Foreword
The Unity of Muslims, Part 5
Despite the antiquity of their religion, Hindus remain divided over their fundamental creed. Whereas Muslims were told thirteen hundred and seventy years ago by the Holy Prophets (as) that our Kalima is
[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]
, encapsulating the message of Islam, others struggle to find a central belief to this day. What an extraordinary expression of unity enjoyed exclusively by Muslims!
Furthermore, Islam has a single qiblah, whereas no unified direction can be found among other faiths. Although Hindus have the Somnath temple, it is not something that unites all of them. Similarly, neither Christians nor Jews have a qiblah. It is claimed that the Temple Mount is the equivalent of their qiblah. However, the First Temple was built nearly five hundred years after Moses (as) during the time of David (as), raising the question: what was the qiblah of the Jews in the first five centuries? Muslims had one from the outset, with the advent of Prophet Muhammads (as). They were not without a qiblah even for a day. It was not after one year, two years, or ten years, but right from the start that Muslims had a qiblah. This is a tremendous form of unity that is absent in other faiths.
Another notable aspect of Islam is the congregational prayer, which is collective, not individualistic. Worshippers stand in straight rows, facing the qiblah. The iqama is recited, and an imam leads the prayer. When the imam stands, the followers stand, and when the imam prostrates, the congregation follows suit. This unique characteristic sets Islam apart from other religions. Neither Christians nor Jews have this feature; although they may gather, there is no directive for them to do so. In the Torah, there is no commandment to assemble for prayers; sacrificial offerings to God Almighty are defined as the perfect form of worship. The directive to pray in congregation is absent in the Puranas, the Vedas, the Torah, and the Gospels. Only Islam enjoins calling the Adhan, assembling in the mosque, standing in rows, facing the qiblah, and following each posture of the imam. In this manner, the entire assembly conforms to the imam. Even Hitler did not have the power to make everyone bow with a single motion. Yet, in Islam, when the imam bows, so does the congregation; when the imam prostrates, so does the congregation. Thus, God Almighty has accorded Muslims a unique power that has established a strong communal spirit unparalleled in other religions.
Hajj is another distinctive hallmark of the Islamic faith. Whilst Hindus also engage in yatras [pilgrimage], their tradition differs from Islam as they have numerous pilgrimages instead of a singular one. There is no teaching in Hinduism mandating a pilgrimage on the condition of having the financial means and safe passage to do so, or one is deemed a sinner. This specific form of communal worship is a feature solely found within Islam. In contrast, other faiths believe that one can become pious with or without a pilgrimage.
Zakat is an exceptional facet of Islam that distinguishes it from charity in other religions. While the concept of almsgiving is practised by the Jewish people, it lacks the level of specificity found in the injunction of Zakat. Expenditures of Islamic charity have been elaborated in great detail and encompass every aspect of national progress. It has a sense of totality lacking in the Jewish system of charity. The poor of all stripes are assigned shares in the Zakat. For example, Islam instructs to allocate funds to assist individuals in various circumstances, such as those without resources to start a business, skilled tailors unable to afford sewing machines, and individuals capable of driving horse-drawn carriages but lacking the means to acquire them. Similarly, an affluent person visiting a town who is robbed and cannot send for money or an impoverished father who is imprisoned and needs help feeding his children is to be aided through Zakat.
Hence, the Islamic charity system is diverse and empathetic. It ensures that individuals from various cultures and backgrounds can receive its benefits whilst preserving their dignity as the state is responsible for distributing the majority of Zakat. For example, I would not donate the amount levied on my land to anyone directly. Instead, it would be deposited with the state, which would deliver it to those in need. Even if the funds were allocated to a neighbour of the donor, the recipient would not feel beholden to or embarrassed by the donor. In essence, Islam eliminates the sense of shame often associated with receiving charity, upholding the dignity of the poor and maintaining their self-respect.
The Qadha [judicial system] is another distinctive feature of Islam, demonstrating the Islamic teachings of social unity and cohesion. If one is assaulted, the Qadha directs them to take the matter before a qadhi [judge] and seek requital. Even for a crime like adultery, for which the Shariah has legislated a stern punishment, Islam strictly forbids taking the law into your own hands. Instead, it directs that the matter be brought before a judge who will pass the verdict. A man approached the Holy Prophets (as). During this period, the Judaic law of punishment was being applied. He asked whether a husband who witnesses his wife committing adultery has the right to kill her.
The Prophets (as) said that he has no right to punish on his own. The penalty for adultery in Mosaic law was death, and until then, the offence was being adjudicated according to that law. Repeating his query, the man asked, ‘If death is the punishment of adultery, and the husband has seen his wife’s infidelity, why can’t he kill her?’ Prophet Muhammads (as) replied, ‘The husband has no right to punish; only a qadhi has this prerogative. So if the husband kills her, he will be sentenced to death.’
Thus, Islam does not permit extrajudicial punishment. It seeks to ensure there is no haste in seeking revenge and that all facts and evidence of a crime are brought forward. Only a qadhi can assess all these aspects of a case, no one else. Though seeking justice is one’s right, taking the law into one’s own hands is not. A criminal can only be punished through the judiciary.
The injunction of Jihad introduces another dimension of Islam. Jihad is not an individual act but a collective endeavour by the community when needed. According to Islam, when the imam declares the time for Jihad, every Muslim is duty-bound to fulfil this obligation. Failure to do so would violate both Sharia and the law. Thus, Jihad is a shared responsibility, and any assertion that Islam is a religion of individualism is fundamentally incorrect. On the contrary, Islam is a communal faith.
On the one hand, Islam acknowledges the importance of individuality and deems it necessary; on the other, it teaches the significance of the collective. The question then becomes: How can we reconcile this apparent dichotomy?
The answer lies in recognising that these two ideologies are not mutually exclusive but rather complementary. A blend of both is essential for progress. Every religion or nation that solely emphasised individuality has faced a decline. No faith or nation can pave the way for advancement without embracing individualism and collectivism.
In earlier eras, communion with God was only an individual act. However, the optimal path lies somewhere between individuality and collectivism, much like the concept of As-Sirāt [the bridge] in the afterlife. In other words, Islam embraces the idea of the individual and the collective in tandem. On the one hand, Islam elevates the individual to such an extent that one ascends to the divine throne, as it were, with no intermediaries between a person and their Creator. On the other, it binds humans to each other akin to how Greeks, when in combat, would tie themselves together, ensuring a collective fate. Similarly, Islam connects one individual to another. Hence, it becomes clear that ittihād entails establishing harmony according to the circumstances and individuals, while progress involves nurturing distinctions within those same parameters. Without deviating from known theories and experiences, progress remains an elusive goal. Thus, progressing without individuality presents challenges, just as maintaining peace without unity poses difficulties. The Holy Qur’an accepts both these realities as evident in the words of God Almighty addressing the Muslims: