Published in English

Truth About the Split, Part 2

controversial tracts addressed to individual persons or

containing personal references. It was he who only a

has sought to cover his mistake by a lie". "As if he (referring to the writer) would sometimes make a false statement for fear of stating a controversy". In his book Tabdil-e-‘Aqida ka llzam, (which is a reply to my tract Muhammad Ali Sahib ki Tabdil-e-‘Aqida Maulawi Muhammad Ali writes: "Miyań Sahib (meaning the present writer) and his disciples consider it light to be Athim (sinner) or Azlam (extreme wrongdoer), but deem it as worse than death to bear witness to truth, therefore they have refused to make a statement of the truth"... "These black hearted criminals did not see"... "May not this party be the representatives of those whom you, till yesterday, considered to be the worst of all the dwellers on earth"... "You may call and inquire of these men who are blind of moral vision, who give the name of apostates to the servants of the faith, whether such rashness on their part in face of the public declaration of a person will not make them liable to the curse of God"... "If the Pir is truthful than his party are proved to be deceivers of mankind, On the other hand, if the party represents the creed taught by the true religion then the Pir been an advocate of falsehood"... "Today, to deny these facts will serve not only to besmirch their faces, but it is certain that persistence in the denial will blacken their hearts and bring upon them the divine curse, and prove them to be fit objects of the appellaton: "Ye who apostatised after being believers".

few days before the death of Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , at a time when his condition was very precarious, wrote a tract containing his opinions on some points of controversy. But as he was afraid that if the matter came to the notice of Khalifatul Masih I (ra) his design would be undone, so with the utmost circumspection and cleverness, he had the tract printed and published in Lahore and did neither read it out to Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , nor inform him of its purport, nor consult him about its subject matter. This was contrary to the usual practice of Ahmadis who, as a rule always consulted and obtained the previous sanction of their Khalifa whenever any book or announcement was to be published on any controversial subject, or on any important issue. It was in accordance with this rule that Khwaja Kamaluddin submitted to Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , all his articles on the question of Kufr and Islam. Similarly before publishing anything on the subject of the Cawnpore Mosque disturbances, the authorities of the Paigham-e-Sulh of Lahore sent a special agent to Khalifatul Masih I (ra) to ascertain his views. It is of course another matter whether those views were also correctly reported later on, or not. The fact remains that a certain deference was paid to the Khalifa. But in the case of this tract Maulawi Muhammad Ali did not care to make even the barest mention of it to Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , although as a matter of fact he had in that tract attempted an extraordinary interpretation of the Khalifa’s Will. At the least he might have consulted the Khalifa regarding the interpretation of the Will to find out whether his own views on the subject agreed with those of the Khalifa. But Maulawi Muhammad Ali did not choose to adopt this course and preferred the way of secrecy. The same course was also adopted in the matter of the publication of the tract. He did not have it printed at Qadian, but sent it all the way to Lahore for printing it, although two or three presses were available for the purpose at Qadian, none of which could complain of pressure of work. Then at Lahore the tract was not published as soon as it was printed. It was held back in anticipation of the day when Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , should depart from life, so that whatever had been said regarding him in the tract should remain unrefuted.

In short, it was Maulawi Muhammad Ali who came first into the lists with a work in which a reference was made to me and to my friends attributing to us beliefs which he said were impious and inconsistent with holy life. In all his subsequent writings also he has continued to refer to us in the same discourteous manner. His contemptuous mention of my name has been of a kind not sanctioned by honourable men while making personal references. In the work under reply, although there are comparatively fewer instances of such verbal strictures, yet the author has not failed to apply to me such opprobrious epithets as Zal (pervert) and Muzil (one who causes others to go astray from the path of Islam), as will be noticed by every reader of the book. In the same book the author has mentioned my name as M. Mahmud. It is not clear what he means by that form of address. I shall, however, continue to deal honourably with him, and although the insulting tone which he has assumed and which seems to grow more and more unbearable, calls for the use of stronger language. I shall take care not to imitate him or to transgress the bounds of propriety.

10 of 10 left today