cause. By way of illustration, let us consider the case of an employer who contracts a labourer on a fixed daily wage. The harder the labourer works, the better he will be able to fulfil the obligations of his work. By being inactive, he might be acting dishonestly, but alternatively, no matter how hard his exertions, he would not have the right to ask for a greater wage, unless he worked overtime in which case he could ask for an appropriate amount of more pay. However, if the employer happily acknowledges the performance of his worker through a discretionary bonus, the supplementary payment would not be considered as part of his original wages, but would emanate from the grace and mercy of the employer. But why is this grace and mercy afforded to one labourer and not to others? Because through his hard work and effort the labourer drew it upon himself. This grace and mercy was not the outcome of his work, as his entitled wage came to him through his daily remuneration. Instead, he caused it to happen through his own efforts. Islam upholds a similar ideal, meaning to say that salvation is the result of God’s grace which is drawn in by good deeds. And all aspects of the world adhere to the principle that though A might not be the result of B, it is certainly caused by it.
Let us take another example. The salaries paid by the government to members of its armed forces are a recompense for their endeavours in the field of battle. But those soldiers who display exceptional valour while fighting are honoured with a variety of other rewards. When soldiers are recruited, they are expected to fight for their country even at the cost of their lives, so why then do governments grant further rewards? Because they are pleased with a particular service they have rendered. In this sense, a government’s reward should not be considered compensation for a soldier’s endeavours, but their efforts result in the reward granted.
The granting of salvation by God Almighty is similar to this. People perform good deeds, even as they possess frailties and weaknesses. However, when individuals ardently strive to undertake acts of virtue, they attract the mercy and grace of God Almighty, and subsequently attain salvation. We are witness to the fact that in worldly endeavours when a person works particularly hard they draw the mercy and appreciation of their employer. Thus it is not possible for a person to strive to win the pleasure of God Almighty and not attain His mercy.
Therefore, according to our beliefs, good deeds are essential in drawing near the grace of God, and it is through His grace that one can attain salvation. There can be no salvation without the exercise of actions. For example, when an individual shows mercy towards another, it is because the sadness of their plight drew the mercy of the former. All things are achieved through certain means. Good deeds are the foremost means by which God’s mercy is attained. It is for this reason that Islam puts such emphasis on personal conduct. However, salvation in its essence, depends on God’s mercy alone. The Holy Prophet (sa) was once asked if his redemption would ensue from the excellence of his conduct. He replied that it too would come from God’s grace. There is no one higher in excellence than the Holy Prophet (sa), therefore, if he regarded God’s mercy as the cause of his salvation, then it is inconceivable that anyone else could depend on their deeds for their redemption. Nevertheless, good conduct is necessary to draw God’s grace, and it is this principle which is forwarded by Islam. One may compare this with Christian theology and decide for themselves which of the two presents the more cogent argument.
Christianity claims salvation is unattainable because human beings are sinful and cannot fully adhere to the law of God. They consider even minor infringements as acts of wrongdoing and, therefore, think it impossible for anyone to follow the law in its entirety. Since no one can succeed in this, it is essential for people to be reprimanded for their sins. Just as governments punish those who break the law, anyone who defies the commandments of God must also be punished. According to this principle, salvation is unattainable by following the law. However, Christians are mistaken [in their commitment to this form of reasoning]. The idea that it is necessary to adhere to the fullness of the law to attain salvation has led them to believe that since it is impossible for human beings to fulfil this requisite duty, God does not grant salvation at all. Islam, on the other hand, avers that God is indifferent to whether human beings worship Him or not, and His being is independent of this. God remains unaffected by an individual who worships Him or follows the law. Even if the whole world were to give over their days and nights in extolling Him, this would have no effect on the glory of His existence. And even if the whole world were to sink into wrongdoing and transgression, it would not diminish His grandeur. God Almighty did not reveal the law to sustain Himself, but instead because it was necessary for people. Adherence to the law is meant to benefit individuals. God did not reveal the law just so people could strive to follow its commandments, but also as a means by which humankind could interact and have communion with Him; it forges the potentiality of individuals through their good conduct, thereby cleansing their souls so that they can develop a relationship with God Almighty.
The law of God cannot, therefore, be compared with the laws enacted by a state. The purpose of government is to ensure laws are followed to uphold public order. If people, for example, begin to steal, pilfer, or appropriate, the government would lose its authority. However, even if the whole world rejects the divine law and disobeys it, God would still remain God. His sanctity and magnificence would not be affected in the slightest; therefore, trying to draw comparisons between the two is mistaken. A government depends on the compliance of its citizens, but God is not reliant on humankind to follow His law. God has created the law through His mercy and grace, so that those who abide by it are able to build a relationship with Him.
Divine laws can be likened to university courses. For example, a university might teach a historical textbook written by a certain author. Here, its purpose is not to teach the exact version of history propounded by the writer, but rather to increase the knowledge of their students to some extent with regards to that particular historical subject. Hence reading lists continuously change and those books that are considered appropriate and beneficial are the ones that are taught. Then once a course is complete the university examines its students. However, no student can answer every question correctly. Yet, every year thousands of students pass their exams despite all of them having made mistakes. This is because a university’s purpose is not to have their students answer every single question, but to build on their skills. A student passes when their proficiency has reached a certain level.
Divine laws are similar to this, in that God Almighty sets out rules so that people may develop the capacity to build a relationship with Him. For example, the purpose of salat is not to perform certain postures, but rather the purification of a person. The purpose of fasting is not to enter a state of hunger, but to increase in righteousness. Similarly, all such requirements of faith fulfil a deeper function. When a person performs them up to a point that the relevant strengths and capacities are inculcated within them, they are deemed to have passed the test. Again, turning to the example of universities, these institutions set certain pass marks, be it 40, 60, or 80 per cent, and those students who attain these scores are successful in their exams. In a similar vein, when it comes to matters of the divine law, the capabilities produced within a person are taken into account.
Christians ask: Does not every commandment of the law which emanates from God Almighty, deserve its due adherence? In the context of a university exam, however, they do not demand similar requirements of answering each question perfectly. The fact is, just as a university passes a student based on their level of learning even without them being able to answer every single question, an individual can also attain salvation despite not following the divine law in its entirety, because they were able to create a capacity within themselves. Furthermore, similar to a student with higher marks passing with distinction, an individual that increases their capacity by following the edicts of the law is considered of a higher stature.