Foreword

The Unity of Muslims, Part 4

Some differences are subtle and hard to articulate. Consider the example of two brothers, recognized by their names Ghulam Qadir and Ghulam Rasool. If you were asked, as a form of test, to characterise the differences between them, you would not be able to do so. Though the eyes can perceive the difference, the tongue cannot express them.

Furthermore, we all have a distinct voice. Our ears can listen to and identify individuals through their voice. Within this hall, many people are seated. If two people converse inside, someone standing outside would be able to distinguish between their voices. In essence, some differences cannot be articulated in words, but our sensory faculties can still identify them. Allah the Exalted says that all this diversity is a great divine sign.

Just consider the array of colours, each with numerous tints and shades. When a woman visits a bazaar and a vendor shows her a red garment, she asks for lighter or darker shades. In other words, every colour boasts a variety of tints and shades, be it green, yellow, or any other colour.

In short, all objects in the world are distinct, and God Almighty says that this fact is a sign for those who possess knowledge and understanding. When a layman walks into a forest, they observe the trees superficially. However, a forest officer can identify different types of plants and their chemical compositions, as well as trees that can be used for specific purposes. Similarly, a fisherman who goes out to sea can distinguish different types of fish and their characteristics, such as which species are spiny, which ones are better suited for preparing delectable fritters, and those that are especially savoury when cooked. To us, it may seem like just a body of water, but a fisherman possesses the knowledge and experience to provide a more intricate and detailed description of it. In other words, when experts in any field make observations, unlike non-specialists, they elucidate diverse aspects of things they specialise in.

God Almighty says that such subtleties are imperceptible to an unlearned person. But present His creation before scholars, experts, colour scientists, doctors, forest officers, and botanists and they will catalogue it. This comprehensive examination will compel you to acknowledge the myriad differences, all fashioned by the same God who created life with all its diversity and colour. In the above verse, then, Allah has mentioned examples of natural and necessary differences, which if erased, would render life meaningless. I have also explained that some differences are such that eliminating them leads to destruction.

The Holy Qur’an says:

In some cases, disputes arise between parties, one leading people to falsehood and the other to truth:

God Almighty shows the path of success to those who differ. In other words, differing is so noble in certain instances that Allah the Exalted grants success to such people—not for uniting, but rather for diverging. The verse further says that they differed

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

for the sake of truth; and not for personal reasons but ٖ بِاِذۡنِہ as per divine command. For the same deed, one is granted honour and respect by Allah, while another is afflicted with punishment. This distinction arises because the latter disagrees for the sake of falsehood, instead of truth.

The disbelievers also advocated for unity, but the Holy Qur’an disapproved it. They accused the Holy Prophets (as) of sowing discord by introducing a new religion, asserting that they were united in their ancestral faith, but Muhammads (as) sought to divide them. Though the disbelievers called for unity, God Almighty declared disagreement as the valid course of action. It is stated in the Holy Qur’an:

That is, when they are urged to forsake their outdated beliefs and embrace what God Almighty has revealed, they say: ‘We cannot do so. We will adhere to the religion of our forefathers, because it keeps us united. So how can we renounce it for your sake?’ Allah the Exalted says:

[Meaning] it is a weak argument to assert that they will follow their ancestral faith and not oppose their forebears by accepting Muhammads (as). They will follow their ancestors, even if they lacked reason, knowledge, and guidance. But unity only makes sense in matters that are grounded in these three aspects; otherwise, it becomes futile. Following their ancestors will, therefore, offer no benefits to the disbelievers. For example, if two people on the verge of drowning spotted a log and held it together, it would be considered an act of unity and cooperation. The same could not be said if a person placed their hand in a snake pit and another person followed suit; aligning in this act would be destructive. In essence, unity is not always advisable. While there are instances when unity is prudent and disagreement is unwise, there are also times when disagreement is the sensible course of action, with unity being unwise.

Given that some differences are natural and others a necessity for human existence, the question arises: Does Islam teach individualism, not collectivism? For it seems individualistic to accept matters benefiting oneself but reject the rest. The answer to this question is that while it is true Islam promotes individualism, the sense of collectivism and community in our Faith in unparalleled. Islam is the only religion that truly draws its adherents towards a collective consciousness. This fact is exemplified by a fundamental tenet that all Muslims must accept. No doubt we have sectarian differences. For example, our jamā‘at disagrees with other sects. However, you will not find a single Ahmadi who disbelieves in the Kalima [Islamic creed]. Similarly, the Shias and the Sunnis have mutual differences. Yet none of them would dare reject the Kalima. This fact holds true across all Islamic sects, with each and every Muslim affirming belief in one fundamental creed:

Every Muslim stands united with fellow believers in this declaration. Despite their differences, the Shias and the Sunnis concur on this creed. The Kalima, however, is unique to Islam and not found in any other faith. That is not to say that Christians cannot affirm the Unity of God. Indeed, they can, but they lack an equivalent credo declaring their belief in the trinity. Visit any mission and ask if they have one, and the reply will be ‘no’. It cannot be claimed otherwise because while a large segment of the Christian world is trinitarian, there is yet another that is unitarian. Conversely, the Muslim world is unanimous on the Kalima. It cannot be that a person subscribes to any teachings or views that contradict the Oneness of God and still remain in the fold of Islam. Further still, Christians comprise those who believe in the divinity of Jesus and those who consider him a saint or a prophet. Thus, the Christian world cannot formulate one universal kalima or declaration of faith. Next, let us examine Hinduism. Hindus are intensely loyal to their faith and take great pride in its ancient roots. However, when asked if they have a fundamental doctrine that encapsulates their religion, they cannot provide a definitive answer. A recently published book, What is Hinduism, features essays by prominent Hindu leaders such as Gokhale, Malaviyah, and Tamluk. A common theme emerges from these essays: the absence of an overarching doctrine that defines Hinduism.

Though some argue that being a Hindu necessitates a belief in the Vedas, this perspective raises questions about those who identify as Hindus while rejecting the Vedas, as seen in the case of the Madrasis. Similarly, the contention that a belief in the Puranas is crucial to being considered a Hindu is contradicted by the Aryas who do not subscribe to these texts. Some purport that idol worship is the hallmark of Hinduism, yet followers of Vivekananda actively eschew such practices. The belief that refraining from eating beef is a key tenet is contrary to the Hindus in Mumbai who do not adhere to this prohibition. Defining a Hindu as anyone born in India is also problematic: it implies that all Indian-born Muslims are Hindus.

·

10 of 10 left today