A Comparative Study of Religions on the Basis of Natural Criterion and Some Comments on the Benevolence of the British Government

The Criterion for Religions, Part 2

There have been many people in this world whose followers believe that their corpses had disappeared and that they had gone to heaven along with their bodies. Will the Christians accept that it might well have been so? Look at the episode of Baba Nanak Sahib. One million and seven hundred thousand Sikhs unanimously believe that he went bodily to heaven after he died. This belief is not only unanimous but is recorded in authentic books, which date back to the time of the occurrence. Now, will the Christians accept that Baba Nanak Sahib has indeed gone to heaven with his earthly body? The pity is that the Christians are quick to invoke reason in respect of other people, but they do not allow it to come within touching distance of their own absurdities. If only the Christians wished to be just, they could readily understand that the arguments of the Sikh gentlemen about the disappearance of Baba Nanak Sahib's body and his going to heaven with his physical frame are more cogent and worthy of attention than their own gilded lies, and are, without doubt, stronger than the so-called arguments of the Gospels, for they were simultaneously recorded in Bala's Janam Sakhz, whereas the Gospels were chronicled many years after the time of Jesus. Baba Nanak Sahib's episode has yet another advantage: The miraculous power attributed to Jesus seems an attempt by the disciples to hide the mortification they had to suffer before the Jews. After drawing Jesus on the cross, the Jews had wanted him to show a miracle by coming down alive from the cross; if he did so, they would believe him. But since Jesus could not get down from the cross, his disciples were greatly embarrassed and cut a sorry figure before the Jews. In order to hide their shame they must, therefore, have had recourse to some subterfuge, which would help them escape the sarcasm, ridicule and laughter of the simple-minded.

It is, therefore, quite reasonable to believe that they may have played this trickery in order to wipe this stigma off their faces, and might have removed Jesus' body from one grave to another under the cover of night-as indeed they have been accused of doing-and then, being the only witnesses to their own claim, started propagating that Jesus has risen from the dead just as the Jews had demanded of him, and that he had forthwith gone to heaven. The Sikhs, on the other hand, didn't face any such difficulties on the occasion of Baba Nanak Sahib's demise. No adversary ever accused them of such trickery nor did they have to resort to deception. Nor, for that matter, did anyone cry out-like the Jews had done in the case of Jesusas_that the corpse had been stolen. It would have been more plausible if Christians had held such a belief about Baba Nanak Sahib rather than Jesus. To hold such a belief about Jesus is a plain concoction and reeks of fabrication.

The one last excuse, which is offered for the suffering and crucifixion of Jesus, is that, being 'God', he was crucified so that his death might redeem the sinners. The possibility that God too can die is yet another invention of the Christians, even though they brought him back to life and raised him to the Throne. To this day they are under the false notion that he will come back to this world to sit in judgement, and that the body he was given after his death shall remain with him forever by virtue of being 'God'. But this 'God' incarnate of the Christians, who, according to them, has tasted death once already, and is made up of blood, flesh, bones and all the other organs, is no different from Avatars of the Hindus who are being gleefully disowned by the Aryas nowadays. The only difference is that while the Christian 'God' was born only once from the womb of Mary, daughter of Jacob, the Hindu god Vishnu, with a view to warding off the sins of the world, allowed himself to wear the stigma of birth as many as nine times. But the episode of the eighth birth, as reported, is of particular interest. It is said that when the earth was overpowered by the wicked, Vishnu took birth at midnight from the womb of a virgin as an Avatar and delivered people from the sins that had pervaded the world. Although this story conforms to the Christian taste, the Hindus were more prudent, for, unlike the Christians, they took care not to crucify their Avatars, nor did they consider them to be accursed. There are certain hints in the Holy Qur’an which clearly indicate that the Brahmans of ancient India were the ones who first invented the concept of deifying a human being. Thereafter the Greeks borrowed these beliefs from the Hindus. Finally, it was the lot of the Christians to gorge themselves on the filth of this detestable belief held by the first two peoples.

The Hindus, however, hit upon another fanciful idea which had not occurred to the Christians. Hindus consider it to be the ancient law of the Eternal God that whenever the world got filled with sin, their Parmeshwar could think of no other stratagem than to let himself be born into this world to redeem mankind. This did not happen once but has always been happening whenever the need arose. The Christians on the other hand-though they believe that God is Eternal and His existence has no beginning, no matter how far we may go back in time, and that He has been the Creator and Lord of the worlds since eternitythey at least do not believe that He has eternally been crucifying His darling sons for the sake of mankind. Rather, they say that it was only recently that He hit upon this stratagem, and that the ageing father has only now thought of saving others from punishment by having His son crucified. It is clear that once one accepts that God is eternal and timeless, one must also accept that God's creation has always existed in one form or the other, and that because of the eternal manifestation of the God's eternal attributes a whole universe has at times been disappearing into the realm of non-existence and, at times, one universe has been appearing in place of another. Furthermore, no one can count how many universes God has withdrawn from the world and replaced them with others. God Almighty, in fact, points to this ever-existing generic universe when He says in the Holy Qur’an that He created the Jinn before He had created Adam. Despite self-evident proof that the universe must be timeless in nature, the Christians have yet to produce a list showing the number of times that the 'Son of God' was drawn upon the cross in the countless universes, each isolated from the other.

While it is evident, in accordance with the principles of the Christian faith, that no one except the son of God is free from sin, we would like to know what arrangements were made for the salvation of the creatures who lived before the time of our own Adam and who had no connection whatsoever with the present human race. Was it this same son who was crucified time and again for their salvation, or was it some other son who would accept the cross for the sake of earlier creations? To the best of my judgement, I believe that if there can be no redemption without crucifixion, then the God of the Christians must have possessed countless sons who would have been useful in such endeavours now and then, and each one of them must have been crucified in his own good time. Hence, it would be futile to expect any good from a God whose own youthful sons continued to die.

During the debate at Amritsar I also raised the following question. The Christians claim that their 'God' does not wish anyone to die in sin, let them, therefore, tell us what arrangements this 'God' has made for the salvation of the evil spirits mentioned in the Gospels? 3 Did any Son of God come to the world to lay down his life for the sins of the devils or to stop them from sin? If no such arrangement was made, it would prove that the 'God' of the Christians has always been pleased to burn the devils-who, according to the Christian belief, outnumber even the sons of Adam-in the everlasting fire of hell. Since no such son ever existed, the Christians were forced to admit that their 'God' created devils only for hell. Thus, ever since they have pronounced the Son of Mary to be 'God', the poor Christians find themselves in all sorts of troubles. I do not believe that even a day passes when their own souls do not look at this belief with contempt. Another predicament they face is that, upon investigation, no final cause can be ascertained as to why he was crucified, nor was any useful purpose served by his crucifixion, for there can be only two possibilities:

( 1) The first is that the ultimate reason for the crucifixion of 'the son' was to encourage his followers to commit sins, and to freely spread sinfulness, impiety and every kind of evil with the help of Atonement. This position is obviously untenable for it is the way of Satan, and I do not believe that anyone in the world would opt for this sinful path or consider the founder of such a faith to be pious who has thus induced the common man to indulge in sin. Experience shows that such beliefs are only held by those who are deprived of true faith and morality, and wish, for their own selfish motives, to cast other people into a life of sin as well. They are in fact like the roadside fortunetellers who lure and deceive passers-by, and by charging a paltry sum, reassure the poor fools in comforting tones that fortune is about to smile on them. Pretending to be true scholars they closely study the lines on people's hands and their facial features, as if looking for certain signs. After turning the pages of a book, which is placed there expressly for this trickery, they assure the client that his great star of fortune is about to shine; and that he will very probably become the king of a country or at least a minister. The people who are intent on making a person 'the recipient of divine favours' despite his chronic impurities, are like the alchemists who, when they come across a simpleton who also happens to be rich, try to cheat him with their bragging. After talking a while of this and that, they begin to criticize earlier alchemists, calling them liars and scoundrels and swindlers. They go on in this manner and finally say, 'Gentleman! during the course of fifty or sixty years of my life every claimant to alchemy that I have come across was a liar, but my late mentor was a genuine alchemist.

He gave away tens of millions of rupees in charity, and I was lucky to have served him for twelve years and was duly rewarded.' On hearing of 'reward' an ignoramus blurts out: 'In that case, old man, you must have learnt the formula of alchemy from your mentor.' At this the old man frowns and says a little angrily, 'Shut up, young man, or else thousands will gather around me; I am trying to hide from the people.' The ignorant are easily taken in by these few remarks. The game is thus ensnared and ready for slaughter. He takes the victim aside and tells him in a secretive manner, 'It is only your good fortune that has brought me here across thousands of miles. I myself cannot understand why this hard heart of mine has softened for you. Now, hurry up! Go home and fetch gold jewellery worth ten thousand rupees, your own or borrowed, and it will multiply ten fold overnight. But, beware, don't let anyone know about me. Make some other excuse for it.' The long and short of it is that after getting hold of the jewel- lery these people simply disappear, and the simpletons who were hoping for ten fold multiplication are left bemoaning their fate. This is the retribution for the greed, which is carried to its limits by ignoring the law of nature. But what I have heard is that such swindlers have to declare all those before and after them to be frauds, bandits, villains, liars and ignorant of the formula. Similarly, Christians too seem unable to establish their bona fides until and unless they have declared all the holy Prophetsas_from Adamas onwards-to be sinners and evildoers. 4

(2) The second possible reason why this pitiable son should have been crucified is that those who believe in his crucifixion may be saved from every kind of sin and wickedness, and that the appetites of their baser selves may not be allowed to find expression. Unfortunately, this condition turns out to be as much against decency and as manifestly false as the first one. If it is assumed that genuine faith in the Atonement of Jesus has the particular quality of making a true believer angelic, after which not even the thought of sin ever crosses his mind, then it will have to be posited about all the earlier Prophetsas that they did not truly believe in the crucifixion of Jesus and in Atonement, for, as alleged by the Christians, they crossed all the limits in evildoing; some among them indulged in idol-worship, while some committed unlawful murder and some were guilty of incest with their daughters. Jesus' grandfather David, in particular, was guilty of every evil. In order to satisfy his lust he got an innocent person killed by subterfuge, sent for his wife through procuress, got her drunk and committed adultery with her. He wasted a lot of money on immoral pleasures and throughout his life kept as many as hundred wives, which in itself, according to the Christians, amounts to adultery. Strangely enough, the Holy Ghost continued to descend upon him everyday and the Psalms continued to be revealed rapidly, yet neither the Holy Ghost nor belief in the Atonement of Jesus could prevent him from immoralities and he ultimately died steeped in these vices. What is even more strange is that Atonement couldn't even save the maternal and paternal grandmothers of Jesus from illicit sex, though it could not but smear the pristine purity of Jesus' nature, particularly when there were as many as three such grandmothers. Thus one 'revered' maternal grandmother of Jesus, who in one sense was also his paternal grandmother, was Rehab, the harlot, i.e., a prostitute. (See Joshua 2: 1) The second maternal grandmother, who, in one sense, was also a paternal grandmother, was named Tamar. She was a woman of easy virtue like professional prostitutes. (See Genesis 38:16-30) Another maternal grandmother of Jesus, who in one sense was also a paternal grandmother of his, is known by the name of Bath-Sheba. She was none other than the 'pious' one who committed adultery with David. 5 (See 2 Samuel 11).

Now, the maternal and paternal grandmothers must obviously have been apprised of Jesus' Atonement and they must have believed in it, for the Christians believe as a matter of principle that earlier Prophetsas and their followers were given the same teaching of Atonement and that they were redeemed only because of this belief. Now, if it is supposed that Jesus' crucifixion saves one from sin, then Jesus' maternal and paternal grandmothers should have been saved from adultery and illicit sex. It would similarly follow that while the

Prophetsas, despite believing in the 'suicide' of Jesusas the Christians profess-could not save themselves from immoralities, and nor could the Jesus' grandmothers do so, it conclusively proves that such false Atonement cannot save anyone from carnal desires, nor could it save Jesus himself. Look how he followed

Satan,6 while it was most unbecoming of him to do so.

Perhaps it was because of this that he was filled with such remorse that when someone hailed him as 'good' not accept that Satan lured Jesus and took him up on a mountain, for they do not believe in the embodiment of Satan. In fact, they don't believe in Satan's existence at all. However, regardless of what these philosophers think, one objection is certainly valid, that had this episode taken place in the mountains inhabited by the Jews and on the paths they frequented, then, of a necessity, not only Jesus but many Jews would also have seen that particular Satan. And without doubt, Satan would not have looked like ordinary humans but would have appeared as a bizarre creature, likely to amaze the onlookers. Thus, if Jesus had really seen Satan in the conscious state, it is inevitable that thousands of Jews would have done so as well, and a crowd would have gathered. But nothing of the kind happened. European researchers, therefore, cannot accept it as an objective phenomenon. On the other hand, it is because of such absurd fantasies-including the claim of Jesus' divinity-that they salute the Gospels from a safe distance. Recently a European scholar has expressed the following opinion about the Gospels of the Christians. He says that all that is required to convince a sensible person that the Gospels are the creation of the human mind-and a wild creation at that-is simply to ask him to read it. This gentleman further says, 'Read the Gospel as an ordinary book, remove the blindfold of reverence from your eyes, drive away the spectre of fear from your heart and free your mind of superstitions; if you study the Gospel having done all this, you will wonder how you could, even for a moment, have considered he stopped him and said, 'Do not call me good.' How

·

10 of 10 left today