The Answers

Three Questions by a Christian and their Answers, Part 4

A careful look at the verses under consideration makes it clear that the first two meanings cannot be correct. It would be wrong to understand from this verse that God will not send any of the numerous signs of warning which He can send, nor will He send any of the numerous signs of chastisement as are beyond human perception and are within His limitless power, merely because earlier people had rejected them. It is evident that earlier people rejected only those signs which they had witnessed, for how can something be rejected which has not been seen? While it is in the power of God to show such extraordinary signs as no man can deny, and to which everyone has to submit, and while He has the power to show every sign, and the signs of His power are infinite and limitless, how can it be correct to say that all of them have been seen and rejected within a short period of time! The fact is that only a limited number of signs could have been shown in a limited period of time. Therefore, the correct meaning of the verse is that it is futile to send again the signs which have been seen and rejected by earlier unbelievers. This is the meaning which emerges when the verse is seen in its true context. Here God refers to the she-camel of Thamud, and this reference shows that the verse relates only to signs of warning which were shown and rejected in the past. This is the third and true meaning of the verse.

Yet another point, which will make things even clearer to discerning people, is that the verse:

bears an affirmation, rather than a negation, of miracles. The point relates to the definite article 'Al', which, according to the rules of Arabic grammar, bears either an all-inclusive connotation or a particular connotation. If the former connotation is adopted, the verse would mean, 'Nothing could hinder Us from sending all the signs, except that they have been rejected by earlier peoples.' And if we were to adopt the 'particular' connotation, the verse would mean, 'Nothing could hinder Us from showing the particular signs (which are being demanded by the unbelievers), except that they have been rejected by earlier people.' In either case, the verse affirms the showing of miracles. To say that all signs cannot be shown because they have been rejected by earlier people, proves that some signs will be shown. For instance, when somebody says that he has not given Zaid everything he possesses, it clearly means that he has given Zaid at least a portion of his possessions. Conversely, if the verse means that God did not send some particular signs, it also proves that some other signs were sent. For instance, when someone says that he has not given Zaid some particular things, it means that he has given Zaid something else. One should first examine the verses adjacent to the one in question and see how they both speak of the signs of chastisement. Secondly, is it conceivable that all the unlimited signs and wonders, which appear from time to time as a manifestation of God’s infinite power, could have been rejected by earlier people in their limited time? Thirdly, one should consider with all fairness, whether the verse speaks of the signs of warning in particular, or if there is some mention of the signs of mercy and glad-tidings as well. Fourthly, one should look again at the article 'Al' of the word Al-Ayat and see what meaning it conveys.

Having considered all the four points, every person—except the one whom prejudice keeps away from the truth—will find, not one, but thousands of testimonies to prove that the negation in this verse pertains only to a particular category of signs, and it does not in any way affect the other kinds of signs; it, in fact, categorically affirms their existence. In these verses, Allah clearly declares that the signs of chastisement which these people demand will not be shown to them because they have been rejected by earlier people. To show, over and over again, signs which have been rejected before, would be an indication of weakness, and would not be worthy of the All-Powerful One. Thus, these verses clearly state that signs of chastisement will be shown, but in different ways. There is no need whatsoever to show the same signs again that were shown by Moses (as) or Noah (as), or the signs that were given to the people of Lot (as) or ‘Ad or Thamud. These verses have been further explained by some other verses. Allah says:

That is: And even if they see every sign, they will not believe therein, so much so, that when they come to thee, they dispute with thee. And when there comes to them a sign, they say: 'We will never believe until we are given something similar to that which Allah’s Messengers have been given.' Say, 'I have come with a clear proof from my Lord, you see that proof and yet you reject it. That which you wish to hasten (punishment) is not within my power. Judgement lies with no one but Allah. He will make the truth clear and He is the Best of Judges. Surely, one day He will judge between you and me. Clear proofs of my Prophethood have come to you from my Lord: so whoever chooses to see, does so for his own good; and whoever turns blind does so to his own peril, and I am not a watcher over you.' And they ask thee to hasten the punishment. Say, He has the power to send punishment upon you, from above you, or from beneath your feet, or to split you into groups and make you taste one another’s wrath. And say, all praise belongs to Allah; He will soon show you His signs, which you will recognize. Say, for you is the promise of a year from which you cannot remain behind a single moment, nor can you get ahead of it. And they enquire of thee: Is it true? Say, Yea by my Lord, it is most true and you cannot thwart the fulfilment of God’s promises. We will soon show them Our signs around their country, as well as among them until it becomes manifest to them that this Prophet is true in his claim. Man loves haste. Certainly I will soon show you My signs, but ask Me not to make haste. Look, how clearly and firmly these verses hold out promises of the signs that were demanded. They go so far as to say that these signs will be so clear that people will easily recognize them.

If someone were to say: It is true that the Holy Qur’an promises signs of chastisement at several places, and these signs will surely be fulfilled some day, and we also agree that these promises were fulfilled at the time when God manifested His power and rid the Muslims of their weak and helpless state, and from a few they became thousands, and through them He subjugated all the unbelievers of Mecca, who, during their time of tyranny, had arrogantly demanded the signs of chastisement; but where, in the Holy Qur’an, do we find evidence that the Holy Prophet (sa) showed other signs besides these?

Let it be clear that the Holy Qur’an repeatedly mentioned the showing of signs. At places it referred to signs that had already been shown. See the verse:

At other places, the Holy Qur’an refers to the biased attitude of the unbelievers and records their assertion that the signs are no more than sorcery. See the verse:

At places the Holy Qur’an presents the testimonies of the unbelievers, that they had indeed witnessed the signs, as it says:

They have testified to the truth of the Prophet (sa), and visible signs have come to them. At places specific miracles have been described, for instance, the miracle of the splitting of the moon, which is a most extraordinary miracle indeed, and is a perfect manifestation of the power of God. I have discussed this in detail in my book Surma Chashm Arya. Anyone interested may refer to it.

It should also be remembered that the majority of those who demanded from the Holy Prophet (sa) signs of their own imagining, ultimately became witnesses to the signs of the Holy Prophet (sa) by accepting Islam and spreading it far and wide. As witnesses to the signs and miracles of the Holy Prophet (sa), they also had their testimonies recorded in books of Hadith. The attitude of critics in our time is strange: They keep repeating how these elders of faith denied these miracles in their time of ignorance—even though they ul- timately withdrew from their denial with penitent hearts; but they refuse to accept the testimonies provided by the same people after they had turned to the right path! The miracles and signs of the Holy Prophet (sa) shine from every angle, it is impossible for them to remain hidden. The miracles that have been testified by the Companions of the Holy Prophet (sa) are about three thousand in number. In addition, there are prophecies, that have already been fulfilled or are continuing to be fulfilled with the passage of time, and they number about ten thousand. Then there are some miracles and prophecies of the Holy Qur’an, the fulfilment of which we perceive and witness even in this age and no one can ever deny them. These are as follows:

First are the miracles of the signs of chastisement, which were shown to the unbelievers at that time, and it seems as if we too are a witness to these signs even in this age, because they are the inevitable result of some sure and inviolable premises which neither friend nor foe can deny. The first premise, which forms the foundation for these miracles, is the self-evident and incontrovertible fact that these signs were demanded from the Holy Prophet (sa) when he and his few Companions in Mecca were themselves undergoing great suffering and hardship on account of inviting people to the truth; and Islam was in such a weak and helpless state that the infidels would ridicule and taunt the Muslims by saying, "If you are true, why then are you suffering such pain and torment at our hands? Why does your God, on whom you depend, not come to your rescue?

Why are you such an insignificant little group of people who are soon going to be annihilated? And if you are indeed true, then why does no punishment come down upon us?" The Holy Qur’an’s reply to these taunts, at a time when the Muslims were in such a desperate state, forms the second premise which helps us to understand the true grandeur of this prophecy. It was a very trying time for the Holy Prophet (sa) and his Companions; they were always fearful for their lives and failure stared them in the face from all sides. It was at such a time that the unbelievers demanded the signs of chastisement and were told, in clear and unequivocal terms, that they would soon be shown the sign of the triumph of Islam and of their own chastisement. And Islam—which was no more than a seed at the time—would manifest itself in the form of a great tree. Those who demanded the sign of chastisement would be killed by the sword. The Arabian Peninsula would be cleared of all disbelief and all non-believers, and the governance of the whole of Arabia would fall into the hands of the believers. God Almighty would establish the faith of Islam to such an extent that idol-worship would never recur in the land. The current state of fear and insecurity would give place to peace and tranquillity. Islam would gain strength and continue to dominate until it would become victorious over other lands, and its triumph would spread far and wide. A great kingdom would be born which would not see decline till the end of the world.

When a person first looks at these two premises, and discovers that the time when this prophecy was announced was one of great hardship, despair and misery for Islam, and how the prophecy made at that time was diametrically opposed to prevailing conditions, and how it was beyond all imagination and conjecture, and was, in fact, an outright impossibility, and then casts an unprejudiced look at the history of Islam—which is accessible to friend and foe alike—he will see how clearly this prophecy was fulfilled, how powerfully it moved hearts, and how it manifested itself far and wide with all its might and power; he will then be obliged to admit that this is most certainly a miracle to which he himself is a witness, and he will remain in no doubt about it whatsoever.

The second miracle of the Holy Qur’an, which we can perceive and witness in our own time, is the marvellous transformation of the Companions of the Holy Prophet (sa), through their submission to the Holy Qur’an and under the influence of the Holy Prophet’s (sa) companionship. When we look at the kind of people they were and how they behaved before they accepted Islam, and how they were transformed by the company of the Holy Prophet (sa) and by submission to the Holy Qur’an, and how, in respect of their morals, their beliefs, their behaviour, their demeanour, their conduct, and all their practices, they rid themselves of their evil condition and entered into a pure and immaculate state; and when we look at the wonderful influence which brought a strange light and radiance to their rusty beings, we have to concede that this change was indeed miraculous and it was brought about specially by the Hand of God, as He says in the Holy Qur’an: I found them dead and I brought them to life, I found them falling into the pit of hell and I rescued them from this dreadful state, I found them ailing and I healed them, I found them in darkness and I gave them light. In order to manifest this miracle, God Almighty has, on the one hand, described the evil condition of the people of Arabia before they accepted Islam, and, on the other, He has described their transformation into a state of piety after their acceptance of Islam, so that whoever analyzes the condition of the Arabs at the time of their denial, and compares it to their condition after they had entered the fold of Islam, will become convinced that this change was completely out of the ordinary, and was no less than a miracle.

·

10 of 10 left today