Foreword
The Unity of Muslims, Part 6
That is, [And obey Allah and His Messenger] and dispute not with one another. Falling into strife will diminish your power and cause you to suffer defeat from the enemy. Always stand united and offer mutual support. وَاصْبِرُوا Since you will encounter many challenges in maintaining unity, it is imperative to cultivate patience. As you progress towards a collective ethos, various disputes will surface.
Even during the era of Prophet Muhammads (as), instances of grievances occurred. Once, he distributed the spoils of war when a man claimed the allocation was unfair. In response, the Prophets (as) said, ‘If I do not uphold justice, who will?’ Being present, Hazrat Umar (ra) drew his sword, offering to behead the man for his audacity. However, the Prophets (as) advised letting him be, stating that despite his indiscretion, executing him would lead people to say that Muhammads (as) slays his own companions. If people from that era could voice their concerns and disagreements, why should individuals from Pakistan, Syria, Iraq, and Jordan not be allowed the same?
Mistakes are an inescapable reality, and people are prone to voicing grievances. What, then, is the appropriate course of action? Allah says that you should exercise patience and place your trust in Him. He will reward you for it Himself. He further instructs Muslims:
Hold fast all together to the rope of Allah and be not divided.
If you allow divisions to form, your collective strength will wane. This is a call for collective unity, yet the Holy Qur’an also acknowledges that those who refuse to diverge from their ancestral religion are faithless. As such, the Book of Allah embraces both unity and divergence.
Similarly, both aspects were acknowledged by the Holy Prophets (as) who said
اِخْتِلَافُ اُمَّتِيْ رَحْمَة or differences in my ummah are mercy. He characterised distinctions as a blessing rather than a curse, asserting that conflicting parties remain integral parts of his nation, regardless of their disputes. However, Prophet Muhammads (as) also said,
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
Whoever strays even a handspan from the congregation is not one of us.
Thus, on the one hand, the Holy Prophets (as) accepted that differences are a blessing, and on the other, he warned that anyone who parts ways from the Jamā‘at is no longer among us and ceases to be a Muslim. A companion of Prophet Muhammads (as) sought guidance on how to address divisions: should he take up the sword and confront the people? The Prophets (as)
advised against this course of action. When the companion inquired further on what he should do, the Prophets (as) said,
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
stand by the Jamā‘at. As such, he highlighted individuality to the point of considering the nation’s disagreements a form of mercy, all the while emphasising the necessity of standing with the Muslim community, even in the face of oppression. In short, the teachings of Prophet Muhammads (as) and the Holy Qur’an recognise the coexistence of disagreement and unity.
The query at hand pertains to the principles that can sustain unity while respecting individuality. In the Holy Qur’an, Allah the Exalted says:
God Almighty instructs His Prophet to extend an invitation to the Christians and the Jews to find unity in the central belief that unites us all. What is that common point? It is that you and I both proclaim that God is One. So let us unite on this point. Indeed, you pray facing the Temple Mount whilst I pray facing the Ka‘bah, yet our shared belief in the Unity of God remains a commonality.
Let us come together and pledge not to worship anyone other than God. Your worship is characterised by prostration, whilst ours incorporates both bowing and prostration. Your devotions occur once a week; ours span across all seven days. You congregate on Sundays, and we do on Fridays. Nevertheless, let us reach a consensus to invoke solely the name of God Almighty, refusing to associate any partners with Him. Although Judaism and Christianity are distinct religions, the Holy Qur’an tells us they share a central belief [with Islam]—the principle of the Oneness of God. Let us rally around this shared doctrine, overlooking other differences.
Thus, the first principle for establishing Muslim unity is acknowledging our differences. An individual who aims to eliminate these differences to foster unity is unlikely to succeed. Only those who can look past secondary differences can prevail.
A renowned phrase from Lloyd George comes to mind. As Britain was under threat from France and Germany, Lloyd George journeyed to France to engage in discussions with the French government.
His return was met with queries such as whether his mission bore fruit and if an alliance had been forged between Britain and France. Lloyd George responded that they had concurred on maintaining their differences. This unity served as their shield. They accepted their disparities yet resolved to stand united, bracing themselves against the adversary, despite their disagreements.
Whereas Lloyd George might have recently uttered these words, Islam had already expressed the same sentiments fourteen centuries ago [when God Almighty said that]: O Christians and Jews! Why do you dispute with us? Do we not have common ground? If so, let us first agree and come together on this point. Thus, to build Muslim unity, it becomes paramount to set aside our mutual differences and adopt all possible aspects in which we can unite. Someone might question how we can address our contentious issues if we focus exclusively on the aspects that align us. The Holy Qur’an offers the solution to this question. Allah the Exalted says to follow your respective scriptures and teachings in disputed matters and settle such issues in their light. The Jews and the Christians have the Torah and the Gospels they can follow. God says: