Not Approved by Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra)

Truth About the Split, Part 2

(3) Yet another refutation of the statement that the tract Kufr-o-Islam was published with the approval of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) , is to be found in the fact that in this tract Maulawi Muhammad Ali writing about Hadrat Imam Abu Hanifah says: "He entertained the belief that if any person should for once utter from the depth of his heart the formula La Ilaha Illallah, it would make him a Mu’min (believer) no matter if he should subsequently be guilty of Shirk, Kufr or Zulm." (Kufr-o-Islam by Maulawi Muhammad Ali, page 4). Such a statement is, on the face of it, without sense or significance. Nevertheless, Maulawi Muhammad Ali not only ascribes it to Hadrat Imam Abu Hanifah, but asserts that it was his considered creed. When, however, Maulawi Muhammad Ali was challenged to produce any work of Hadrat Imam Abu

Hanifah or work of any of his disciples where this belief was described as a part of the great Imam’s creed, Maulawi Muhammad Ali did not give any reply except that Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) had dictated so to him. But as Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) did not live in the time of Hadrat Imam Abu Hanifah, whatever he might have said about the Imam must have been derived from the writings of the Hanafites. But of all the works which record the words of Hadrat Imam Abu Hanifah, not one can be found which contains anything warranting the statement made by Maulawi Muhammad Ali. Under the circumstances, it cannot be held that Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) attributed any such statement to Hadrat Imam Abu Hanifah. It is certain that the statement was either an invention of Maulawi Muhammad Ali’s mind or a result of misunderstanding something which Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) might have said. Whichever view is taken, it becomes clear that the tract cannot have been approved by Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , or published with his consent.

These three items of internal evidence show then that the tract could not have been approved by Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) . But, in addition to these we may take note of the circumstance that, in spite of the fact that the tract was read over to Hadrat Khalifatul

Masih I (ra) about a month before his death, it was not published till after that sad event, although a longer tract written subsequently by Maulawi Muhammad Ali was published earlier. This fact is sufficient to indicate that the postponement of the publication of this paper was intentional, and that the obvious purpose was to await the death of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) .

10 of 10 left today