Foreword
The Unity of Muslims, Part 7
On the one hand, God says that Jews and Christians should adhere to their respective teachings; failure to do so would make them betrayers of their faith. On the other, He tells them to unite. Thus, the Holy Qur’an teaches both points: retain your differences and collaborate on common grounds.
Furthermore, it is natural that once we come to the table, many avenues of unity will gradually emerge. Raising slogans to support or oppose someone does not accomplish anything. If a pivotal point offers the potential for unity, it should be seized. The Holy Qur’an says to maintain differences, even assuring divine assistance in some scenarios. Hence, it is foolish to neglect unity because of these differences. I have also experienced this practically. When the Khilafat Movement emerged, Maulana Muhammad Ali and Shaukat Ali initiated the movement to caution the British against taking any action against the Sultan of Turkey, whom the Muslims acknowledge as their caliph. They warned that if the British interfered, Muslims would collectively resist. The broader Muslim community was invited to join the movement. For this purpose, a conference was hosted in Lucknow. Reflecting on the matter, I realised that the Shias, Ahle Hadith, and Kharijites did not accept the Sultan of Turkey as their caliph. Similarly, Ahmadis held a different view, with their Head serving as the Khalifa. I wondered why all these groups would accept the Sultan of Turkey as their caliph and pledge to unite in his defence if he was attacked.
I sent a delegation with a letter to attend the conference in Lucknow. I wrote that if you go to the British with the stated premise, they would note that Khawarij, Ahl-e-Hadith, and Shia Muslims do not accept Abdul Hameed as their caliph; so how can we claim he is the caliph of all Muslims? Instead, it should be said that most Muslims regard the Sultan of Turkey as their caliph, whilst the rest hold him in high esteem; and, thus, any action taken against him would be met with resistance from the entire Muslim world. I wrote that formulating the argument in this manner would serve the purpose. It would avoid provoking opposition from Ahmadis, Shias, or Ahle Hadith, as none would openly call for the Sultan’s demise. Even if such sentiments were held, they would be kept private, not expressed publicly. But Maulana Shaukat Ali had a fiery temperament. When the delegation presented him with my letter, he deemed it a source of division. Fifteen days later, the Ahle Hadith published a declaration asserting their non-acceptance of the Sultan of Turkey as their caliph. The Shia community followed suit with a similar declaration, leading to unrest. Although not present in this country, the Kharijites would likely have made a comparable statement. A year and a half later, the Turks themselves deposed the Sultan.
At a gathering at Shimla some three or four years later, Muhammad Ali observed that the movement had a noble cause; unfortunately, the Muslims fell apart and failed to achieve the objective. I then reminded him of [the advise I had proposed]. If it had been followed, this failure might have been averted. Upon this, Maulana Muhammad Ali said he had not received my advice. I mentioned that it was conveyed to his elder brother, Shaukat Ali, who disregarded it. I reiterated that if my proposal was heeded—and it was written [to the British] that most Muslims recognised the Sultan of Turkey as the Caliph, whilst the minority considered him a symbol of their authority—the Ahle Hadith, the Kharijites, and the Shia would not have raised any objections. The Maulana expressed disappointment at not receiving my message sooner.
Hence, it is time to put aside the differences between Shia, Sunni, Hanafi, Wahabi, and Ahmadis and non- Ahmadis, and embrace our shared values. This is the principle of unity. The Holy Prophet Muhammads (as) extended invitations to Christians and Jews based on this very principle.
The second principle of unity entails prioritising major concerns over minor ones. If unity cannot be attained in every aspect, focus on significant matters and overlook trivial issues. For example, in the Holy Qur’an, God Almighty discusses the Unity of God, but also emphasises obedience and fidelity towards parents. However, concerning those who refused to abandon the religion of their forefathers when prophets appeared among them, Allah the Exalted declared that the ancestors they followed were ignorant. While it is a great virtue to honour and respect one’s forefathers, one must abandon this virtue if it opposes God Almighty. Thus, the second principle of unity is to nurture the spirit of sacrificing minor aspects for more critical ones. For example, do not neglect the truth, even if it requires diverging from national or cultural traditions.
In short, unity can be realised by adhering to these two principles. Currently, Pakistan, Lebanon,
Iraq, Jordan, Syria, Egypt, Libya, Iran, Afghanistan, Indonesia, and Saudi Arabia are eleven independent Muslim countries, each with their own mutual differences. If these states are interested in unifying, it is incumbent upon them to consider common points around which to unite, whilst overlooking their differences. If such a point is found, they should ally and work to achieve its aims. For instance, they can collaborate on the goal of not permitting any Muslim country to remain subjugated. Rather than waiting for their internal disputes to be resolved, they should join forces in preventing any Islamic land from being enslaved and make concerted efforts for its liberation. Just as Prophet Muhammads (as) invited Jews and Christians to unite based on a shared belief in Tauheed, all Muslims ought to unify in liberating enslaved subjects, with differences being resolved later. Similarly, Pakistani Muslims have many internal disputes, yet they also have commonalities with other countries that can unite them. For example, they can form a coalition to save Pakistan from the Hindus or [take up the cause of liberating] Kashmir. Instead of allowing differences to divide them, they can forge alliances based on shared interests. Their mutual relations will serve to resolve their internal disputes later.
I have observed that Muslims focus entirely on their differences and disregard what binds them. Every sect declares the others it disagrees with as wajib-ul-qatal [punishable by death], even though it contradicts the practice of the Holy Prophets (as). Are they greater believers than Prophet Muhammads (as) who invited the Jews and the Christians to stand in solidarity with Muslims on the shared belief in the Unity of God? Yet, the believers fail to extend the same invitation to their fellow adherents, and like [the Jewish moneylender in] The Merchant of Venice, they refuse to move an inch without carving out each other’s flesh.
The same call for solidarity will unite the world of Islam. If Muslim countries wish to achieve unity, they must rally around the principle of joining forces, regardless of their contentious issues, and stand together to fight the enemy. Let us agree that, despite our mutual differences, we will not engage in conflict with each other.
I had intended to deliver a short speech due to my illness, but God Almighty has enabled me to speak at some length. As it is time for the Adhan, I will conclude my speech.
Islam is embarking on a critical era, and Muslims must remain vigilant and open their eyes to the looming threats. At the very least, we must unite to ensure that the legacy of Prophet Muhammads (as) remains untarnished, come what may. (Al-Fazl, December 12-19, 1962)
Glossary
Hajj is one of the five pillars of Islam. It refers to the Muslim pilgrimage to Makkah that all Muslims are expected to make at least once during their lifetime if they have the means to do so.
Jamā‘at a united body of Muslims with a leader is referred to as Jamā‘at in Islamic terminology.
Jihad an Arabic term that means to struggle or strive. It has several connotations including spiritual and moral endeavours. Additionally, it is also used for warfare in Islam whereby Muslims are permitted to take up arms to defend themselves or punish the aggressors.