A Supposed Warning by Khalifatul Masih I (ra)
Truth About the Split, Part 4
Yet a third doctrine, alleged to have been newly promulgated by me, is my belief that the Promised Messiah (as) is the object of the prophecy relating to Ahmad which occurs in Chapter Al-Saff of the Holy Qur’an. Whatever may be the merit of this belief of mine, it was promulgated long before Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan took the oath of Bai‘at; and even after its publication the said Maulawi Sahib remained for a long time on friendly relations with me. It was, in fact, during the lifetime of Khalifatul Masih I, that 1 wrote an article on the subject of the prophecy relating to Ahmad; only, it could not be shown to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) . My friend Qazi Zahuruddin Akmal published the article in the Tashhidhul Adhhan soon after I became Khalifa, and it was no less than two years after its publication that Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan announced his revocation of the Bai‘at. During all this time he consistently supported me and my party, and opposed Maulawi Muhammad Ali and his coadjutors. Thus, it would appear that even this belief could not be the real ground for his revocation of the Bai‘at.
Before finishing this point, I wish to cite one written testimony from the pen of Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan himself which shows that all the three doctrines had met with his entire approval, that he had bestowed upon the opponents of these doctrines opprobrious names like Pharaoh, etc. In fact, it appears that it was due to my advocacy of these very doctrines that he recognised me to be the Promised son of the Promised Messiah (as).
When, towards the close of the year 1914, Khwaja Kamaluddin returned from England, he delivered a lecture at Lahore at a meeting of the friends and partisans of Maulawi Muhammad Ali. The lecture was printed and widely distributed. I published a reply to it in my book called Al-Qaulul Fasl. In that book I discussed all the three questions: (i) the prophethood of the Promised Messiah (as), (ii) Kufr of non-Ahmadis, (iii) the Prophecy in the Holy Qur’an relating to Ahmad. By way of illustration I shall here quote a few passages from the book, bearing upon all the three subjects:
"If one were to define Haqiqi Nabi (real Prophet) as a Prophet who is not an impostor or pretender but a Prophet who has really been sent by God, who bears the title of Nabi in the sense of an accredited messenger of God, agreeably to the sense in which the word is used in the Holy Qur’an and possesses all the attributes requisite in a Nabi in their proper measure, then in view of such a definition, I would say that the Promised Messiah (as) was a Haqiqi Nabi, but, of course, I would not give him that name if it is understood to mean that he brought a new Law." (Al-Qaulul Fasl, page 12). Again, "According to us what is meant by the Promised Messiah (as) being a Zilli or a Baruzi Nabi, is simply this that his Nubuwwat (prophethood) was attained by virtue of his pupillage and obedience to the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa), whereas the previous Prophets attained this rank directly, and the words do not imply that the Nubuwwat (prophethood) of the Promised Messiah (as) was something of the nature of an honorary title which had no real substance behind it, or that his Nubuwwat did not entitle him to the status and privileges of Prophets." (Al- Qaulul Fasl. p. 18)
In the same book, there is to be found from page 2 to 26 a discussion of the question of the Nubuwwat of the Promised Messiah (as). Therein light has been thrown upon every possible aspect of the question, and nothing has been omitted from the discussion. Further on from page 27 to 32, has been discussed the prophecy concerning Ahmad. A few extracts from this discussion are now quoted: "The Promised Messiah (as) has called himself Ahmad, and said that it was he who was the real object of the prophecy, because he said that in this passage (the verse Ismuhu Ahmad in Chapter Al-Saff of the Holy Qur’an), there is a prophecy concerning Ahmad, alone, whereas the Holy Prophet was both Ahmad and Muhammad." (Al- Qaulul Fasl, page 27). Again, I wrote on page 31, "The person who is referred to in Ismuhu Ahmad is the Promised Messiah (as)." In short, in six pages of the book I proved by quotations from the writings of the Promised Messiah (as) and the testimony of Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , that the Promised Messiah (as) was the real object of the prophecy in the Holy Qur’an concerning Ahmad. Regarding the question of Kufr of non-Ahmadis, I wrote on page 33 of the book, "The other question discussed by Khwaja Sahib is that of Kufr of non- Ahmadis. Regarding this question, I have already published the writings of the Promised Messiah (as) which have a bearing on the subject. Further explanation is unnecessary. My belief continues to be the same as before." Below in a footnote, it was noted 'For details, see Tashhidhul Adhhan for April 1911.' This was the number in which was published my article running over 40 pages on the subject of Kufr of non-Ahmadis, from which several extracts have already been quoted above. I wrote, "Thus, whatever the Holy Qur’an says concerning such people as disbelieve in any Prophet is applicable to the deniers of Mirza Sahib (the Promised Messiah (as))." Al-Qaulul Fasl, p. 33).
From the above quotations, it is evident that the book Al-Qaulul Fasl, declared in the clearest possible terms that the Promised Messiah (as) was a Nabi, and his deniers kuffar, and that he was the object of the prophecy contained in the verse in the Holy Qur’an relating to Ahmad. The book was published in January 1915, and a copy of it was forwarded to Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan. Maulawi Sahib in a letter to Qazi Zahuruddin Akmal wrote about the book as follows:
"I have had the book Al-Qaulul Fasl read over to me from beginning to end. I have already expressed my opinion about it that it has given to the opponents of the Khilafat a conclusive argument in proof of their error."
Further, a letter also came to me from Sayyid Muhammad Ya‘qub, son of Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan wherein he wrote on behalf of his father: "The book Al-Qaulul Fasl was read over by me to my father. He was so glad to hear the claims and the arguments that he forgot, for the moment the discomforts of age and the pains of the ailments from which he has been suffering, and gave vent to his feelings in the words, 'Praise be to God, I have lived to see the day for which I had been waiting for years'." The writer continued, "I may mention here on behalf of my father regarding this tribe of the Pharaoh namely, the Lahore party, that it has transpired that one Devil among them, in speaking about the book Al-Qaulul Fasl, referred to its author saying that he was an evil minded man, a liar, a man of craft and that he would work to expose all his toils. These foul words are among the least uttered by the man. His condition is in fact similar to that of the Pharaoh. If he will not repent, then, in the end, he will be engulfed in a Hood of darkness. Amen!" Dated, February 11, 1915.
From these letters, written by or on behalf of Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan, it would appear that he had carefully heard the book Al-Qaulul Fasl from beginning to end, and had found its conclusions both valid and well-demonstrated. In other words, he considered the subject matter of the book to be at once correct and well-substantiated by the testimony of God and His holy men. He was so pleased to hear the book that he forgot his physical discomfort; and moreover its hearing enabled him to discover in me one he had been waiting for, for years. (He was here referring to the prophecy relating to a Promised son of the Promised Messiah (as), a subject to which he was never tired of referring in all his writings and discourses). We may also note that he regarded the decriers of the book as the followers of the Pharaoh or like the Pharaoh himself—men who were in danger of being engulfed in a flood of darkness. After such exuberant assurances of approval and support which Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan was pleased to accord to my beliefs, it seems altogether inexplicable that he should on the ground of those very beliefs, now announce his renunciation of my Bai‘at. Such an abrupt change is incredible in any rational person. I am certain the actual reasons must be far other than those avowed. Either the said Sayyid Sahib has been grossly deceived, or words have been attributed to him which he never uttered. At any rate, it is hardly right to say that the oldest and most learned of the living Companions of the Promised Messiah (as) has written against my beliefs, because after such an unreserved support of them, for the same person to call them heretical can never be expected from anyrational man. Regarding the subject of the Kufr of non-Ahmadis I had, as already mentioned, published an article in Tashhidhul Adhhan.
This article was cordially supported by Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan in a certain letter, some extracts from which are quoted below and will, it is hoped, be found illuminating by every fair-minded reader. Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan wrote in reference to my article above mentioned: "In my opinion, in the discussion on the subjects of Kufr and kafir, you have fully discharged your duty of conveying the message. Henceforth, there is no more need for you to devote your attention to this subject. As the Holy Qur’an says, 'They can never do you any harm so long as you are yourself rightly guided'." This letter dealt with the subject of my article on the Kufr of non-Ahmadis, which was published in April 1911. The letter itself was written by Maulawi Sahib on the 6th September 1911 from his home at Amroha.
What the Enlightened Members of the Community Think.
The tenth item in Maulawi Muhammad Ali’s narrative is that, besides Maulawi Sayyid Muhammad Ahsan, other enlightened members of the Ahmadiyya Community are now realising the error of my beliefs and their dissatisfaction is becoming more and more pronounced every day.
I have already dealt with this subject, but I may mention here once more that, by the grace of God, all the members of my Jama‘at, except such rare instances as may be known to God alone, are quite at one with me in the matter of beliefs. It would indeed be surprising if in this age of free thought and speech, educated men should find themselves opposed to my doctrines and still remain my followers, and in spite of the fact that I possess no temporal authority or power. The fact that they are with me, is itself a positive proof of the fact that they are at one with me in their views. But, nevertheless if Maulawi Muhammad Ali still thinks that he is right in his statement, then the best course for him is to publish a list of such educated members as are dissatisfied with my beliefs. If, however, he has in his mind the few who have gone over to him from among my followers, then I would request him to compare their number with the number of those who have left his ranks in order to enter my Bai‘at.