Musnad Abu Hanifah 312: Disputes, Appeals, Crimes and Punishments
Hazrat Abdullah bin Mas'ud (ra) relates that a man brought his nephew, who was dead drunk, to him. He ordered him to be confined. When he came to his senses and the intoxication wore off, he sent for a whip, cut off its front knot and softened it. Then he called the executioner and said: “Strike him with the whip on the fleshy parts, but when striking do not raise your hand so high that your armpits show.” Then Abdullah began to count the lashes until the number of eighty was complete, and then he let him go. After the punishment had been carried out, the man who had brought the accused said: “O Abu Abdur Rahman! By God, this is my nephew, and apart from him I have no children.” Hearing this, Abdullah bin Mas'ud (ra) said: “You are a very bad uncle. You became the guardian and caretaker of an orphan, but you neither brought him up well in his childhood, nor covered his faults when he grew up.” Then he related this hadith: In the early days the first prescribed punishment (Hadd) was given to a thief. He had been brought to the Prophet (saw). When clear proof of his crime was found, the Holy Prophet (saw) said: “Take him away and cut off his hand.” When the people were taking him away, they saw that this had affected the blessed face of the Holy Prophet (saw); he was sorrowful and sad. At this some submitted: “It seems that the Holy Prophet is exceedingly grieved by this incident.” The Holy Prophet (saw) said: “Why should I not be grieved? You people become helpers of Satan against your brother.” People submitted: “Why did the Holy Prophet not let him go?” At this he (saw) said: “You could have let him go before bringing this complaint to me. When the accused is brought before the Imam and the crime is proved, then after this procedure the prescribed (punishment) becomes binding, and the Imam (judge) cannot suspend this punishment.” After saying this, he (saw) recited this verse: “Let them forgive and pass over the offence.” (Qur’an 24:23)
AI-translated by Islam-Today