Alleged Innovations
Truth About the Split, Part 3
In short, it is incorrect to say that it was from M. Zahiruddin that I first derived this belief in the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as). The facts are that some five years before the publication of M.
Zahiruddin’s book, and during the lifetime of the Promised Messiah (as) in my introductory article in the Tashhidhul Adhhan I had already declared the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as), and Maulawi Muhammad Ali had commended that very article and published a summary of the same in his own magazine The Review of Religions (Urdu edn), and Maulawi Sahib referred to my views as a miracle of the Promised Messiah (as), and used the same as an argument against the opponents of the Movement. All these facts are sufficient to prove that at that time Maulawi Muhammad Ali himself believed that the Promised Messiah (as) was really a Nabi. Nor was the article the only one published by me. There were also others in which I mentioned the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as). For example, one of my article was published in The Badr of 10th May 1906, which concluded with the following words:
"For God’s sake take warning and bow down your heads in humility before Him, and supplicate His true Rasul saying (Oh Messiah! pray to God for our safety from the epidemic.)" (The Badr, 10th May 1906, page 8).
Again, on page 10 of the Badr of 1st May, 1906, in my article entitled Al-Hakam and Watan there occurred the sentence "The earth and the Heavens may pass away but the word of this divine Nabi can never fail of fulfilment."
These two quotations also serve to show that even in the lifetime of the Promised Messiah (as) I entertained the belief that he was a Nabi, and that I did not keep the conviction a secret in my own bosom but availed myself of every opportunity to declare it in public.
After quoting these references published during the lifetime of the Promised Messiah (as), I would now quote some others published after the death of the Promised Messiah (as), so that it may be clear to all seekers of truth that at no time has it been my policy to make a secret of my convictions, nor have 1 ever been slow to give publicity to them. On the contrary, ever since I have begun to write, I have repeatedly brought these views to the notice of the public and my writings from, first article on the subject up to now, form a long, connected and continuous series without a link missing.
The most important events in the history of the Community subsequent to the death of the Promised Messiah (as) are of course those which immediately followed his death. Agreeably to the Divine rule in the case of the Promised Messiah (as) as in the case of the previous Ambiya’, his death took place under circumstances which led his enemies to believe that the work which he had set out to accomplish would now be completely undone. Even some of the professed Ahmadis were shaken much as the tribes of Arabia were shaken on the occasion of the death of the Holy Prophet (sa) . In view of such circumstances, it was felt necessary in order to frustrate the attacks of enemies and to strengthen the hearts of friends that steps should be taken to allay those doubts and misgivings which the opponents of the Promised Messiah (as) sought to create regarding his work. Accordingly, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) as well as many other Ahmadis including myself wrote articles refuting the objections raised by the opponents. One of my articles was published in the Tashhidhul Adhhan of June and July 1908, and was also issued separately as a booklet. It was named "Sadiqoń Ki Raushni Ku Kaun Dur Kar Sakta Hai" (Who Can Extinguish the Light of the Righteous) by Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , acting under the direction of a revelation. The book and the magazine were largely circulated both among Ahmadis and non-Ahmadis, with a view to counteracting the doubts and misgivings which the enemies of the Promised Messiah (as) had sought to create after his death. In this little book, at no less than 22 places I called the Promised Messiah (as) by the name of Nabi.
It is not necessary here to quote all the passages in full. The interested reader may consult the book itself for his satisfaction. Here I wish to quote only a few lines by way of example. This will suffice to convince the reader how in this book the Promised Messiah (as) was called a Nabi by me: (Tashhidhul Adhhan Vol. 3 page 217)—"Well, if they should still persist in their denial, then what else can one do than say in the words of the Promised Messiah’s (as) revelation i.e.
"There came a Nabi and spent days and nights grieving for the people till he departed from this life. But still the people persisted in their denial." We do not pray to God for the destruction of these unbelievers; we have anguish in our hearts for their sake and a yearning that God may grant to them His guidance and the grace to recognise His Nabi. They may mock and scoff at us but we would still pray for them "God Omnipotent! Thou knowest our hearts and art aware how sorely stricken they are for the sake of these erring ones. Thou Knower of the unseen and the manifest! Mark our sufferings and have pity on us and relieve us of our woe and inform our brethren of the path of Thy guidance, the path of light which Thy
Nabi has opened for us and grant them the grace to recognise the same."
Thus, at a time when the death of the Promised Messiah (as) had thrown the whole Ahmadiyya Community into a spasm of grief, the fact that I repeatedly called him a Nabi while Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , Maulawi Muhammad Ali himself, and all the other members of the Community raised not a voice against my action, rather on the contrary, they looked upon it with approving eyes conclusively proves that it was at that time, not only my own conviction but a conviction of the Community as a whole that the Promised Messiah (as) was a Nabi.
Similarly, on the occasion of the Annual Conference of the year held in April 1909, the speech delivered by me contained the following words. This speech was published both in The Badr and in the Tashhidhul Adhhan. Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , was in the chair, I said: "This Divine promise was not made to us in order that we might believe in the death of Jesus (as); rather, God promised to us through His Rasul, the Promised Messiah (as) that if we should make a purchase similar to what was made by the previous people, then we too should receive a similar favoured treatment" (Tashhidhul Adhhan, February 1909, p.
28). Further on I said, "God is no tyrant. We may look to ourselves and observe that one of His Ambiya’ came to us and left us having done his work." (p.39). Later on, I again spoke on the same subject in the Annual Conference held in December, 1910, This speech was published in the Badr of 19th January, 1911. In this speech also I laid special stress upon the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as), which point might be said to have been the central topic of the whole discourse. The reason for this lay in the following circumstances. In 1910, my respected and valued friend Mufti Muhammad Sadiq, and Maulawi Sadruddin, one of the friends of Maulawi Muhammad Ali, were sent out on a missionary tour. In the course of their tour they had occasion to meet Maulawi Shibli, the well-known founder of the Nadwatul Ulema. In the conversation that ensued, mention was made of the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as). In answer to a question by Maulawi Shibli the two gentlemen said that they called the Promised Messiah (as) a Nabi in the strictly literal sense of the word. Although the answer was quite accurate, seeing that the literal significance and the theological connotation of the term Nabi are identical, yet the form of the answer conveyed a certain impression that the word Nabi bore a certain technical meaning when used by the Divine Being. It seemed to me undesirable that such a dubious mode of expression should find general currency in the Community. The apprehension was further deepened when I marked that during that year a number of Ahmadis had mixed themselves up with some of the secular topics of the day (e.g. agitation over the Muslim University question) and were gradually breaking away from the central purpose of the Movement. This knowledge made me resolve to draw the special attention of the Community to this question on the occasion of the Annual Conference. Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , was not present during the speech, but Khwaja Kamaluddin, Maulawi Muhammad Ali, and Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan were all present. In the presence of these gentlemen and before the Community at large I spoke on the point, and that speech of mine clearly shows that I had all along believed the Promised Messiah (as) to be a Nabi. A few extracts from the speech which was published in the Badr of 19th January, 1911, may be quoted.
"He is God who out of His bounty granted to you the grace to follow a Nabi."
Again referring to the difference between Ahmadis and non-Ahmadis, I said: "I have seen two dealers trafficking in the same article, each averring with reference to his own goods 'sir! my goods are of a special quality.' But in your case you may even point to an obvious difference between the two parties. Nevertheless, there are those among you who will say 'No, no, there is no difference'. What, is it no difference that you follow a Nabi whereas the other party rejects that Nabi?"
"Remember also that Mirza Sahib was a Nabi and that this rank of Nubuwwat he attained by following closely the Holy Prophet (sa) who was the Khatamun Nabiyyin (the Seal of the Prophets), and I do not know how many others there are who may be destined to attain to the same rank. Why should we not call him Nabi whom God called Nabi? We may see in one of his later revelations God addressing him saying: