Alleged Innovations
Truth About the Split, Part 2
Community into false beliefs viz. (i) that all the followers of the Qibla professing the Kalima (the Muslim formula of faith) are unbelievers and outside the pale of Islam, (ii) that the Promised Messiah (as) is a full and real Prophet, not a partial Prophet or a Muhaddath (iii) that the prophecy relating to Ahmad (Al-Tahrim, 66: 6) is for the Promised Messiah (as) and not for the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa) . (10) The learned Sayyid was not the only one who made such a declaration. Many educated persons had done the same before him in the Paigham-e-Sulh and besides them other educated Ahmadis were realising the great error into which the Community was being led and their dissatisfaction with the beliefs taught by me was becoming more and more pronounced every day. (11) But there was one step which, according to Maulawi Muhammad Ali, I took in the beginning and by which I have succeeded in keeping my section of the Community in the dark. I condemned the opposing section of Ahmadis (i.e. friends of Muhammad Ali) as Fasiqs and prohibited my followers from having any relations with the members of that section, so much so, that they were forbidden to take food with them at the same table or to have friendly relations with them or to read any literature issued by them. Thus, my followers remained generally ignorant of the arguments which were given against the novel beliefs which I was teaching and, being ignorant, they thought that my teachings were not different from those of the Promised Messiah (as).
These are the eleven points raised by Maulawi Muhammad Ali in describing the history of the dissensions. Before entering upon a discussion of the merits of the beliefs which divide us, I wish to deal with these points in order to make it clear to the readers, unacquainted with these matters how far our opponents have been regardful of truth and facts.
Was Zahiruddin the Originator of
Ahmadiyya Dissensions?
In describing the history of the dissensions, the first misstatement made by Maulawi Muhammad Ali is that the disputed beliefs had their origin in one M. Zahiruddin who in April 1911 wrote a book named Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur and thus laid the foundation of the belief in the Nubuwwat (prophethood) of the Promised Messiah (as). I wish to point out that in making this statement Maulawi Muhammad Ali has done a plain violence to truth. Muhammad Zahiruddin is too small a person to be the author of the belief in the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as). Was he present with the Hoy Prophet (sa) when the latter said that the Masih Ibni Maryam to come would be a Nabi? Was it M. Zahiruddin who put these words into the mouth of the Holy Prophet? Were the words—revealed to the Promised Messiah (as)—'A Nabi came to the world but the world accepted him not, etc. etc' revealed to him by God or by M. Zahiruddin? To attribute these words to a person as ignorant, benighted and full of self-conceit as M. Zahiruddin is nothing less than a blasphemy against the Divine words and against the Holy Prophet (sa) . I may even ask—Was there any Ahmadi present with the Holy Prophet (sa) when he declared the Nubuwwat of the Promised Messiah (as)?
Moreover, let us all remember that long before the publication of Zahiruddin’s book I had announced the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as). If Zahiruddin was really the originator of the doctrine I may well inquire—how was it that full five years before the publication of this book, and during the lifetime of the Promised Messiah (as), I could describe the Promised Messiah (as) as a Nabi, in my writings? How was it that Maulawi Muhammad Ali himself could commend those writings of mine which contained open reference to the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as) and even cite them in proof of the truth of the Promised Messiah (as). Maulawi Muhammad Ali admits that M. Zahiruddin’s book had been finished in April 1911, and thinks that it must therefore have been written towards the close of 1910 or in the early months of 1911. The book contains 120 pages of small size and might have taken at the most a month in writing. But even assuming Maulawi Muhammad Ali’s estimate to be correct, it may well be asked how could the contents of this book published in 1911, have possibly been, known to me in 1906, when I so emphatically declared the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as)? What I say relates to the year 1905 when I was only seventeen years old. In that year in collaboration with the late Shaikh Abdur Rahim of Malerkotla, Chaudhary Fateh Muhammad Siyal M. A—later Muslim Missionary—and some other students, I decided to publish a periodical to advance the cause of the Movement and to create in the younger members zeal for the service of religion.
Accordingly after securing the approval of the Promised Messiah (as) and requesting him to select a suitable name for the periodical, we published the same under the name Tashhidhul Adhhan. At the instance of these friends I myself undertook the editing of it. The first number was issued on the 1st March 1906. In the introductory article written by me and published in the first number, I made mention of the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as) and explicitly called him by the name of Nabi. On page 10 of that issue, writing about the Promised Messiah (as) and addressing the people of the world in general I wrote: "Do you think that because you belong to a great nation or because you possess gold and jewels, or because you have a large following, or because you are a millionaire or a king or a scholar or head of a pious foundation or a fakir—that there is, therefore, no need for you to obey this Rasul?" Again in the same article on page 11 of that issue I wrote: "Only a few have accepted him, most have rejected him. This has been the Divine rule in the case of all previous Ambiya’; and the same has been the case now." Similarly on page 8, I wrote: "In short, every nation has been expecting a Nabi and the time assigned for his advent is the one we are now in, Our beloved Prophet Muhammad (sa) mentioned certain signs which were to mark the advent of this Nabi and in other ways made it easy for us to recognise him. Such predictions go to prove how high and great the rank is of our Prophet." Similarly on pages 5 and 6, I wrote: "We are now to see whether or not there is any need for a Nabi to appear in this age, and whether we should call this age a good or an evil one. So far as can be seen, no age of the world has exceeded the present in vice and crime.
The whole world has been crying with one voice that the high water mark of iniquity has been reached. This is the age which more than any other stands in need of a Divine Messenger." This article was so much approved by Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , that in the mosque he urged many people, among them Khwaja Kamaluddin, to read it. He also praised the article in the presence of the Promised Messiah (as). But perhaps such encomiums by the Khalifatul Masih (ra) will not be so convincing to Maulawi Muhammad Ali as his own remarks. He may therefore look upon the comments which he himself made on this article in the Review of Religions while reviewing the Tashhidhul Adhhan. Those comments bear sufficient testimony to the nature of the views then entertained by him. He wrote: "The editor of the magazine is Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmud Ahmad, son of the Promised Messiah (as). In the first number there is an introductory article from his pen running over 14 pages. The article will, of course, be read in due course by members of our Movement but what I wish to do is to cite this article before the opponents of our Movement as a manifest evidence of the truth of the Movement. The article purports to say that when disorders prevail, on the earth and the majority of the people abandon the path of God, and betake themselves to the path of vice, and sit down like vultures to feast on the carrion of a dead world forgetful altogether of the life to come, at such a time it is always the rule with God that from among the same people He raises a Nabi to remind the people of the time of His true teachings and to point out to the people the right way to Him. Then such of them as have been blinded by their vices in the intoxication of material enjoyment, either laugh at the words of the Nabi, or persecute him and his followers, and seek to overthrow his Movement.
But since the Movement is founded by God, it cannot be destroyed by the machinations of man. On the contrary, the Nabi even under such circumstances informs his adversaries in advance that it is they who will ultimately be overthrown and that a portion of them will be destroyed and making of them an example God will guide the rest to the right faith. All these prophecies come to pass as predicted. This is the rule with God, which has always held true, and the same has happened in the present case. "These were the remarks made by Maulawi Muhammad Ali on my article published as introductory to the Tashhidhul Adhhan on the 1st March 1906 during the lifetime of the Promised Messiah (as). After this I may leave it to every fair-minded reader to consider for himself the question that if it is true, as is stated by Maulawi Muhammad Ali, that the belief in the Nubuwwat (prophethood) of the Promised Messiah (as) was an invention of M. Zahiruddin and that the Promised Messiah (as) was not a Nabi, then how could it be that, as early as 1906, while the Promised Messiah (as) was yet alive, it was already known to me that he was a Nabi and I attached so much importance to the point that I made it the central theme of my introductory article in the Tashhidhul Adhhan that just as in the past Ambiya’ had been raised by God so also in this age there was need for another Prophet and he was no other than the Promised Messiah (as)? But I may waive the question for a while and assume that even then I was acting under the influence of M. Zahiruddin and it was at his suggestion that I spoke of the Promised Messiah (as) as a Nabi but there still remains the other question viz. how was it that in reviewing the article a writer of Maulawi Muhammad Ali’s experience, who now poses as the sole mandatory for the reform of the Community, should have expressed himself in such laudatory terms?
In that article I had said very explicitly that the Promised Messiah (as) was a Nabi and had said so not once or twice but quite a number of times, and had moreover added that it was the Promised Messiah’s (as) claim that God had vouchsafed to him His revelations just as he did to Adam (as), or Noah (as) or Abraham (as) or Moses (as) or Jesus (as) or Muhammad (sa) . [Tashhidhul Adhhan No. I, Vol. I, page 1—9]. If it had been a fact that at that time the members of the Community did not regard the Promised Messiah (as) as a Nabi, then my words should have come to Maulawi Muhammad Ali as an unpleasant surprise, inasmuch as in the said article another person after the Holy Prophet (sa) had been styled a Nabi. It is not open to Maulawi Muhammad Ali to say that he had reviewed my article without proper scrutiny because in his review he was able to quote a summary of my article in my own words. He must, therefore, have read at least that portion of the article which he had quoted and even in this portion there was mention of the Promised Messiah (as) as a Nabi. If the belief in his Nubuwwat had been promulgated after the death of the Promised Messiah (as), then it was only natural that Maulawi Muhammad Ali should have raised a cry of protest on coming across such a claim in my article. But on the contrary, we find him referring to it as a miracle of the Promised Messiah (as) that there should arise such a noble thought in the bosom of one of his children at an age when young men are apt to be occupied with play, which fact according to Maulawi Muhammad
Ali was proof of the complete unison between the public and private life of the Promised Messiah (as), since such unison alone could produce a deep impression upon the young mind of a child. All this, however, has now changed. According to the present opinion of Maulawi Muhammad Ali, my views published in the Tashhidhul Adhhan are highly dangerous, dark and full of error. In other words, the article had put the axe at the root of Islam and things had been said in it which in the opinion of Maulawi Muhammad Ali were to prove the source of a dissension hitherto unknown in Islam. The article was a poison cup intended to destroy all spiritual life. What therefore was meet was not to refer to it as a miracle, but to greet it with execration and abhorrence and instead of saying that such excellent views of his son proved the truth of the Promised Messiah (as), Maulawi Muhammad Ali should have likened me to the son of Noah and seriously warned the people not to be deceived by my doctrines, which were not those taught by the Promised Messiah (as), who never claimed to be a Nabi and never intended that the term should be applied to him. He might have gone even further. Apprehensive of the harm that was likely to be caused to Islam by my article, he might have gone to the Promised Messiah (as) crying and lamenting and told him of the mischief that had been done and might have urged that I should be expelled from the Community. By this means he might have saved the Community from a grave calamity and won a great reward. But on the contrary we find at that time Maulawi Muhammad Ali heartily commending my views.
May we now ask whether at that time Maulawi Muhammad Ali himself was one of that undiscerning set of admirers regarding whom he wrote "Being brought up within the narrow circle of admirers of his father, he contracted the narrow views which fall to the lot of young men brought up under similar circumstances" (The Split p. 23), or was it that he was aiming merely at flattering me when he wrote the remarks quoted above? Or, was he aware that the Promised Messiah (as) really claimed to be a Nabi, but feared that as he was still alive a rejection of his prophethood might lead to an exposure of his (the Maulawi’s) own secret thoughts and the discovery of the truth? Or, was it also his own conviction at that time that the Promised Messiah (as) was really a Nabi'! These are the only three possible motives which could have actuated Maulawi Muhammad Ali when he commended my views. One would naturally feel curious to ask which of them it was that inspired his action? Was it a desire to humour me? Was it the fear of an exposure? Or was it real personal conviction? For myself, I am disposed to think that at that time Maulawi Muhammad Ali honestly shared the conviction that the Promised Messiah (as) was a Nabi. To attribute the origin of the doctrine to M. Zahiruddin is thus a very unhappy invention on the part of Maulawi Muhammad Ali. Maulawi Muhammad Ali had a passing fancy and proceeded to use it as a foundation to build upon it an airy castle. As a matter of fact the Ahmadiyya Community has since the lifetime of the Promised Messiah (as) recognised him as a Nabi. In particular, Maulawi Muhammad Ali as well as myself have alike borne written testimony to this conviction and the only difference between us is that I have up to this time remained faithful to my old convictions while Maulawi Muhammad Ali has already retracted them.
In connection with this changed attitude of Maulawi Muhammad Ali, it is remarkable how close a parallel it offers to the case of Maulawi Muhammad Husain of Batala, one of the greatest opponent of the Promised Messiah (as). The latter also in the early years of the Promised Messiah’s (as) career held up to universal admiration the very revelations of the Promised Messiah which later on he pronounced to be heretical, and in his review of the Promised
Messiah’s (as) work Brahin-e-Ahmadiyya attributed to it an excellence nothing short of the miraculous. Regarding the said work he wrote. "In my opinion it (Brahin-e-Ahmadiyya) is a book the like of which has not up till now been produced in the history of Islam… and its author has proved himself such a loyal steadfast servant of Islam offering in its service his wealth, life, pen and tongue, that an example equal to his it is hard to find even among the early Muslims. If there is any one who is disposed to consider my words a mere oriental exaggeration, then I would request him to mention at least one book of like merit." And similarly the greatest opponent of the Promised Successor of the Promised Messiah (as) in reviewing in early years an article by that Successor containing views, stigmatised later as false by that very opponent, has expressed himself in the following laudatory words. "The editor of the magazine is Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmud Ahmad, son of the Promised Messiah (as). In the first number there is an introductory article from his pen running over 14 pages. The article will be read in due course by members of the Movement but what I propose to do here is to cite before the opponents of the Movement, this same article as a manifest proof of the truth of the Movement." Further on he wrote alluding to the same article. ''But the intense love for religion and zeal for the service of Islam so transparent in the above unvarnished words are some-thing miraculous." He continued: "Now let those black-hearted people who call Mirza Sahib an impostor answer this question: If all this is an imposture then whence arose this genuine zeal in the heart of this young boy? Falsehood is dirt and ought to produce only obnoxious fruits and not something so pure and beautiful of which we can hardly find a parallel." Again he wrote: "Consider whether we can ever deem him an impostor whose teaching and training have produced such a fruit." [The Review of Religions (Urdu ed.), Vol. V, p. 119]. Thus it would appear that there is a most extraordinary coincidence between the case of Maulawi Muhammad Ali and that of Maulawi Muhammad Husain of Batala. Bold indeed must be the man who can say that such a coincidence was there without a Divine purpose. The hand of God can clearly be seen at work behind the two conjunctions of circumstances. "A sufficient matter for reflection for any one who will reflect."