A Supposed Warning by Khalifatul Masih I (ra)
Truth About the Split, Part 2
Why then did they miss the Juma prayer? To this, the Doctor replied that they had waited there in order to read out an article to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra). I inquired "And did they read out the same to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih?" The Doctor said, "No, twice or thrice they asked leave to read, but Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) declined saying he was going to take rest. Thus they failed in the object for which they had forgone their Juma prayers". After this I came back to Sahibzadah Sahib and related to him the whole story. Then I went back to the house of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih and sat down determined not to leave the place till Maulawi Muhammad Ali had either read the article or returned home disappointed. Maulawi Muhammad Ali waited in the house of Maulawi Sadruddin looking for the time when I should leave Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra), while I looked for the time when Maulawi Muhammad Ali should read out his article to him. At length came the time for the Maghrib prayers. Maulawi Muhammad Ali now departed for his house out of town, and I departed for the Maghrib prayers. After the prayers I said to Sahibzadah Sahib, "Friday has passed and Maulawi Muhammad Ali has not read out his article to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra)." To this Sahibzadah Sahib replied "Well, when he is determined so far to keep it a secret and does not wish that we should know anything about it, it is better to leave him alone. How long can we keep watch over him? Let us instead pray to God and fast that these troubles and travails may be averted." After this, we paid no further attention to Maulawi Muhammad Ali. The latter, however, did not have the opportunity to read out his article either on Saturday or on Sunday following. But the night following Sunday or, may be, the night following Monday he made arrangements, to prevent people from coming to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih’s (ra) house and had the opportunity to read out the article.
He posted some Pathans to guard the doors of the house and told them it was the Khalifa’s command that nobody should be allowed to enter in. At this time, Mir Nasir Nawab Sahib called to inquire about the health of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra). The guards told him that nobody was permitted to enter. Similarly, Sufi Maulawi Ghulam Muhammad B. A. also came to inquire of his health. He also was sent back. Then came Dr. Khalifa Rashiduddin. He too was stopped by the guards. But he said that he was a doctor and nobody could prevent his entrance. He forcibly made his way in. Coming to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) he inquired of him whether he had given orders not to allow people to come in. Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) replied that he had given no such orders. Dr. Khalifa Rashiduddin subsequently reported that at that time Maulawi Muhammad Ali was reading out his article to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra). When he had finished, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) asked him whether he felt fully satisfied with the article. Maulawi Muhammad Ali said, "Yes." Thereupon, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) said that he himself was not fully satisfied with the article. Maulawi Muhammad Ali made several attempts to get Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) to sign the article, but always remained unsuccessful.'
Written on the 27th August, 1919, by Ata Muhammad, Assistant to Hafiz Raushan Ali Sahib."
"I attest that the above account has been dictated by me.
"I attest the correctness of the account dictated by Hafiz Raushan Ali and state that it is all in accordance with facts and is quite accurate.
Civil Assistant Surgeon (Retired),
Physician in attendance on Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra),"
In addition to the above testimonies, there was the testimony of the late Sahibzadah Abdul Hayi, son of Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , who told me that Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) did not approve of the article and said that it required further consideration and that therefore Maulawi Muhammad Ali must not make haste to publish it. This testimony received confirmation from actual facts, as we may notice that the article was not published so long as Hadrat
Khalifatul Masih (ra) was alive, although another pamphlet which Maulawi Muhammad Ali wrote later, in anticipation of the death of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) on the subject of succession to the Khilafat, was published during his lifetime. What is the conclusion to be drawn from all this evidence? This question, which hardly needs an answer, will be answered by the conscience of every reader.
Did the Bai‘at on the Hand of the Second Khalifa take Place in Ignorance?
The ninth item in Maulawi Muhammad Ali’s account is that Ahmadis accepted my Bai‘at under several misconceptions, and that many of them are now openly averse to beliefs held by me. For example, even Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan, the oldest and the most learned living Companion of the Promised Messiah (as), has issued a handbill declaring that I am not fit for the office of Khilafat, because I have been promulgating the following erroneous beliefs.
(i) That all the followers of the Qibla, professing the Kalima, are kuffar.
(ii) That the Promised Messiah (as) was a perfect and real Prophet and not a partial Prophet or Muhaddath.
(iii) That the prophecy about Ahmad in Chapter Saff of the Holy Qur’an relates to the Promised Messiah (as) and not to the Holy Prophet (sa) .
In dealing with these charges, I wish in the first instance to state that it is altogether wrong to say that people accepted my Bai‘at under any misconception regarding my views. My principles and beliefs had been published long before I was elected to the office of Khalifa. My views on the question of the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as) had been expounded in a lecture I delivered in 1910. This lecture was duly published in the organs of the Ahmadiyya Movement. They were also to be found in other writings of mine. I had also published a tract on the subject of the Kufr of those who did not accept the Promised Messiah (as), and, in the words of Maulawi Muhammad Ali himself, I had in 1913 once again announced that those who did not believe in the Promised Messiah (as) were kuffar. In the presence of so many repeated declarations, how can it be said that people entered my Bai‘at through a misconception? It is true that there are a few who first entered my Bai‘at and then renounced it. But, on the other hand, more than a hundred times their number have later replaced these defections. When I was elected there was only an inconsiderable number who accepted my Bai‘at.
The majority of the Jama‘ats in centres outside held back through misunderstandings created by these very people. But God worked on my behalf and gradually gathered the whole Community to my side. It is wrong therefore to say that people entered my Bai‘at through any misconception. They continue still to enter and from December last up to now (March 1919), about 25 persons from among the followers of Maulawi Muhammad Ali have accepted me as the true Khalifa. All this has happened in spite of the fact that I have refrained from devoting any attention to my opponents who have been spending the bulk of their funds and energy against me. Wherever our men have gone to preach the truth of Ahmadiyyat, there their men have followed them in order to create an aversion in the public mind against us and often against Ahmadiyyat itself. If I, on my part, had cared to devote to these people even half the time which they have been wasting in their activities against us, then, by the grace of God, we could have had even larger results. It seems to us better, however, that our energy should be devoted to the propagation of Islam and the advance of Ahmadiyyat. Accordingly, all our lecturers are directed to work only among non- Ahmadis and non-Muslims. On the other hand, nearly all the lecturers of Maulawi Muhammad Ali’s party are engaged in misleading Ahmadis. Nevertheless, those who have deserted us to join Maulawi Muhammad Ali’s party are few, and have been compensated many time over by those who have left his party to join us. I am prepared, in case Maulawi Muhammad Ali desires, to furnish proof.
As for his statement that a majority of the enlightened Ahmadis are opposed to my views, it is but a claim for which Maulawi Muhammad Ali has still to furnish some evidence. Of course, if we start with the assumption that those who belong to his way of thinking are enlightened and those who do not are not, then certainly not a majority but rather all the enlightened members of the Community have abandoned my party and joined his. If, however, such an assumption is inadmissible, then there is no evidence for Maulawi Muhammad Ali’s claim. For, if there are any men learned in religion whom Maulawi Muhammad Ali can produce from among his followers, then there is a much larger number of them whom I can produce from among my followers. This is, however, a futile method of arguing, useless for the establishment of truth. If, however, Maulawi Muhammad Ali is fond of arguing in this way, we are quite prepared to stand even this comparison of strength.
Maulawi Muhammad Ali’s narrative seeks also to prove that the enlightened members of the Community who still continue as my followers, are opposed to the beliefs held by me. If words used by him, which carry the above sense, are deliberate and intentional, then I cannot but say that he has only attempted to mislead people. For those who are with me agree in my beliefs, and if there is anywhere any stray exception, the case is beyond my knowledge, and such exceptions can in no wise serve as the basis of an argument. I do not, of course, speak of those few men who are openly consorting with Maulawi Muhammad Ali, but who still for considerations of expediency are averse to making a public declaration of the renunciation of this Bai‘at. These men by their conduct have proved themselves hypocrites. But even they are negligibly small in number.
Now to those statements which Maulawi Muhammad Ali has made concerning Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan. In the first place, I wish to say that the statement made by Maulawi Muhammad Ali that Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan is the oldest living Companion of the Promised Messiah (as) is quite wrong. There are among my followers men still living who entered into the Bai‘at of the Promised Messiah (as) long before Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad