Factors Relating to Zahiruddin’s Expulsion
Truth About the Split, Part 3
In addition to evidence furnished by this commendatory notice in The Review of Religions, there is other strong evidence which disposes of the allegation by Maulawi Muhammad Ali. This is that the whole story of the expulsion of M. Zahiruddin and his re-admission into the Community was published in Al-Hakam, the oldest newspaper of the Movement, during the lifetime of Khalifatul Masih I (ra) . The same article which contained the story, contained also a commendation of the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur. It could not possibly be that while announcing the pardon granted to Zahiruddin Al-Hakam should at the same time have been commending the book, publication of which had led to the author’s excommunication, and had compelled him to sue for pardon. Would not such levity on the part of the editor of Al-Hakam have rendered himself liable to excommunication by Khalifatul Masih I (ra) ? Is it possible that the editor, while noting that Zahiruddin had committed a mistake and now repented and was sorry, should have himself committed the same offence and commended that very poisonous book? Anyone who cares to peruse the article in Al-Hakam, cannot but arrive at the conclusion that the expulsion of Zahiruddin from the Community was not based on "the contents of the book (Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur) or some other leaflet on the same subject." (It is important to remember that up to that time no other book or leaflet on the same or a kindred subject had been published by Zahiruddin.) In expressing his views on the story of the excommunication and pardon, the editor of Al-Hakam wrote: "The service rendered to the Movement by Maulawi Zahiruddin by his publication of the books Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur, Vedon Ka Fatur and Radd-e-Chakrhalawi, is not such as we can afford to forget." These words clearly show that the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur did not provide the ground for expulsion for had it been so, the oldest organ of the Movement, while dwelling on the story of the expulsion, could not have expressed itself in such glowing terms in appreciation of the book.
But in addition to the above, there is yet another consideration which proves the groundlessness of the allegation made by Maulawi Muhammad Ali. This is that while, according to Maulawi Muhammad Ali, it was the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur which was the ground for the expulsion of Zahiruddin, it remains to be explained why I was not similarly expelled on the ground of what I wrote on the subject of Kufr of those who had not accepted the Promised Messiah (as), especially as what I wrote was, according to Maulawi Muhammad Ali, founded on the doctrine of Nubuwwat taught by Zahiruddin, although as a matter of fact my article had been published before Zahiruddin’s book, and had been read in its entirety by Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , himself?
I feel sure that a consideration of the whole evidence—internal and external—will force upon every judicious reader the conviction that Maulawi Muhammad Ali has knowingly and intentionally attempted to compile a false history of the Movement in order to mislead those who live in distant lands. Whoever makes a study of the facts and the references to newspaper writings quoted above cannot fail to confess to a feeling of amazement at the following words of Maulawi Muhammad Ali:
(i) "Much notice of the book does not seem to have been taken by the Ahmadiyya Community."
(ii) "But probably the contents of the book or some other leaflet on the same subject were brought to the notice of the late Maulawi Nuruddin Sahib then head of the Ahmadiyya Community, and after some correspondence between Zahiruddin and Maulawi Sahib, an announcement was made by the latter in the paper The Badr dated 11th July 1911 (this announcement has already been quoted at length some pages back and is itself sufficient disproof of Maulawi Muhammad Ali’s allegation) to the effect that as Muhammad Zahiruddin was promulgating new doctrines, he was not to be considered as having any connection with the Ahmadiyya Community." (The Split pp- 13, 14).