A Supposed Warning by Khalifatul Masih I (ra)
Truth About the Split, Part 3
Ahsan, and who had become attached to the Promised Messiah (as) at a time before the said Sayyid Sahib had even heard his name. For example, there is Shaikh Hamid Ali Sahib (ra) who was the third of those who accepted the Bai‘at of the Promised Messiah (as), and Munshi Rura Sahib, retired Tahsildar of Kapurthala, who was the seventh or eighth of those who entered into the Promised Messiah’s (as) Bai‘at. This last gentleman, some years ago, migrated to Qadian. He is one of those who possessed a special attachment for the Promised Messiah (as), and about him the Promised Messiah (as) wrote on page 799 of Izala’-e-Auham. "He is attached to me by a bond of love." The Promised Messiah (as) entertained a special affection for him, a fact well-known to visitors to Qadian. Munshi Rura Khan belonged to the Ahmadiyya Jama‘at of Kapurthala. With regard to this Jama‘at, the Promised Messiah (as) was pleased to remark, "I hope that by the grace and bounty of God you will be with me in this life and the next." (Letters of the Promised Messiah (as) to Muhammad Khan Sahib of Kapurthala, dated 27th January, 1894—reproduced from the Badr, October 1 st , 1908). All members of this Jama‘at are in my Bai‘at. Similarly, there is Mir Inayat Ali Shah Sahib (ra)
of Ludhiana who was the ninth of those who accepted the Bai‘at of the Promised Messiah (as). There is also Maulawi Abdullah Sahib of Sanaur, who is the witness of a great miracle of the Promised Messiah (as), and regarding whom the Promised Messiah (as) made the prophecy, "I am fully assured that God has filled your heart with sincerity and love. You possess a natural affinity and your love is such that it cannot change with the passing of time." (Extract from the Promised Messiah’s (as) letter to Maulawi Abdullah of Sanaur, dated 6th March 1908. This letter will be found fully reproduced elsewhere in this book). This gentleman too is, by the grace of God, among my followers. There is also Munshi Zafar Ahmad Sahib, who was one of the earliest to accept the Bai‘at of the Promised Messiah (as), and who entertains a more than ordinary attachment for the Promised Messiah (as), and is at present a member of the Kapurthala Jama‘at. Similarly, there are Munshi Abdur Rahman Sahib and Munshi Fayyaduddin Sahib, both of Kapurthala. All of them are deeply devoted members of the Movement, and all of them entered into the Bai‘at of the Promised Messiah (as) long before Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan. There is also Pir Sirajul Haq Nu‘mani who was not only one of the earliest to accept the Bai‘at, but had also at several times lived in the company of the Promised Messiah (as). These gentlemen not only joined the Promised Messiah (as) earlier than Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan, but are mostly such as enjoyed more of his society than was the case with Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan. Thus it is altogether wrong to say that Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan is the oldest Companion of the Promised Messiah (as). The earliest work in which the Promised Messiah (as) enumerated the names of the men who joined him is Izala-e-Auham. Of the persons mentioned therein, there are eighteen now alive regarding whom the Promised Messiah (as) was pleased to record his remarks. Out of this number, fourteen have entered my Bai‘at and four have joined the party of Maulawi Sahib. Can there still be any doubt as to which side enjoys the confidence of the majority of the Promised Messiah’s (as) Companions?
Nor am I prepared to agree with Maulawi Muhammad Ali that Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan is the most learned man in the whole of the Ahmadiyya Movement. It is no easy matter to determine the extent of a person’s learning. In my opinion, Maulawi Sayyid Sarwar Shah Sahib and Qazi Sayyid Amir Husain Sahib are in no way inferior to Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan in the matter of scholarship. I may also include Maulawi Hafiz
Raushan Ali Sahib who, although young in years, may be reckoned among the aged in learning. Thus, neither on ground of years, nor on the ground of learning, does Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan enjoy any such pre-eminence over the rest of the Community as might entitle his pronouncements to any special authority. It is true that by reason of his learning and his age he enjoyed the general regard of both the educated and the ordinary members of the Movement; and, as for myself, I do even now hold him in esteem for the sake of the respect he enjoyed in the past. I am of opinion that the said Sayyid Sahib is labouring under a sad delusion, and that God willing, when he recovers his normal self, he will turn again to the Centre. May God fulfil the hope that it is only a passing trial which he is undergoing, and that he will come out victorious in the end, and that God will save him from the fate of the old woman, spoken of in the Holy Qur’an, who span her yarn during the day and undid it during the night. Amen!
I now proceed to deal with the charges upon the grounds of which Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan claims to depose me from the Khilafat. I would, however, note in passing that the appointment of a Khalifa is the work of God, and that it lies with God alone to depose him. It is in no man’s power either to appoint or to depose a Khalifa. Thus my appointment as Khalifa was not due to Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan, nor could 1 be deposed by his command. It is, indeed, one of the favours of God, that since the announcement of deposition by Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan, further success has come and continues to come to me. From that time up to now (March 1919), some fifteen to twenty thousand new members have joined me and every day brings more and more success. May God add to the success. Amen!
It is not my intention at this stage to enter into a discussion of the charges brought against me by Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan, nor shall I attempt here to prove or disprove the beliefs which he states. A full discussion of these beliefs will be made further on. All I wish to say at this place is that it is hardly proper on the part of Sayyid Sahib to attack me on the ground of those beliefs. It was certainly open to him to say that the error of those beliefs is now manifest to him, and that he has therefore, decided to renounce them, or he could have said that, in addition to those beliefs, there were some novel beliefs which I had adopted, and that it was on account of these that he would now renounce my Bai‘at. But he has no justification to speak of the beliefs held by me, as novel or heretical, or to make them the ground of an announcement against me. I say this because he has been familiar with those beliefs for a long time before now, and was well aware of them, when the Bai‘at of my Khilafat was held. For, as Maulawi Muhammad Ali admits, my article on the subject of Kufr of non- Ahmadis was published in the Tashhidhul Adhhan of April 1911 and, as he further admits, I have since been writing regularly on the subject. Thus when even in the lifetime of Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , I had declared non-Ahmadis to be kuffar, and this was well-known to members of the Movement, I can only wonder why Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan, who knew all this, entered into my Bai‘at. If my beliefs were really such that their entertainment rendered me unfit for the office of Khalifa, how was it that on the day of the election in the Masjid Nur, it was he who stood up to propose me for the Khilafat, and he who made a powerful speech in my support?
A more proper attitude for him, on seeing people wish to enter into my Bai‘at, would have been to dissuade them from doing so, to point out that I had pronounced all Muslims to be kuffar, and that therefore I was not fit to be their Khalifa. As it happens, I have had no occasion to enter into any elaborate discussion of this question of Kufr of non-Ahmadis, since my election as Khalifa. The most important article I wrote on the subject was the one published during the lifetime of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) . Accordingly, if holding this belief is really a valid ground for my deposition from the Khilafat, the blame attaches to Sayyid Sahib who, in spite of my holding the belief, was so strong in his support of my election as Khalifa. Besides, it may also be noted that on the eve of the meeting at which God was pleased to decide the question of successor to the Khilafat, Maulawi Muhammad Ali came to pay me a call. There were present on the occasion Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan, Dr. Khalifa Rashiduddin, and Nawab Muhammad Ali Khan, Jagirdar of Malerkotla. Maulawi Muhammad Ali at that time laid stress upon this very question. He pointed out that it was difficult to proceed with the election of a Khalifa, because there was such serious disparity of beliefs prevailing in the Community. One party regarded the Promised Messiah (as) as a Nabi and his deniers as kuffar while the other party refused to subscribe to any such doctrine. Upon this, it was Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan who engaged Maulawi Muhammad Ali in argument, and tried to establish the validity of our beliefs. But I restrained him pointing out that the occasion was not one for the settlement of differences of belief. The question immediately before us was how to find a solution of the impasse, and in any case a settlement of beliefs required time.
I am prepared to swear to the truth of this incident, and I ask Maulawi Muhammad Ali to say whether he too is prepared to swear that he did not refer at this meeting to our beliefs, and that Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan was not one of those who argued with him in order to establish their validity.
Now, to the subject of prophethood. On this subject also, as I have already stated, I had publicly explained my views in a speech I delivered on the occasion of the Annual Conference of the year 1910. I had there stated in plain words that the Promised Messiah (as) was a Nabi. I have already quoted a number of passages from this speech. Here I shall content myself with quoting one more passage. "A Nabi from God has appeared among us. If we follow him, we shall reap all the rewards promised to the Companions of the Holy Prophet (sa) ." In this passage not only was the Promised Messiah (as) distinctly called a Nabi, but mention was also made of the eminence of his rank by saying that his followers were to be classed with the Companions of the Holy Prophet (sa) . When I delivered the speech, Maulawi Muhammad Ahsan was present in the gathering and no sooner had I finished speaking than he broke out reciting in a loud voice the verse in the Holy Qur’an
"They do not fear the slander of any slanderer."
This, however, was not all. The next day, Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan himself delivered an address in the Masjid Aqsa. In the course of this address also, he praised my lecture and in these words: "There was a revelation to the Promised Messiah (as)
'I give you glad tidings of a boy, the manifestation of truth and greatness'."
The revelation was in accord with the prophecy contained in the Hadith relating to the Promised Messiah (as) —that he would marry and would be granted sons who would be great. We have accordingly, amongst us Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmud Ahmad who, in addition to being the noble son of a noble father, has in spite of his extreme youth disclosed, in the sermon he delivered in explanation of some verses in the Holy Qur’an, such a depth of knowledge and such an insight into truth as is indeed without a parallel. Now if any one were to slight him, and to speak about him saying that he was a child of yesterday, reared by their hands, given to sport and frolic, then one ought to remember that such remarks were the characteristic of the Pharaoh who spoke to Moses (as) saying 'Did we not rear thee in our midst as a child? You lived amongst us many a year of your life'. Well brother! If such thoughts were to arise in the heart of any of you, you should seek forgiveness of God, because the end of the Pharaoh was bad indeed. (The Badr for January, 1911). Thus, it is impossible to say that Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan had no knowledge of the beliefs which I held.
He knew all about them. He accepted my Bai‘at with full knowledge of their nature. And now, on the ground of those same beliefs, he has renounced my Bai‘at. Who is there who, under the circumstances, will look upon his action with approval? One more point to be remembered, in this connection, is that my belief regarding the nature of the Promised Messiah’s (as) prophethood is the same as that of Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan, as stated by him in the Tashhidhul Adhhan. The difference is merely one of terminology.