Foreword
Truth of Ahmadiyyat, Part 5
Believing that Jesus (as) is still alive not only insults the Holy Prophet (sa) but also dishonours God Almighty. As someone aptly said, زاب�اںڑگبیوتڑگبییھتربخےجیلدنہڑگبا. The belief that Jesus (as) is still alive is an affront against God Almighty.
Was God who raised a prophet after Jesus (as), as glorious as Muhammad (sa), incapable of raising another prophet like Jesus (as)? Of course He was capable. Consequently, God had no need to keep Jesus (as) alive and cast doubt over His own omnipotence.
This belief not only tarnishes Islam, the Holy
Prophet (sa), the Muslim community, but also brings dishonour to God Almighty. Muslims adopted this idea when it entered the Islamic belief system through the conversion of Christians to Islam in large numbers. However, many eminent figures in Islamic history have argued that Jesus (as) died a natural death. It was by giving into error that Muslims unknowingly embraced this idea. If they had realised the grave insult it represented against the Holy Prophet (sa), they would have never adopted it.
Returning back to the matter of the claimant of the current age, his second claim is that for the sake of the reformation of the umma of the Holy Prophet (sa), any reformer should be born from within it, as seeking help from an external source would be a cause of dishonour. Therefore, again, it needs to be determined whether the coming of Jesus (as) as a reformer for the umma of the Holy Prophet (sa) would diminish or honour the status of the Prophet of Islam (sa). Recently, I came across a piece in a newspaper which impressed me a lot. [To illustrate this point, a story of ] an old kingdom in Amman is mentioned. When a revolt took place against this kingdom, India offered military assistance, but the Sultan declined, saying that as long as their people had strength, they would not need any external help.
Therefore, as long as a person has any strength left in them, they neither ask for help, nor wish to receive it. Similarly, Jesus (as) did not belong to the umma of the Holy Prophet (sa); he was from the people of Moses (as) and came for their reformation. Jesus (as) himself said, “I was not sent but to the lost sheep of the house of Israel.” Believing that Jesus (as) would come to reform the umma of the Holy Prophet (sa) when it will fall into discord implies that God Almighty made the Holy Prophet (sa) dependent on the help and support of Jesus (as). This would be a grave insult to the sacred and benevolent individual who filled the world with divine light and blessings and who opened the gates of his treasures so widely that the entire world was blessed by these riches. In truth, God Almighty said to the Holy Prophet (sa):
We have given you so many blessings and re-
wards that whosoever comes to beg you, do not
turn him away.
Indeed, God Almighty said that the Holy Prophet (sa)
possessed so much wealth that:
You must loudly proclaim to people to come
and take it.
One who does not turn away a person asking for charity can be considered generous. But the kindness of the Holy Prophet (sa) far exceeded simple generosity, so much so, that God Almighty told him that his treasures were so abundant he ought to go from place to place and call people to come and take from his wealth. That is, not only should he offer his riches to those who asked for them, but that he should seek people out and offer them his treasures. Is it then befitting for a person of such glory and majesty—to whom God Almighty had entrusted the treasures of divine light and knowledge—to call upon a prophet from the Children of Israel and implore of him to save his umma once it falls into discord? If this were the case, it is difficult for me to comprehend how the Holy Prophet (sa) would be able to face Jesus (as) on the Day of Resurrection. For [the second coming of Jesus (as)] would imply that in that moment when faith had ascended to the Pleiades, [Muslims] had forsaken the Holy Qur’an, and their enemies were determined to eradicate Islam, the sanctifying power of the Holy Prophet (sa) faded. Therefore, he was forced to light a flame from elsewhere, and only an external source was able to rescue his umma. Could anything be more sorry and agonising than this? Can any greater injustice be committed against the Holy Prophet (sa)? In such circumstances who could ever believe that Muhammad (sa) was superior to all the other prophets? Thus it must be conceded that any such belief is mistaken as is the idea that a need could ever arise to send Jesus (as), who belonged to the Children of Israel, for the reformation of the umma of the Holy Prophet (sa). On the contrary, the only acceptable belief on this matter is that the sanctifying power of the Holy Prophet (sa) would give birth to Jesus (as)! That is to say, the spiritual munificence and teachings of the Holy Prophet (sa) would raise such individuals for the reformation of his umma.
Now that the points [of contention] with regards to Jesus (as) have been settled—that is, the issue of his demise, and the coming of another Jesus from within the umma of Muhammad (sa) for the sake of its reformation—[the matter of the continuity of prophethood remains]. While a consensus may be formed around the first two points, the claim that the Promised Messiah (as) had been commissioned by God as a prophet is often contested as an affront to the Holy Prophet (sa). To evaluate this claim, one must consider whether the appearance of another prophet after the Holy Prophet (sa) diminishes or honours his status. Only a prophet of higher rank can abrogate the divine law brought by a previous law-bearing prophet. Thus, believing that a prophet could appear and replace the sharia of the Holy Prophet (sa) would be an offense against him, for it would assume his teachings were no longer fit for purpose or were lacking in some way. However, just as buildings are demolished only once they have become dilapidated or are no longer able to be utilised according to their original purpose, the sharia of Muhammad (sa) can only be supplanted if it becomes untenable or obsolete. Any such belief is an insult to the Holy Prophet (sa). If the sharia of Muhammad (sa) remains operative and whole, the belief in another law-bearing prophet would undermine his status and suggest the existence of another pathway to God beyond complete obedience to the Holy Prophet (sa). And if such a gateway existed, it would have to be the equivalent to the Holy Prophet (sa) or greater than him and this too would be an affront to him. However, the question at hand is whether a person can attain the honourable rank of prophethood through obedience to the Holy Prophet (sa), as could not otherwise be attained by obeying the teachings of earlier prophets. That is, could a person by acting on the teachings of the Holy Prophet (sa) rather than standing counter to them, by coming under the servitude of the Holy Prophet (sa) rather than seeking to be his equivalent; and by submitting to his commandments rather than defying them, attain the rank of honour of prophethood. Hence, the question which needs to be determined is whether the appearance of this type of prophet would diminish or elevate the status of the Holy Prophet (sa).
Regarding the need for reformers, some argue that if they accept a prophet after the Holy Prophet (sa), it would be an insult to him because it implies that a reformer is still needed after his advent. However, this does not hold true. The appearance of Mujaddid in Islam and the acceptance of oaths of allegiance by Muslim saints clearly indicate the necessity of reformers, and they indeed appeared when they were required. The question then arises, whether it is possible for a person of a higher rank than a reformer to appear. If the umma of the Holy Prophet (sa) can never regress or decay, there would never be any need for a reformer of any type whatsoever. However, what does it say about the status of Muhammad (sa) that the condition of his umma may deteriorate and Muslims may deviate from the teachings of the sharia, yet no one will arise to rectify these evils? In reality, the immense love that God Almighty has for the Holy Prophet (sa) necessitates that He takes special care of his umma and does not allow it to perish or go astray. Showing care and attention to someone is a sign of love and affection. Can anyone claim that when their children fall ill, they do not seek a remedy for them? Or when their loved ones stray, they do not try to set them right? Certainly not. Therefore, if in the eyes of God Almighty, Muhammad (sa) holds the highest rank among all the prophets, it is imperative that God Almighty safeguards his umma more than any other community or people. The greater the degree of love, the more closely one looks after their loved ones. In matters of love, everything else becomes insignificant compared to the well-being of those we hold dear. It is narrated in a hadith that the companions would quarrel over the leftover water from the ablution of the Holy Prophet (sa). Abdullah bin ‘Umar (ra), during Hajj, would relieve himself at the same place where the Holy Prophet (sa) used to do so.
Although this may seem pe- culiar in today’s world, those who truly understand the meaning of love comprehend that when one cares deeply for someone, every aspect of their life is an object of endearment. Yet, unfortunately, there are some who believe that when the umma of the Holy Prophet (sa) falls into decline, God Almighty will not provide the means for its revival. As for those who assert that the umma of the Holy Prophet (sa) will always remain Godfearing and righteous, never requiring a reformer, if their claims were true, then it would be certain that no reformer would be needed by the umma of the Holy Prophet (sa).
However, if it is evident that Muslims have, for instance, abandoned the obligatory prayers despite the Holy Prophet’s (sa) emphatic statement that he felt like burning down the homes of those who did not go to the mosque for the Isha prayer, even if they were still inside their homes, then how can there be no need for a reformer? The importance of offering prayers, including Isha, is clearly highlighted by the Holy Prophet’s (sa) profound emphasis on it. Likewise, if it is observed that Muslims no longer fulfil their obligation of paying zakat, despite Abu Bakr’s (ra) firm stance that he would wage jihad against anyone who did not pay it, even if their dues were as little as the rope of a camel, and if other divine commandments are being abandoned by Muslims, how can there not be a need for a reformer? It is undeniable that if the condition of Muslims had not deteriorated, they would not require a reformer. However, since the decline of the Muslim community is an established fact, why is it so difficult to accept that God Almighty has made provisions for their revival? If this were not the case, it would imply that God Almighty did not truly love the Holy Prophet (sa). Therefore, those who persistently claim that the Muslim world does not need a reformer are in a state of denial. When the truth is evident to all, including the enemies of Islam, continuing to deny the need for a reformer is an act of foolishness.
Then there are those who argue that while Mujaddid and Ma’mur can emerge in Islam, another prophet cannot, as it would be seen as an insult to the Holy Prophet (sa). This would indeed be true if an individual claimed to be a law-bearing prophet and declared that they had brought a new law that superseded the sharia of the Holy Prophet (sa). However, if a person from within the umma of the Holy Prophet (sa) was granted this rank and status as an honour, it would not diminish the status of the Holy Prophet (sa). Rather, it would enhance his prestige. In the world, those who have subordinates of great merit and worth are considered to hold a high position. Why is a commander-in-chief of an army regarded as having the highest rank? It is because their subordinates are generals. Similarly, why are generals considered to occupy a high rank? It is because their subordinates consist of colonels. Therefore, the concept of superiority inherently includes the idea that those in positions of seniority have subordinates of high rank. It is absurd to assume that a person can only claim the highest rank if other people of merit cease to exist. By that logic, one could consider a child to be brave and courageous in comparison to the deceased, but would that truly be the case? A truly brave person is one who bears comparison to other courageous individuals. However, a child cannot defeat a lifeless body and claim to be brave. The courage of a person is judged in comparison to others who possess the same quality. Similarly, why are certain educational institutions considered superior to others? It is because their students excel over those of other institutes.
The Holy Prophet (sa) himself said that God Almighty had elevated him above all other prophets, and on the Day of Judgment, his umma would fill him with pride. What would make him proud of his umma?
What distinction would be bestowed upon his people that would set them apart from others? Just as the communities of other prophets witnessed the advent of reformers and Mujaddid, no prophet came within any other community to achieve that station by following the law-bearing prophet of that umma with absolute devotion. Therefore, it would be a source of pride for him that such a status was attained by one of his own servants, thereby elevating his honour and greatness. In addition to all of the above, there is yet another reason for a prophet to appear from within the umma of Muhammad (sa). The Holy Prophet (sa) has said: