Factors Relating to Zahiruddin’s Expulsion

Truth About the Split

We now proceed to the next point in Maulawi Muhammad Ali’s narrative of the history of the dissensions. He writes: "Much notice of the book was not taken by the Ahmadiyya Community. But probably the contents of the book or some other leaflet on the same subject were brought to the notice of the first Khalifa. Upon this, there was some correspondence between the Khalifa and Zahiruddin and as a result an announcement was made by the Khalifa to the effect that as Muhammad Zahiruddin was promulgating new doctrines he was not to be considered as having any connection with the Ahmadiyya Community. "(The Ahmadiyya Movement, part IV, The Split, by Maulawi Muhammad Ali).

The following points deserve special attention in the above statement;

(i) The contents of the book—Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur—or some other leaflet on the same subject were brought to the notice of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) .

(ii) This led to some correspondence between Khalifatul Masih I (ra) and Zahiruddin. Apparently this means that after reading the book or some other leaflet, Khalifatul Masih I (ra) wrote to Zahiruddin.

(iii) When nothing fruitful resulted from the correspondence, Khalifatul Masih I (ra) made an announcement to the effect that as Muhammad Zahiruddin was promulgating new beliefs he was not to be considered as having any connection with the Ahmadiyya Community.

Before entering upon a systematic refutation of these statements, I wish to say at once that all these statements are incorrect and have been made designedly with a view to misleading the public.

There is no doubt that M. Zahiruddin now entertains beliefs repugnant to the teachings of Islam and of the Promised Messiah (as), but no such beliefs found a place in the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur nor was the book at all looked upon with disfavour by the Ahmadiyya Community. Maulawi Muhammad Ali says that the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur or some other leaflet on the same subject was brought to the notice of Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , who was therefore displeased with it. This statement is altogether unfounded. Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) was not displeased with the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur. Evidence of this will be seen in the facts narrated below.

In the years 1911 and 1912, some tracts were published by two men named Maulawi Yar Muhammad and Abdullah Timapuri. Each of these men claimed to be the Imam (leader) of the Community under special authority from God. There was therefore some danger of people being deceived by their tracts and notices. Hence, Khalifatul Masih I (ra) was obliged to make an announcement against them in one of his speeches. But the words used by him in the announcement were general and only Abdullah Timapuri was mentioned by name. The words of the announcement were as follows:

"Again, there are young men who are in too great a hurry to write books although they possess neither the wisdom nor the insight required by an author. Mere fancies are of little avail so long as one does not get into touch with facts. Such writings give rise to dissension. If, therefore, difficulties should arise, one ought to seek help from God and have recourse to prayer.

I would warn our members to shun such people. There is a number of them who go about giving publicity to their pretensions." (The Badr 25th January 1912)

When the above was published, friends of Maulawi Muhammad Ali, namely Khwaja Kamaluddin, Dr. Ya‘qub Baig, Dr. Muhammad Husain and others gave out that the announcement was concerning M. Zahiruddin’s book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur. Zahiruddin thereupon in a letter to Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , made the inquiry whether the Khalifatul Masih (ra) had made any such announcement about his book. In reply, the Khalifatul Masih (ra) wrote to him saying that the announcement did not appertain to his book but to notices issued by Maulawi Yar Muhammad and Abdullah Timapuri. Subsequently we find M. Zahiruddin in his letter dated 22nd June 1912 to Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , referring to the Khalifa’s assurance in the following words: "Your favour is to hand. In reply I beg to submit that if in making the announcement the men you had in mind were only Abdullah Timapuri and Maulawi Yar Muhammad, then it would have been well to mention the names of the two men in the announcement as it would have saved people from all risk of misunderstanding. In answer to this letter Khalifatul Masih (ra) wrote: "You said that it contained a reference to you. I answered that it contained no reference to you, and contrary to my views of what is proper in such cases. I mentioned to you the names of the persons to whom my announcement referred. But in spite of that you have now declared in very plain words that you are opposed to the beliefs entertained by Nuruddin (meaning himself)" [letter of Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , dated 11th July 1912]. This correspondence was published in Al-Hakam, the oldest organ of the Movement, on 14th October 1912, i.e. in the lifetime of Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , and it is from the same journal (pages 6 and 7) that the above excerpts have been made.

A perusal of the two excerpts will make it clear to the reader that in making the statement that Khalifatul Masih I (ra) disapproved of Zahirudin’s book and held a correspondence with him on the subject Maulawi Muhammad Ali has not been faithful to facts. For, as is evident from the correspondence held between Khalifatul Masih I (ra) and Zahiruddin, Khalifatul Masih I (ra) denied the fact that he had made any announcement adverse to the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur. If it was a fact that the correspondence had originated from a perusal and disapproval of the book, then what need was there for Zahiruddin to refer to the announcement in order to prove the Khalifa’s displeasure, for in that case the letter of the Khalifa itself could have served as sufficient evidence of the Khalifa’s displeasure. But instead of referring to any such letter, we find Zahiruddin writing to the Khalifa that he had made an announcement against Zahiruddin’s book, which fact we find was being denied by the Khalifa. The latter wrote that the announcement had in view the notices circulated by certain men and in order to substantiate his word he had, contrary to his usual practice, mentioned even the names of those against whom the announcement had been made. These facts are sufficient to prove chat the Khalifa did not disapprove of the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur or any other leaflet on the same subject. He rather, repudiated the suspicion that he had in any announcement expressed a disapproval of the book and found fault with Zahiruddin who, in spite of the assurance on his part, had proceeded to assert in clear terms that he was opposed to beliefs entertained by the Khalifa. If it was actually after a reading of the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur or some other leaflet on the subject that the Khalifa began his correspondence with Zahiruddin, then there appears no reason why the

Khalifa should have tried to dispel the suspicion that there was reference to Zahiruddin in the Khalifa’s announcement, nor any reason why Zahiruddin should not have been included among the persons alluded to in the said announcement. Under the circumstances one also fails to understand why the Khalifa should have had to complain that when he had clearly pointed out that Zahiruddin was not the subject of the announcement, the latter should still persist, in saying that he differed from the Khalifa in his beliefs. If the Khalifa had actually disapproved of Zahiruddin’s book, then whether the fact was mentioned in the announcement or not, a difference in beliefs would still have been an established fact. But, the Khalifa denied the existence of any such differences and asked why Zahiruddin still insisted that he had differences with the Khalifa, when the Khalifa had already assured him that the announcement bore no reference to him. From this statement, it is clear that up to that time the Khalifa did not think that there were any differences between him and Zahiruddin in the matter of beliefs, and considered it groundless and unreasonable that Zahiruddin should speak of differences with the Khalifa.

The second point in which Maulawi Muhammad Ali has departed from the truth in his narrative of facts relating to M. Zahiruddin, is that the Khalifa started correspondence with Zahiruddin after a perusal of the book. As a matter of fact, the correspondence was started not by the Khalifa but by Zahiruddin. The reason why Maulawi Muhammad Ali has used language which would convey that it was the Khalifa who started the correspondence seems to be that Maulawi Muhammad Ali wants to prove that the Khalifa, when he read the book, was highly displeased with it and wrote to Zahiruddin about it. But as would appear from the contemporary notices of these events, correspondence on the subject was initiated by Zahiruddin and the occasion for it, as can be ascertained from Al-Hakam of 14th October 1912, arose as follows: The Khalifatul Masih (ra) had gone to Lahore to take part in a certain function. There he delivered a speech on this same question, which divides to-day the two sections of Ahmadis—the adherents and the seceders. The editor of the Zamińdar was also present at the speech of which he subsequently published a garbled report in his paper. He wrote that Khalifatul Masih I (ra) had declared all non-Ahmadis to be Muslims. Zahiruddin, when he read the report, made haste to write without adequate deliberation a very impertinent and disrespectful letter to the Khalifa. He found fault with the Khalifa’s views and declared them to be opposed to the teachings of the Promised Messiah (as). Upon this, the Khalifa wrote to him with the greatest affection and tried to explain matters to him. But Zahiruddin was lacking in uprightness and understanding. He increased in his impertinence, and in spite of the fact that a correct, version of the speech had in the meantime been published in Al-Hakam and many of his objections had already been satisfactorily answered, he remained obdurate and doubtful of the good faith of the Khalifa. This may be seen from his letter published in Al-Hakam of 14th October 1912, wherein he wrote: "Your favour is to hand. If the persons you had in view were only Abdullah Timapuri and Yar Muhammad." These words clearly show that, in spite of the assurance by the Khalifa that his announcement did not relate to Zahiruddin and that it related only to Maulawi Yar Muhammad and Abdullah Timapuri, Zahiruddin was still unsatisfied with the assurance, and signified his disbelief by an 'If '. He also proceeded to reiterate his former statement that he was opposed to the beliefs of the Khalifa.

All this correspondence and the way in which it began has been set forth in Al-Hakam of 14th October 1912. It fully contradicts the version given by Maulawi Muhammad Ali that it was the Khalifa who began correspondence with Zahiruddin, after he had read Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur. It shows, on the contrary, that it was Zahiruddin who really began the correspondence, and that the origin of the correspondence did not lie in the fact of the Khalifa’s disapproval of the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur but in the fact of Zahiruddin reading a garbled version of the Khalifa’s speech at Lahore and his taking exception to it. It is therefore no small thing on the part of Maulawi Muhammad Ali that he should venture to distort facts published and known to the public, should in fact invent a new set of facts quite different from those already published, and then incorporate them in The Split.

The third point relating to Zahiruddin, which Maulawi Muhammad Ali has mentioned is that after the correspondence an announcement was published by Khalifatul Masih I (ra) to the effect that "as Muhammad Zahiruddin was promulgating new doctrines he was not to be considered as having any connection with the Ahmadiyya Community." As I have already said, this statement of Maulawi

10 von 10 heute frei