A Comparative Study of Religions on the Basis of Natural Criterion and Some Comments on the Benevolence of the British Government
The Criterion for Religions
In my opinion none could have a better opportunity of evaluating and judging the truth of a religion and of differentiating between right and wrong, than the people of our land-the Punjab and India. The first blessing of God Almighty in this regard is that our country happens to be under the British Government. It would indeed be extreme ingratitude on our part not to be grateful to this benevolent Government from the depth of our heart. By virtue of its blessed presence we have such privilege of inviting people to Islam and communicating its message as not even a king has ever enjoyed before us. Because this knowledgefriendly Government allows us such freedom of expression as is not to be found in any other existing government. Is it not strange that while we are free to preach Islam in the streets of London, it is not possible for us to do the same in the Holy Mecca! Not only has this Government given freedom to publish books and preach one's religion to one and all, but has also taken upon itself to help every sect by spreading the knowledge of modem sciences and arts. Thus, through education and training it has opened the eyes of a whole world. In addition to this favour, which in it- self is no small achievement, this benign Government protects our lives, honour and property with all sincerity and to the best of its ability. It is also providing us with the benefits of the freedom for which many a true well-wisher of mankind passed away thirsting before now. Yet another favour of the Government, which is of even greater value, is that it wants to transform wild savages and so-called humans into wise and scholarly people through different disciplines of education. We find that through sustained efforts on the part of this Government those who almost lived like animals and beasts have now partaken something of humaneness, knowledge and understanding. As a result, most minds and hearts are now radiant with such light as is gained from the acquisition of knowledge.
It is as if the expansion of information has changed the world all at once. However, just as light can pass through a glass and water cannot, similarly, the light of knowledge has indeed entered hearts and minds but the pure and truthoriented water of sincerity has not yet entered people's hearts to nurture the plant of the soul and to yield good fruit. But the Government is not to blame. The fact of the matter is that the conditions which inspire true spirituality are either extremely rare or completely non-existent. Curiously enough, with the progress of knowledge, cunning and deceit seem to be on the rise and seekers after truth are confronted with overwhelming doubts. Simplicity of faith has all but disappeared and philosophical thinking, which is unaccompanied by religious knowledge, is exerting such a poisonous influence on the newly educated people as to pull them towards atheism. The truth is that it is exceedingly difficult for people to escape this influence without the help of religious knowledge. Therefore, pity be upon the person who has been left to the mercy of such schools and colleges without any knowledge of religious truths and verities. We can of course say that this courageous Government, which is so sympathetic to mankind, has cleansed with its own hands the wasteland of the hearts of our people and cleared them of wild shrubs and bushes, and from all kinds of weeds that had grown thick and tall and had covered up the soil underneath. Naturally the time has now come for the seed of truth to be sown in this soil and to be irrigated by heavenly water. Fortunate indeed are those who have come so close to this heavenly rain with the help of this blessed Government. Muslims should look upon the presence of this Government as a gift of God, and genuinely try to obey it so that they become an example for others. Can the reward of goodness be anything but goodness? Is it not obligatory to repay goodness with goodness?
Everyone should reflect over this and dis- play his innate goodness. Islamic Shariah does not teach us to forego the rights of others and to waste their favours. Therefore, not hypocritically, but genuinely, one should obey this benevolent Government, for God has established it as the first and foremost means for spreading the light of our faith.
The second means available in our country to assess the truth of religions is the profusion of printing presses, for such books as lay buried in the earth were again brought back to life through them. So much so, that even the Vedas of the Hindus has come out dressed in new pages. In other words, it has been reborn, and the tales invented by the fools and the rabble have been exposed.
The third means is the opening of the channels of communications, the establishment of an efficient postal system, and the conveyance of books from far off countries to our land and vice versa. All these means, which, by the grace of God, have now been made available in our country, and from which we are freely benefiting, are instrumental in searching for the truth. All these benefits have been received through this kind and well-meaning Government and we pray for it from the bottom of our hearts.
It may be asked as to why such a civilized and wise Government associates itself with a religion that <lei- fies a man and thus detracts from the self-evident, eternal and immutable glory of the true God? The answer to this question can only be that, unfortunately, monarchs and kings are so preoccupied with running the affairs of the state that it consumes all their faculties of thought and reflection. Preoccupation with national interests does not let them attend to the affairs of the hereafter. Hence such continuous and relentless absorption in worldly pursuits undermines the spirit of recognizing the Almighty and of seeking out the truth. Nevertheless, I am hopeful that He will guide this courageous Government towards the right path. Our prayer for this Government is as much for its worldly prosperity as for the hereafter. No wonder therefore if we do witness the effect of this prayer.
In this day and age, while so many means are available to distinguish between truth and falsehood, three major religions in our country are in the field confronting one another. Each follower of these three faiths claims that only his faith is right and true, and, strangely enough, none of them is ever inclined to confess that his faith is not based on the principles of truth. But I cannot believe that the hearts of our opponents can, even for a moment, agree with the claim they make with their tongues. The hallmark of a true religion is that even before we advance arguments in its favour, it is, in its very essence, so bright and resplen- dent that against it all other religions appear to be enveloped in darkness. A wise person can clearly understand this argument only when he concentrates on the essence of a religion, leaving aside all the specious arguments that are offered in its favour. That is to say, as he makes comparison between different faiths on the basis of their approach to recognizing God, and does away with all extraneous arguments in favour of any particular religious dogma, he comes to recognize the religion which possesses the intrinsic light of truth, and which has the ability to draw hearts towards itself purely because of its manner of Divine recognition. In this context I have already spoken of three religions, namely Arya, Christianity and Islam. If we wish to present the true picture of these three faiths, it would be as follows:
The Arya religion has a 'God' whose godhood cannot function independently on the strength of His inherent power and might, for all His hopes are pinned on existents which are not His own creation. While it is impossible for man to comprehend the extent of the powers of the True God, the powers of the god of the Aryas can be counted on fingertips. He is a Parmeshwar [God] of such meagre resources that the limits of all His powers have already been defined, and the utmost one could say in His favour would be that, like a mason, he can only put together things that are coeter- nal with Him. But if it is asked whether He personally contributes anything to it, the answer would be in the negative. Thus, the maximum extent of His power consists only in joining together existing souls and tiny material particles that are as eternal and necessary as His own being and over the creation of which He has no influence whatsoever. It is, therefore, difficult to explain why at all such eternal entities need a Parmeshwar since they themselves and all their properties are self-existent. Moreover, their ability to combine with one another is also innate and their mutual pull and attraction has existed since eternity. All their characteristics, resulting from their synthesis, are similarly self-existing. One fails to understand how the existence of such a defective and powerless Parmeshwar can be justified. And what is there to distinguish Him from everything else except that He is more clever and intelligent! There is no doubt that the Parmeshwar of the Aryas lacks the infinite powers that are the hallmark of Divine perfection. As ill luck would have it, this imaginary Parmeshwar failed to attain the absolute perfection which is a must for the full manifestation of Divine glory. Another misfortune is that, except for a few pages of the Vedas, there is no way of recognizing Him through the laws of nature.
Because, if it is true that souls and material particles, along with all of their properties, attractions, characteristics, intellects, cogni- tions and consciousness are self-existing, then common sense sees no need for any external being to bring them together. The reason is that in such a case it would be impossible to explain why things-which have been their own creator since all eternity, and which contain within themselves such properties as are necessary for their mutual connection-stand in need of someone else to bring them together, when they don't even need Parmeshwar for their existence, their faculties or their characteristics. The fact is that joining souls and material bodies to their qualities is also a kind of synthesis. Thus, it proves that just as these eternal entities stand in no need of any creator for their existence or for their properties, similarly they do not need any assembler to combine them with one another. It would be the height of folly to admit that such entities do not need any external being for their existence, their properties and their mutual connection, and then to claim, in the same breath, that some entities do need an external being to combine them. This would be a claim without any argument. Thus, in view of this doctrine, it becomes exceedingly difficult to prove the very existence of Parmeshwar. None can be more unfortunate than the one who relies on such a Parmeshwar, who, because of His limited power, does not have sufficient means even to prove His own existence. So much for the divine powers of the
Parmeshwar of the Hindus! But when we come to his moral qualities, we find them inferior even to those of humans. We find that a kind-hearted person forgives, time and again, such offenders as seek his pardon with humility and contrition. And many a time, due to his generous nature, he shows kindness even to those who do not deserve it. But the Aryas confess that their Parmeshwar is bereft of both these moral qualities. In their view, each sin is the cause of millions of reincarnations and there is no possibility of deliverance until and unless a sinner receives his full quota of punishment by going through countless reincarnations. Furthermore, according to their belief, it is utterly futile to hope that repentance, contrition and seeking forgiveness will save a person from rebirth, or that his return to the truth will save him from the punishment of his past errors of word and deed. On the contrary, it is inevitable that one must pass through countless reincarnations, and there is no way to avoid them. Also, Parmeshwar is not wont to grant pardon through grace or generosity, and anything pleasant or any bounty that is given to man or animal is only the fruit of some previous incarnation. What a pity, that though the Aryas are so proud of Vedic principles, this false teaching has not been able to subdue their conscience. In my frequent meetings with some members of this sect I have often experienced that just as they are mortified at the mere mention of Neug 1 , they are also extremely embarrassed when asked why the divine and moral powers of the Parmeshwar are so limited that even his Godhood cannot be proven on the basis of reason, and because of which the unfortunate Aryas have been deprived of eternal salvation. The quintessence and the truth about the Parmeshwar of the Hindus is that he is extremely weak and pitiable with regard to his divine and moral powers. Perhaps this is the reason why, in the Vedas, worship of Parmeshwar has been left out, and stress has been laid on the worship of fire, air, moon, sun, and water, and every reward and favour has been sought from these objects. It would indeed be a mistake for the Aryas to rely on their Parmeshwar, for he cannot lead them anywhere while he is himself deprived of all powers and leads his life in frustration. What I have written should be enough for anyone to visualize the true picture of the Parmeshwar of the Hindus.
Next comes Christianity, whose adherents vociferously and exaggeratedly believe their 'God', whom they call Jesus Christ, to be the true God. Here is the profile of the 'God' of the Christians: He was an Israelite born of Mary, daughter of Jacob, and departed from this transitory world at the age of thirty-two. When we reflect how, at the time of his arrest, he could not attain his desire even though he prayed all night, and with what ignominy he was apprehended, and how, as the Christians say, he was drawn upon the cross and died crying 'Eli, Eli'2 , a shudder all at once runs through us: how can we call such a person the Almighty whose prayer was not accepted by God, and who, after being continuously beaten and harassed, met his death in a state of disappointment and frustration? Just imagine the spectacle of Jesus Christ being sent to Herod after remaining in captivity in the court of Pilate. Is it in keeping with Divine glory that after being arrested, handcuffed and shackled he was sent off to Galilee under the custody of a few troopers, suffering their rebukes, and moving from one prison to another in such ignominy? Pilate wanted to release him if only he could show a miracle, but he could show none. Thus Pilate was left with no choice but to return him to prison and hand him over to the Jews, who did not waste any time doing away with him.
Readers may now judge for themselves whether these are the signs of the true God! Can any pure conscience ever accept that the Creator of heaven and earth, Who is the Omnipotent, and possesses limitless powers, should end up so unfortunate, weak and miserable that mischief-makers should trample him under their feet? If anyone worships such a 'God' and relies upon him, it is up to him. But the truth is that if you compare the God of the Christians even with the Parmeshwar of the Aryas, and weigh his power and might, he will still be found wanting in comparison. For although the supposed Parmeshwar of the Aryas has no power to create anything, they still say that at least he has the power to combine things that already exist. But Jesus of the Christians could not demonstrate even this much power when the Jews drew him on the cross and said, 'If you now save yourself, we will believe you.' And yet he could not save himself though it was no big task; all he had to do was to combine his spirit with his body. The poor man failed to do even that. Thereafter his apologists spun the tale that he was resurrected in the sepulchre. Unfortunately, they did not realize that the Jews had wanted him to come back to life right before their eyes. Since he could not come back to life before their eyes, nor did he meet them after his resurrection from the sepulchre, what proof is there for the Jews, or any researcher for that matter, that he did indeed come back to life? In the absence of any such evidence, even if one were to assume that the corpse somehow went missing in the sepulchre, it would not prove that he had in fact come back to life. The best that could reasonably be asserted with any degree of certainty is that someone who wished to show a miracle must have stealthily whisked the body away.