Zahiruddin’s Second Expulsion

Truth About the Split

The third point, worthy of note in Maulawi Muhammad Ali’s account of the dissensions, is that in April 1913, Zahiruddin published another tract in which he tried to prove that the new Kalima (formula of faith) promulgated by him was not an error and that therefore he was once more out off from the Community, and though ostensibly this was because he was a claimant to the Khilafat, really it was because of the promulgation of the new beliefs.

There is no doubt that Zahiruddin published another tract in April 1913, but, so far as I am aware, there was nothing like an announcement of his expulsion from the Community, because the opinion, expressed by him in the tract, was so much at variance with Islam that no need was felt either by the Head of the Ahmadiyya Community or any learned member of it to excommunicate him from the brotherhood. The person who formulates a new Kalima after the Holy Prophet (sa) , ispo facto withdraws himself from the Movement, and there is no need for his formal expulsion from the Community. This, in my opinion, was the reason why no announcement regarding him was published by the Community. It is, therefore, incorrect to say that either the Community or their leader said anything regarding Zahiruddin’s claim to the office of Khalifa. Like Maulawi Muhammad Ali himself, M. Zahiruddin was one who did not recognise the validity of Khulafa’. He could not, therefore, be a claimant to that office. What he claimed was that he was the Promised Muslih (reformer). He held the opinion that a claim to the leadership of the Community was valid only if established on the basis of a revelation vision or prophecy. Accordingly, we find that he was never charged by the Community with having made a claim to the Khilafat, nor was there any announcement ever made of his exclusion from the Community on the ground of any such claim. It is true that the Community, in actual practice severed all connection with him, but that was because of the novel doctrines forged by him, e.g. formulating a new Kalima (formula of faith), turning the face towards Qadian while at prayer, asserting that the Promised Messiah (as) was a Nabi with a new Shariah (Law), denying the authority of Khalifatul Masih I (ra) and charging him with various malpractices. So far as I can recollect, the only person who took any notice of his writings was Mir Qasim Ali, editor of the Al-Haq. In his paper, then published from Delhi, he referred to him in the following words:

"A perusal of Zahiruddin’s book has given me a mixed feeling of regret and disappointment. Regret, because the said gentleman has apparently taken 'the road to Turkistan, thinking that he was going to the Kaaba'; and disappointment, because I fail to discover in the book any evidence of scholarship or any new information which might prove of advantage to the Ahmadiyya Movement or to Islam; or if there is any, it is at any rate too deep to be perceived by a man of my understanding and attainments." He continues, "I would respectfully request members of the Movement, who are given to public writing, to bestow on the bills of Zahiruddin the same amount of attention which they have been devoting to Abdullah and Yar Muhammad." (Al-Haq, May 30th and June 7th, 1913),

From the above extracts it is clear that apart from dismissing Zahiruddin’s doctrines with contempt, the only notice taken by the Community of those writings was to leave them severely alone, and this has been ever since the attitude of the Community towards writings of this kind.

Argument from Article by Maulawi

Muhammad Ahsan

The fourth misstatement in the account of Ahmadiyya dissensions as related by Maulawi Muhammad Ali, is that Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan, in his report of a controversy held at Rampur, published under the heading 'Discussion relating to Partial Prophethood in Subordination to Complete Prophethood', has stated that "by following the Holy Prophet (sa) one can be granted partial prophethood in subordination to complete prophethood for helping the cause of the faith of Islam." Maulawi Muhammad Ali writes: "The same learned old man wrote an article in the monthly paper Tashhidhul Adhhan edited by M. Mahmud under the heading 'Prophethood among the Followers of Muhammad' in which he showed that the only prophethood which could be granted to Muslims was Nubuwwti Juzwi or partial prophethood." What Maulawi Muhammad Ali means to prove by this citation is that the belief of the more eminent Companions of the Promised Messiah (as) was that the door of prophethood was closed after the Holy Prophet (sa) , the door only of partial prophethood being left open. Another point which Maulawi Muhammad Ali seeks to prove from the fact that the article was published in the magazine of which I was myself the editor, is that at that time I either shared the same views with Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan or did not venture to give public utterance to my own views for fear of Khalifatul Masih I (ra) . I am, however, sorry to submit that the facts of the case fail to bear out either of the two conclusions which Maulawi Muhammad Ali seeks to draw from them. In the first place, the words of Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan possess no special authority. They may be regarded as possessing the same value as the words of any other learned man. In the second place, the publication of his article in the Tashhidhul Adhhan cannot lend any special value to the views expressed therein, because the article was published in October, 1913, when I had already for two years ceased to have any active connection with the magazine. At that time Qazi Muhammad Zahuruddin Akmal was the de facto editor of the Magazine. The managing body of the paper, however, continued to print my name on the cover in order to retain its popularity, inasmuch as it was I who had been editing it since its foundation. Under the circumstances, if any particular view was at that time published in the magazine, it cannot justly be cited against me. I was not then its active editor nor were the articles published in the magazine shown to me whether in original or in proof. Nevertheless, if

Maulawi Muhammad Ali would still insist upon holding me responsible for the matter in the magazine, on the ground that my name was connected with it as its nominal editor, then it would be only right and proper that Maulawi Muhammad Ali should himself accept responsibility for the notice of the book Nabiyyullah Ka Zahur, published in The Review of Religions.

But apart from the question of responsibility, I deem it necessary to point out that a consideration of Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan’s articles goes to show that they by no means justify the conclusion drawn by Maulawi Muhammad Ali. For, excepting the use of the term Juzwi Nubuwwat, the articles serve only to confirm the Nubuwwat of the Promised Messiah (as) in the sense claimed by us.

What concerns us is the writer’s intention, not the terms which he uses. A difference of terms is of no great moment so long as we agree on the meaning of those terms. It is true that Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan in his article in the Tashhidhul Adhhan spoke of the Nubuwwat of the Promised Messiah (as) as a Juzwi Nubuwwat (or Partial Prophethood) but at the same time he added regarding all the Israelite Prophets, raised after the Prophet Moses (as), that their Nubuwwat also was Nubuwwati Juzwi. He wrote: "Hence it follows that prophecies regarding future events granted in proof of the truth of Islam will be transmitted through the medium of Nubuwwat and that is what is meant by Nubuwwati Ghair Tashri‘i (Prophethood without Law) or Nubuwwati Juzwi Partial Prophethood). All the Ambiya’ who came after Moses (as), were honoured by the gift of this kind of Nubuwwat because the Nubuwwat of Ahkam (Lawbearing Prophethood) had ceased among the Israelites with the advent of the Torah" Tashhidhul Adhhan October 1913, page 500). From these words it is clear that according to Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan, the Mubashshirat (Gift of Prophecy) promised to the followers of the Holy Prophet (sa) in

(Nothing remains of Nubuwwat except Mubashshirat), was nothing else than Nubuwwati Ghair Tashri‘i or Juzwi Nubuwwat, and that it was this kind of Nubuwwat which was granted to the Israelite Prophets after the Prophet Moses (as). Now, this exactly is our own position, and to add to it even so much as a title is regarded by me as an act of heresy. I go even further and think it necessary to add that the Prophets, who came to the Israelites after Moses (as), although they were Prophets without Law, all derived their prophethood without the intermediation of Moses (as). But the Promised Messiah (as), although he was a Prophet without Law like the Israelite Prophets who came after Moses (as), yet received the gift of prophethood, not directly but through the intermediation of the Holy Prophet (sa) . Thus, I have no difference with Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan in the views expressed by him in the Tashhidhul Adhhan regarding the nature of the Promised Messiah’s (as) Nubuwwat. The only objection I can take to the article is that he calls this kind of Nubuwwat, Nubuwwati Juzwi. We do not describe the Promised Messiah (as)’s Nubuwwat as Nubuwwati Juzwi. Thus the attempt of Maulawi Muhammad Ali to cite the article of Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan in support of his position serves only to prove his own lack of understanding. He seems to have been taken in by the terra Nubuwwati Juzwi but what one can see from Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan’s article is that all the Prophets who came to the Israelites after Moses (as) were endowed with Nubuwwati Juzwi. Thus, if the prophethood of David (as), Solomon (as) and Jesus (as) is to be classed as Nubuwwati Juzwi, I have no objection in this sense of the term, to apply it to the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as). But I am sure Maulawi

Muhammad Ali will never accept this sense of the term. He cites authority only so long as it agrees with his own views.

I wish here to quote a few passages from some of the other writings of Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan in order to prove my contention. Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan, elsewhere speaks of Maulawi Muhammad Ali in the following words:

"Maulawi Muhammad Ali has not understood the meaning of the term Juzwi Nubuwwat (partial prophethood) nor of Majazi Nubuwwat (metaphorical prophethood), nor of Zilli Nubuwwat (reflex prophethood), because he is of opinion that just as we may call somebody a lion because of his great prowess, so likewise the name of Nabi has been given to the Jariullah fi Hulalil Ambiya’ (revelation title of the Promised Messiah (as) , meaning Fighter for Allah in the mantles of the Prophets). God protect us! Maulawi Sahib does not even understand to whom the term Majazi is being applied. My dear friend, metaphor strictly is false. If the Promised Messiah (as) is Nabi-i-Majazi in this sense, then his prophethood is false! God protect us from such views! The fact is that the Holy Prophet (sa) is the original Prophet, and the Promised Messiah (as) a succeeding Prophet. Whatever of the original Prophet may be attributed to the succeeding Prophet is in the nature of a Majaz (metaphor), as may be seen in many of the revelations of the Promised Messiah (as) , as for example in the revelation

This is the meaning of Majaz. Similarly Maulawi Muhammad Ali has also failed to understand the meaning either of Nubuwwat Juzwi or Zilli. I have already explained in Sitta-i-Daruriya that under such circumstances if there should happen to arise an equality between the original and the reflex, there is still no harm, because the superiority will still remain with the original on account of its priority.' This is what is signified by Zilliyyat (Reflexion). Nor has Maulawi Muhammad Ali understood the meaning of the term Juzwi; because, according to the generally accepted Hadith, "nothing remains of Nubuwwat save

10 von 10 heute frei