Alleged Innovations
Truth About the Split, Part 4
(O Nabi! feed the hungry and the poor).
"Whoever considers even a single word of the Promised Messiah (as) to be false is rejected of God, because God does not keep any of His Nabis in error till the time of his death."
"Why would you renounce one mark which distinguishes you from others. You have accepted a Nabi, one who was the elect of God; while your opponents have rejected him. In the lifetime of the Promised Messiah (as) a suggestion was made that Ahmadis and non-Ahmadis might work together in the preaching of Islam. But the Promised Messiah (as) asked "Which Islam will you preach to the world? Will you hide the signs which God has vouchsafed to you and conceal the favours which He has shown to you?"
"Even so, one Nabi came to us from God. If we follow him we shall be the recipients of the same rewards which were promised to the Companions of the Holy Prophet (sa)."
From these passages it is evident what my convictions were regarding the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as). The speech was delivered in the presence of Khwaja Kamaluddin, Maulawi Muhammad Ali and Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan. They had particular reason for being present at the time, as my speech was to be followed by the reading of the Annual Report of the Sadr Anjuman Ahmadiyya and the appeal for contributions, and they were all members of the Anjuman. Thus, it would appear that none of them could plead want of knowledge of my views on the subject of the Promised Messiah’s (as) prophethood.
From the above it should also be evident that all my writings from the year 1906 to December 1910 go to prove that I had all along believed the Promised Messiah (as) to be a Nabi. Later on, in March 1911, I wrote an article on the status of those who did not believe in the Promised Messiah (as). This was published in the April issue of the Tashhidhul Adhhan and in the Badr of 4th May 1911, and Al-Hakam of 14th May 1911. This was followed by a long succession of writings and lectures on the subject, knowledge of which has not been denied and cannot be denied even by Maulawi Muhammad Ali.
In the light of the above facts, I would now ask every fair-minded reader to say whether it could be said or even imagined that the influence of
Zahiruddin’s teachings and particularly a study of his book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur led me to a belief in the Nubuwwat of the Promised Messiah (as). This book, on the admission of Maulawi Muhammad Ali himself, is the first book written by Zahiruddin on the subject of the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as). Maulawi Muhammad Ali also admits that the writing of the book was completed in April 1911. On the last page of the book there is a note saying 'Finished writing, the 26th of April, 1911,' and on the same page there is another note 'This is by the publisher Chaudhary Barkat Ali' from which it appears that the book was sent to the press on some date subsequent to the 5th July 1911. On the other hand, it may be observed that my article on the subject of 'Kufr or Islam' of non- Ahmadis, which was in fact not the first but the last article on the above controversy (as has been already explained), was published in the Tashhidhul Adhhan of April 1911 and, as will appear from the following quotation from the Badr of 15th April 1911, had been written in March 1911. The learned editor of the Badr in one of his replies to Maulawi Sanaullah published in the Badr of 16th April 1911, while explaining his views regarding the status of non-Ahmadis, wrote as follows: "On this subject Hadrat Sahibzadah Mahmud Ahmad Sahib has already written an elaborate article and submitted the same to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) . It is to be hoped that every important aspect of the question will be found thoroughly discussed in that article." It is a general rule with newspapers that they bear a date one day in advance of the actual date of publication, that is, they bear the date on which they are made over to the post office.
Thus this number of The Badr must have been actually written on 15th April, 1911. The editor remarked that the article was already before Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , from which it would appear that the article had been submitted to the Khalifatul Masih (ra) sometime before the writing of this note. It may therefore be concluded that the article was written in March 1911. The question therefore arises—How could my article which was written in March 1911 and published in the following month, be the result of M. Zahiruddin’s book which was written in April 1911 and published in July 1911? And what can be said regarding the honesty of an author who, though fully aware of the respective dates of the two writings, does nevertheless, only in order to mislead and misguide people living in distant parts of the world, proceed to state that the work which was written one month after my last article on the subject of the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as) and published three months after the same, was the origin and source from which I had derived my views. Can a person be deemed worthy of calling people to faith who does not himself shrink from practising deception in matters of faith? A man who has no scruples while indulging in such a distortion of facts can hardly be a fit person to invite others to truth.
I really wonder how Maulawi Muhammad Ali could venture to state that M. Zahiruddin’s book was the origin of my writings, and his beliefs the source of my inspiration. He admits that my article on 'Kufr or Islam' was published in April 1911, and the note—quoted above—in the Badr bears ample testimony to the fact that it had been written in the month of March preceding. On the other hand, in the book written by M. Zahiruddin on the page which bears the note referred to by Maulawi Muhammad Ali and only four lines below the note is to be found the statement that the work was published in July 1911. The date—5th July 1911—has in fact been noted in bolder type than that in which has been printed the date quoted by Maulawi Muhammad Ali. In view of facts so obvious, and in spite of possessing full knowledge regarding them, the statement of Maulawi Muhammad Ali that it was Zahiruddin’s book which inspired my article could not but be due to a design on his part to mislead his unwary readers. Errors of reasoning may be assigned to some honest mistake, but the manipulation of a long series of facts and their presentation in a distorted manner cannot be ascribed to any such mistake. The fact of the matter is that M. Zahiruddin by reason of his obnoxious beliefs had deviated far from the true teaching of Islam and Maulawi Muhammad Ali thought that if somehow or other he could trace my beliefs to the influence of Zahiruddin, there would result a general disinclination in the public mind for my beliefs, while a corresponding inclination would result for the beliefs advocated by Maulawi Sahib. It is, however, futile for him to entertain such a hope for who could succeed in throwing dust at the moon or in concealing a light describing it as darkness!
As I have already proved and, as is well known to Maulawi Muhammad Ali himself, though he may not find it convenient to admit it in public, belief in the Nubuwwat of the Promised Messiah (as) has been entertained and openly advocated by me since the lifetime of the Promised Messiah (as). After his death, during the years 1908, 1909 and 1910, to be quite precise, the belief was preached by me continuously through my various writings. My last contribution on the subject, which to suit his ends Maulawi
Muhammad Ali has described as the first, was written one month before the book by M. Zahiruddin was written and three months before it was published. Under the circumstances, to describe Zahiruddin as the source of my inspiration and the author of beliefs which I advocate, is a travesty of facts of which there are but few parallels in the world. The author of the belief is the Promised Messiah (as) or rather, we may, say, the Holy Prophet (sa) himself who spoke of the Promised Messiah (as) as a Nabi. We may go even further and say that the author of the belief is God Himself, in as much as He it is who addressed the Promised Messiah (as) as Nabi.
We know there are Christian historians who, blinded by prejudice, seek to deceive the world by affirming that Islam was the product of the collective deliberation of certain little known persons of the time of the Holy Prophet (sa) . Their rashness in making such a statement is, however, put in the shade by the hardihood displayed in this instance by Maulawi Muhammad Ali. For, as the proverb goes, 'Bold must be the thief who goes with a light in his hand'. Christian historians seek to distort things which happened a long time ago, while Maulawi Muhammad Ali speaking about views which he himself endorsed in 1906, which have since been continuously promulgated, and of which he has been well aware himself, now seeks to assign their origin to a book published in 1911!