Factors Relating to Zahiruddin’s Expulsion

Truth About the Split, Part 2

Muhammad Ali is also wholly false and contrary to facts. Maulawi Muhammad Ali found it necessary, in order to compass his purpose, to prove that the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur was really at the root of all these dissensions and that the Khalifa was opposed to the views set forth in it. He, therefore, tried to distort the actual facts and to fabricate new facts which would lend support to his version. In the announcement by the Khalifa, it was not mentioned that as Muhammad Zahiruddin was promulgating new doctrines, he was not to be considered as having any connection with the Ahmadiyya Community. What the Khalifa wrote was that as, notwithstanding his assertion that a certain announcement did not refer to him (Zahiruddin), he still persisted in saying that he was opposed to beliefs held by the Khalifa, therefore, on the basis of his letter (and not on the basis of his book) the Khalifa announced that Zahiruddin had no connection with the Ahmadiyya Community.

As stated by Maulawi Muhammad Ali, this announcement by the Khalifa, was published in the Badr of 11th July 1912. I shall here quote the announcement in full in order that readers may judge for themselves how far Maulawi Muhammad Ali has been honest in his statement of the case. The announcement was as follows:

"Zahiruddin Arupi"

"Some time ago, an announcement was made in the Badr to the effect that people some times published notices of their own accord, which notices must not be considered to have been published on behalf of the Movement, inasmuch as they are not published with the permission or approval of the Khalifatul Masih (ra). Soon after this, upon a communication received from Munshi Zahiruddin Arupi, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) has been pleased to order the following announcement in the papers: The recent notice had no reference to Muhammad Zahiruddin, but referred to Maulawi Yar Muhammad and Abdullah Timapuri, It is a pity, however, that Muhammad Zahiruddin has chosen to make a strange response to that announcement. In a recent letter he has informed me that he disagrees with my beliefs. Accordingly, on the basis of his letter, I inform my Community that Muhammad Zahiruddin differs from me in his beliefs. Under these circumstances, he has, as it were, run from the shower to stand under the gutter. If he had mentioned some minor point of difference, it could have been passed over in silence. But now as he speaks of a difference of belief and is firm in his convictions, therefore, I have no further connection with him, nor have my Community anything to do with him. This is a very strange response which Muhammad Zahiruddin has made!

'Verily for God we are and to Him we return.' The above is a translation of the announcement in the Badr. One may well mark that in this announcement there is neither directly nor indirectly any reference to the fact that Zahiruddin had been promulgating new beliefs. The announcement merely states that as notwithstanding the Khalifa’s assurance that a certain announcement did not refer to him, instead of feeling ashamed of what he had written and making amends for the impertinence of his conduct, Zahiruddin wrote to the Khalifa that he had differences of belief with the Khalifa. It was therefore, on the ground of his letter that the Khalifa announced that under the circumstances Zahiruddin had no connection whatsover with the Khalifa, nor anything to do with the Khalifa’s followers."

Now let any one read the above announcement side by side with the following words of Maulawi Muhammad Ali: "As Muhammad Zahiruddin was promulgating new doctrines he was not to be considered as having any connection with the Ahmadiyya Community." The words "promulgating new doctrines" have obviously been put intentionally by Maulawi Muhammad Ali in order to prove the connection that the reason for excommunicating Zahiruddin from the Ahmadiyya Community was his book—Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur or some other leaflet on the same subject. As a matter of fact, in the Khalifa’s announcement there is no reference to any book or tract published by Zahiruddin but only to a letter which he addressed to the Khalifa, wherein—in spite of the written assurance given by the Khalifa that his announcement was not, directed against any of the publications of Zahiruddin but was directed against the notices published by Maulawi Yar Muhammad and Abdullah Timapuri— Zahiruddin impertinently proceeded to address the Khalifa in the words: "Sir, I differ from certain beliefs held by you, and so long as you do not prove the error of my views I shall continue to stand by them." (Al-Hakam, page 46, October 1912.) Accordingly, we find that in the reply to the letter which was sent to him privately by the Khalifa, he proceeded to say: "You contended that it had reference to you. I assured you that it bore no reference to you and contrary to my practice, I even mentioned to you the names of the persons referred to in the announcement. But in spite of that, you state very boldly that you are opposed to beliefs entertained by Nuruddin and stand firmly by your own beliefs". In another letter, the Khalifa wrote, "Because you state in your letter that you differ from beliefs held by me, I do not consider you an Ahmadi".

If one were to read those quotations side by side with the public announcement, one would clearly see that the Khalifatul Masih (ra) expelled Muhammad Zahiruddin from the Ahmadiyya Community, not on account of any actual differences of belief, but on account of Zahiruddin’s own profession in writing that he differed from the beliefs held by the Khalifa, and that he was firmly attached to his own beliefs. In fact, the Khalifatul Masih (ra) was sorry that when he had explicitly stated that Zahiruddin was not the subject of his announcement, the latter should persist in stating that he was opposed to the Khalifa’s beliefs. And when a follower confesses that he holds beliefs contrary to those of the Khalifa of his time and that he will not give in spite of explanations, but will only further stiffen in his opposition, what remedy is there for such a case but to exclude the recalcitrant from the Community?

The question may now be asked, when there were no actual differences of belief or doctrine between the Khalifa and Muhammad Zahiruddin, and when the incorrect version of the speech published by the Zamińdar had already been corrected by Al-Hakam, and when the Khalifa himself had contradicted the unfounded report regarding Muhammad Zahiruddin’s book to which some persons had given publicity, what ground was there for Zahiruddin to urge that he had differences of doctrine with the Khalifa? To understand this, it should be remembered that although the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur contained nothing repugnant to the teachings of the Movement, yet at the time (1912), when his differences with the Khalifa began, a change had begun to come over the views of Zahiruddin. He had begun to entertain the belief that he too was the subject of some prophecies by the Promised Messiah (as). He had, in fact, actually begun to spread such views among Ahmadis and was aiming at a rift in the Community. In his letters, he had made it a rule to charge the Khalifa with want of veracity. For instance, as already pointed out it was clear from his letters that he received with suspicion the assurance by the Khalifa that his announcement did not relate to Zahir, and inwardly believed that the report of the speech as published by the Zamińdar was the correct one, while the one published in Al- Hakam was intended to satisfy Ahmadis. It was on account of this that in his correspondence, in spite of the repeated assurances by the Khalifa, Zahiruddin persisted in declaring that he was opposed to the doctrines of the Khalifa. When, however, he found that the Khalifa had expelled him from the Community and that nobody took his part, he recanted outwardly and apologised for his conduct and was received back into the Community. But in reality he was only waiting for a more favourable opportunity. Thus, his professed doctrinal difference with the Khalifa was not based upon any actual facts. It had its basis in the secret conviction that the doctrines outwardly avowed by the Khalifa were sheer camouflage, his actual beliefs being far other than those which he openly professed. Zahiruddin wanted to persuade the Community to this view about the Khalifatul Masih (ra) . But his machinations proved unavailing and he met with complete discomfiture. In corroboration of my view about Zahiruddin it may also be mentioned that Zahiruddin is one of those few men who held that in fulfilment of one of the visions of the Promised Messiah (as), Khalifatul Masih I (ra) had turned an apostate towards the latter part of his life.

This is some of the internal evidence which goes to disprove the allegation made by Maulawi Muhammad Ali that Khalifatul Masih I (ra) expelled M. Zahiruddin because he disapproved of his book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur. I shall now proceed to adduce some external evidence. First, there is the fact that reference to the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur is to be found in various places in the Ahmadiyya literature, but nowhere has a voice been raised in condemnation of the book. On the contrary, wherever any comment is to be found, it is invariably in commendation of the book. In The Badr, volume for 1911, may be seen an acknowledgement of the receipt of the book and an advertisement of it issued by the editor, but not a word which may be said to be adverse to the book. If the book was really so objectionable, how was it that notices regarding it, were issued in the newspapers of the Movement by the editors of the papers but not a word was said to warn the Community against its obnoxious contents? It is no doubt true that particular notice need not be taken of every minor difference of view but doctrines promulgated in the book in question were, in the words of Maulawi Muhammad Ali himself, so dangerous in their nature that the Khalifatul Masih (ra) had to expel Zahiruddin from the Community on account of them. How then could such a dangerous book have been passed without an adverse notice?

If the notice in the Badr were all we had on the point, it might be said that the editor of The Badr had published the advertisement in the way of an acknowledgment of the book and had not actually scrutinised its contents. We find, however, that even The Review of Religions, of which Maulawi Muhammad Ali himself was at the time the editor, published a highly commendatory notice of the book, which I quote below in full:

"Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur Part I…This is a booklet of 126 small sized pages written recently by our friend Munshi Zahiruddin in support of the claim of the Promised Messiah (as) . In this book there is a long and elaborate dissertation on the word Khatamun Nabiyyin. It also contains many other matters both instructive and important. It has resolved a large number of doubts and objections by cogent arguments. It discusses a large number of verses in the Holy Qur’an from new standpoints. The signs, which have been adduced by the Holy Qur’an in evidence of the truth of a genuine Prophet, have been enumerated in the book together with their original references, and they have been illustrated in their application to the Promised Messiah (as) . Some of the peculiar and novel arguments of the Chakrhalawi sect have been very satisfactorily refuted. The book is really worth a perusal. The paper and the print are also good." (The Review of Religions, October 1911).

Regarding the above quotation, Maulawi Muhammad Ali is reported to have said that at the time to which this quotation from the Review relates, he was busy with the translation of the Holy Qur’an, and could not devote sufficient attention to The Review of Religions, and that therefore any matter published in The Review of Religions at the time cannot fairly be cited against him. I am prepared to accept this plea. But what I say is not that this review was composed by Maulawi Muhammad Ali himself, and that therefore, it is admissible as evidence against him. What I say is that the Ahmadiyya Community did not regard the book in the light suggested by Maulawi Muhammad Ali and this, because we find that in the accredited organ of its central executive—the Sadr Anjuman Ahmadiyya—a very emphatic and favourable notice of the book was published by the editorial staff, it matters not whether by the pen of Maulawi Muhammad Ali or by any other writer. If the book was considered as objectionable as Maulawi Muhammad Ali would have us believe, such a review of it was quite impossible. It should be remembered that there is one important difference between 'articles' and 'reviews' published in any paper. Articles may sometimes be published which express views opposed to those of the editor. It is not necessary that opinions of correspondents should always conform to those held by editors. But with reviews the case is different. Commendatory notices of books are always evidence of the fact that the editorial staff of the paper is in full agreement with the views expressed by the reviewer. If, however, in this instance, it was a case of mistaken judgment on the part of the reviewer, then it was the duty of members of the Community to raise a voice against the reviewer.

And the least one could expect was that as soon as—according to Maulawi Muhammad Ali, Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , after reading the book and corresponding with the author had ordered his expulsion from the Community, the Sadr Anjuman Ahmadiyya, in whose organ the appreciation had been published or Maulawi Muhammad Ali himself who was formally, if not actually, the editor of that organ and was therefore, in the eyes of the public, responsible for its reviews, or the writer of the appreciation himself, should have taken steps to undo the harm that had been done to the Community by means of the notice and to inform the Community that the book contained sentiment so dangerous as to have led Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , to expel its author from the Community, and that whatever commendation of the book had been published in the Anjuman’s magazine was a mistake which need not mislead any of the members.

·

10 of 10 left today