Foreword
Truth of Ahmadiyyat, Part 4
Could a person commanding such respect be deemed devoid of a sound mind? Certainly not. They could either be considered clever and quick-witted, adept at deceiving people, or they could [actually] be truthful and commissioned by God Almighty. Thus, only two possibilities exist: either they are liars misleading people in the name of God Almighty, making them the most dishonourable individuals, or they are truthful and commissioned by God Almighty requiring people to accept their claim.
Therefore, it is necessary to thoroughly consider the claim of an individual who is of sound mind and declares that they speak on behalf of God Almighty. If their claim is deemed false, it should be rejected. However, if it is the truth, denying it is no trivial matter. Rejecting a true claim is graver than playing with fire. Fire may burn the body, but rejecting a true claimant burns the soul. Fire can only end a life that spans a few decades, but rejecting a true claimant destroys a life that extends for millions of years. Fire merely separates a person from worldly pleasures, but rejecting a true claimant hinders the joys and solace of the hereafter. Fire merely severs transient relationships, but rejecting a true claimant alienates individuals from their Creator, Master, and beloved Lord. Therefore, no matter how much inquiry is undertaken on this critical matter, it remains insufficient. It is the responsibility of every individual to listen and carefully deliberate over the claim of one who asserts divine commission.
To properly reflect on such a claim, one of many methods, I will expound, is to examine whether it honours or diminishes the status of the Holy Prophet (sa). If the claim affronts his status, it should be rejected, even if the claimant can summon the sun and place it on their right hand and the moon on their left. However, if the claim establishes the superiority of the Holy Prophet (sa) and elevates his glory, it should be deemed worthy of acceptance, leaving believers with no choice but to accept the truth of the claimant.
One key tenet that requires scrutiny is the matter regarding life and death of Jesus (as). The claimant of the present age avers that Jesus (as), who was chosen by God Almighty for the reformation of the Children of Israel, has passed away and that now he [that is Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as) of Qadian] has been sent to reform the Muslim umma. Now, this claim needs to be assessed on the basis of whether it honours or diminishes the status of the Holy Prophet (sa). Any claim that supports the latter should be rejected as the superiority of the Holy Prophet (sa) is an established truth supported by evidence. Followers of other religions often consider their prophets superior to all other human beings, even if it is not the case. However, Muslims have been bless- ed with a guide who truly deserves the highest honour and reverence, and who can genuinely be referred to as the greatest of all prophets. Unfortunately, Muslims seem to have forgotten this fact and have consequently committed serious errors, leading them astray.
Let us determine whether the belief that Jesus (as) is still alive and will return to revive the umma of the Holy Prophet (sa) honours or diminishes the status of the Holy Prophet (sa). Many people believe that God Almighty raised Jesus (as) to the heavens to protect him from his enemies, where he remains to this day. On the contrary, they believe that the Holy Prophet (sa) died at the age of sixty-three and was buried on earth. He faced numerous trials and tribulations, fleeing from Mecca, being wounded in battle, and persecuted by his enemies. Throughout these ordeals, God Almighty did not raise him to the mountaintops, let alone the heavens. However, when Jesus (as) encountered the slightest suffering, God Almighty immediately raised him to the heavens. Whereas, when Muhammad (sa) was afflicted by one suffering after another, God Almighty kept him on earth without ever raising him to the heavens. The Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa) displayed an unwavering commitment and devotion to God Almighty, dedicating his days and nights to the worship and rever- ence of the divine and it became the sole purpose of his life. This aspect of his character is acknowledged even by Christians. Regardless of our personal beliefs about Muhammad (sa), it is undeniable that he constantly remembered and invoked God in every aspect of his life—whether sitting, standing, eating, drinking, sleeping, waking, whether by morning or evening, in times of joy or sorrow, during intimate moments, when getting dressed, and even while tending to the natural duties of the body. His profound love and devotion to God were akin to a person captivated by an intense longing for the divine.
Hence, the question naturally arises: Why did God Almighty not raise to the heavens a person whose love for Him surpassed all others, to the extent that even Christians were compelled to recognise his unwavering devotion, particularly during times of hardship and adversity? Moreover, why did God choose to elevate Jesus (as) to the heavens at the slightest sign of suffering? Why did the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa) have to flee from Mecca under the cover of night and seek refuge in a cave to protect himself from his enemies, whereas God Almighty, for the protection of Jesus (as), opened the gates of heaven and raised him up into the celestial realm? Hence, which of these two prophets was dearer to God Almighty and more beloved by Him?
Such a belief is an accusation against God Almighty. When Muhammad (sa) surpassed all others in his love and devotion to God, why did God Almighty not display the highest degree of love and affection for him? Why did God show greater love and affection for Jesus (as) when he faced difficulties? If Muhammad (sa) had exceeded all others in his love for God, then God Almighty should have clearly demonstrated His love by raising him to heaven during his time of trial.
The idea that the Holy Prophet (sa) would not experience a temporal death in this world even crossed the minds of his companions. When the Holy Prophet (sa) passed away, Umar (ra), a noble companion, stood with a drawn sword, declaring that he would behead anyone who claimed that the Holy Prophet (sa) had died. Umar (ra) believed that the Prophet (sa) had ascended to heaven and would return. No one dared to challenge him in that moment, and all fell silent. However, Abu Bakr (ra) arrived and upon seeing the Holy Prophet’s (sa) lifeless body, went to the companions and declared:
Muhammad (sa) was only a Messenger of Allah. The messengers before him have died. So if he dies also, will you turn back on your heels? He was just a messenger, not God Himself.
Then, Abu Bakr (ra) said:
Whoever worships Muhammad (sa) should know that he has died, and whoever worships Allah should know that He is alive and eternal.
Through these words, Abu Bakr (ra) clarified that anyone claiming the Holy Prophet (sa) had not died perceived him as a type of divine figure, for only God enjoys eternal life. The Prophet (sa) had died like messengers before him. Umar (ra) later recalled that when Abu Bakr (ra) recited this verse, he realised the reality of the Holy Prophet’s (sa) death, causing his legs to buckle, and he fell to the ground. To mark the passing of the Holy Prophet (sa), the poet Hassaan (ra) recited mournful poetry that lamented his passing:
Muhammad (sa) was everything to us. Whosoever dies after him may die, for we only feared his death.
It is evident that the superiority of the Holy Prophet (sa) can only be established when it is accepted that no messenger before him continued to live while he passed away. Otherwise, how can a true Muslim reconcile with the belief that the Holy Prophet (sa) is buried beneath the earth while Jesus (as) continues to reside in heaven? While it is possible for one prophet to live longer than another, sustaining a particular prophet for hundreds of years implies that God Almighty kept him alive because He needed him more than those prophets He allowed to die in the natural way. This constitutes a grave affront to the greatness of the Holy Prophet (sa) that no Muslim can tolerate.
In response to this, people often claim that since God Almighty is Omnipotent, He has the power to keep Jesus (as) alive in heaven. While it is true that God is All-powerful, one must also consider how His omnipotence is manifested. It is well within His power to manifest the superiority of the Holy Prophet (sa). Therefore, He would not allow anything to contradict this manifestation. Furthermore, the natural law set by God Almighty cannot sustain the life of Jesus (as) in this manner. The poor save their old clothes for reuse, while the wealthy usually donate them. Similarly, the poor save leftover food for later consumption, while the wealthy [usually] do not, knowing that they can always have freshly cooked meals. Sustaining Jesus (as) would imply that it was only by chance that God was able to raise a prophet of such high rank as Jesus (as), and since God could not do it again, He sustained Jesus (as) and placed him in heaven, ready to send him back when disorder and transgression prevailed in the world.