Zahiruddin’s Second Expulsion
Truth About the Split, Part 2
Mubashshirat" (prophecy). Thus, only because the Jariullah (the Promised Messiah (as) —Tr.) has not brought any new Shariah (Law) save the Shariah of Islam nor any new book superseding the Holy Qur’an, he is called a Juzwi Nabi.''
Likewise, the following lines of Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan are quoted from his book Sitta-i- Daruriya where, in order to confute the deniers of the prophethood of Ahmad the Promised Messiah (as), he proves from the verse Khatamun Nabiyyin the continuance of prophethood in the Khairul Umam the best of people meaning the Muslims), and refutes the doctrine advocated by Maulawi Muhammad Ali. He writes:
"Regarding the meaning of the word Nabi and Rasul, there is a very great divergence of opinion prevailing among the doctors of religion, but if from among the conflicting mass of opinion we are to accept the meaning furnished by the Tafsir-e-Kabir what is there to prevent us from such a course? The meaning given there is as follows: "Rasul is a Nabi who in addition to miracles, has had a book revealed to him, and a Nabi other than a Rasul is one to whom no book has been revealed and who has simply been commanded to call people to a book previously revealed.' (Volume VI, page 92). Thus, if it is proved that, in accordance with the above definition the Promised Messiah (as) is a Nabi and not a Rasul and wherever the name Rasul has been applied to him it is to be understood in the sense of Nabi, I do not see what objection can there be to such a view." (Sitta-i-Daruria, p. 67). He writes further: "The verse should be understood in a sense that would signify praise and exaltation of the "Holy Prophet (sa) with God. That is the proper sense of the verse. Now, let us see what this sense can properly be. It is that after the advent of the Holy Prophet (sa), there can arise no Prophet such as will bring any new command of Shariah (Law), which is not already to be met with in the Holy Qur’an or in the Sunna (Practice) of the Holy Prophet (sa) or which will abrogate any command of Islam." (Ibid p. 59). Again: "The Holy Prophet (sa) was the 'Seal of the Prophets,' which means that the excellences of all the earlier Prophets were to be found in him. (Ibid p. 61). What is signified by the term, 'Seal of the Prophets,' is that the Holy Prophet (sa) had attained the highest stage of perfection granted to Prophets, not that the grace of his prophethood would never reach any of his followers.)" Ibid p. 64). Again he writes: "If the Holy Prophet (sa) is the Prophet of Prophets only in reference to the Prophets before him, then, in the first place such a claim would be lacking in evidence, inasmuch as there is no Prophet who has attained to the rank of Prophet by following the Holy Prophet (sa). In the second place, such a belief will attribute to the Holy Prophet (sa) one kind of excellence—that
of personal perfection. But it will withhold from him the other kind of excellence—that of making others perfect. May God save us from such a view! Now, as a matter of fact even the Prophets of whom he is the Master, enjoyed this kind of excellence—that of making others perfect. For example, among the followers of Moses (as) , there arose hundreds of Prophets who attained to the rank by virtue of faithfully following Moses (as) their teacher; and yet let us remember what the Holy Prophet (sa) said: 'Had Moses (as) been alive, he would have had no choice but to follow me.'" (Ibid p. 71). Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan writes further on: "To understand the term Khatamun Nabiyyin in this sense adds to the dignity and glory of the Holy Prophet (sa), inasmuch as it makes both the preceding and the succeeding Prophets depend upon him." (Ibid p. 66). And again: "We claim two things for the Holy Prophet (sa). The first is that after the advent of the Holy Prophet, there cannot appear till the last day another Prophet who will bring a new Shariah (Law), and the second that obedience to the Holy Prophet (sa) keeps the door open for Juzwi Nabis (partial Prophets) to appear for the defence of Islam, and to function in subordination to the perfect Prophet."