The Answers
Three Questions by a Christian and their Answers, Part 5
The third miracle of the Holy Qur’an, to which we can ourselves testify, lies in the truths and verities, and points of beauty and subtlety which abound in its eloquent text. This miracle has been greatly emphasized in the Holy Qur’an. It says, let the Jinn and men join in their effort to produce the like of this Book; they shall fail. This miracle is corroborated by the fact that, although this challenge of the Holy Qur’an has been proclaimed loud and clear in every corner of the world for the last thirteen hundred years, no one has been able to take it up. This categorically proves that the whole human potential put together is incapable of contesting the Holy Qur’an. In fact, if we were to search for the equivalent of just one, out of the innumerable excellences of the Holy Qur’an, it would be beyond the capacity of a poor mortal to produce anything like it.
One of the many beauties of the Holy Qur’an, for instance, is that it is a compendium of all religious verities. There is not a single religious verity, relating to truth and wisdom, which is not to be found in the Holy Qur’an. But can anyone show us another book which possesses this quality? If anyone is in doubt about the Holy Qur’an being the compendium of all religious verities, regardless of whether he is a Christian, an Arya, a Brahmu Samajist or an atheist, he is welcome to test this claim in the manner of his own choosing and thus satisfy himself; and I undertake to satisfy any seeker after truth who comes to me.
All the sacred truths found in the Bible, all the points of truth and wisdom contained in the writings of the sages which have come to my knowledge, all the verities which have perchance been recorded and have survived in the Vedas of the Hindus that I have had the occasion to see, and all the finer points of truth and wisdom contained in hundreds of books by the Sufis that I know of, I find them all in the Holy Qur’an. It has become categorically and unambiguously clear to me, as a result of the perfect inductive knowledge that I have acquired from thirty long years of deep and extensive observation, that there is not a single spiritual truth that can contribute to the consummation of the self and development and training of the human mind and soul, which is not to be found in the Holy Qur’an. I am not alone in reaching this conclusion, the Holy Qur’an itself makes this claim—a claim which has been tested, not only by myself, but by thousands of scholars who have all along testified to its truth.
The fourth miracle of the Holy Qur’an is its spiritual influence which endures to this day, i.e., those who follow the Holy Qur’an, attain stations of Divine acceptance and are blessed with Divine discourse. God hears their prayers and answers them out of His love and grace. He communicates to them some of the secrets of the unseen, just as He does to His Prophets, and He distinguishes them from His other creation with signs of His help and succour. This is a sign that will last in the Muslim umma till the Day of Judgement. It has continued to be manifested in the past, it lives on to this day, and is a verifiable fact. Even today there are people among the Muslims whom God blesses with His special support and honours them with pure and true revelations, glad-tidings and news of the unseen.
Now, you who seek after truth and crave and thirst for true signs, be fair, and ponder with an unbiased mind how wonderful the signs that God Almighty has mentioned in the Holy Qur’an are, and how they can be seen and felt in every age! As for the miracles of earlier Prophets, they are a thing of the past and are much like fairy tales. Only God knows how authentic they really are.
This is particularly true of the miracles of Jesus (as) mentioned in the New Testament. Even though we allow for the fact that they have been related in the form of fables and tales and are full of exaggerations, it is still difficult to clear them of all the doubts and misgivings to which they are susceptible. Even if we were to suppose for a moment that there is no exaggeration in all that has been written in the
New Testament about Jesus (as) curing the lame, the crippled, the paralyzed, and the sick, etc., by his mere touch, and that it is all to be taken literally, and it does not have any other connotation, even then it would not confer any merit on him. First of all, there was a pool in those very days which could cure people suffering from all such ailments if they had a dip in it at a particular moment. This has been mentioned in the New Testament itself.
Secondly, it has been proven by long observation and research that the healing of the sick is one of the many branches of science, and many people are to be found even today who are adept in this field. This science requires extreme concentration, mental power, and expertise in controlling another person’s thoughts. Hence, this ability has nothing to do with Prophethood, and it does not even require that the person practising it should be pious. This science has been in vogue since times immemorial. Some eminent Muslim scholars—such as Mohyuddin Ibn-e- ‘Arabi, author of the Fusus, and some elders of the Naqshbandi order—are known to have been great experts in this science and had no equal in their own times. Of some of them it has been said that, with perfect concentration, and with the leave of God, they could even talk to the people who had recently passed away; and that they could gather two or three hundred patients around them and restore them to health with a single glance. Those who were less proficient in this art would cure a patient by touching him or his clothes. When he practised this art, the practitioner would feel as if some sort of energy was radiating from his person; and the patient would at times feel as though some poisonous matter within him was moving down to his lower limbs until it vanished altogether.
Muslims have written numerous books on this subject, and I believe the Hindus have done the same. The art of mesmerism invented by the Europeans in our time is also a branch of the same knowledge. Upon examination, the New Testament reveals that Jesus (as) was also, to an extent, proficient in this art, though not to the degree of perfection. Nevertheless, since people in those days were simpleminded and ignorant of this art, it was considered deserving of greater acclaim than it actually was. But, as time passed, and the truth became more and more evident, people grew weaker in their faith, until they began to say that healing the sick or curing the insane by such practices is not something that deserves merit, and it does not even require that one should be a believer, let alone that it should serve as a proof of someone’s Prophethood or Sainthood. They even say that to become perfect in the exercise of curing bodily ailments and to occupy oneself day and night in this voca- tion is very harmful for spiritual advancement, and such people are poor at imparting spiritual training, and their heart’s ability to give light to others also becomes feeble. Perhaps it may be for this very reason that Jesus (as) proved to be so weak in imparting spiritual training. Reverend Taylor, who appears to be a man of stature on account of his office and his personal ability, writes with great regret that the spiritual training imparted by the Messiah (as) proved to be weak and ineffective.
The people who formed his company, and were known as the Apostles, showed no enviable example, either in their spiritual development or in the perfection of their human capacities. (Would that Jesus (as) had concentrated less on the practice of healing the sick and had given more attention to curing the spiritual weaknesses and ailments of his disciples, and particularly those of Judas Iscariot.) At this point, the said gentleman also writes that if the Apostles are compared with the Companions of the Prophet of Arabia (sa), in their spiritual development and the strength of their faith, we would have to admit, albeit regretfully, that the Apostles were seriously lacking in spiritual development, and that Jesus’ companionship proved of little help in enhancing their faculties of mind and heart which could have earned them any merit vis-à-vis the Companions of the Holy Prophet (sa). Rather, they showed cowardice, lack of faith, meanness, worldliness and infidelity at every step. The Companions of the Arabian Prophet (sa), on the other hand, showed such sincerity and devotion, the like of which can hardly be found amongst followers of any other Prophet. This was the result of perfect spiritual training which completely transformed them and raised them to immeasurable heights. Likewise, many Western intellectuals have recently published books in which they have admitted that, if we leave aside those miracles of the Prophet of Arabia (sa) which are found duly recorded, and consider only the circumstances of his devotion to God, his faith, his steadfastness, his perfect and pure teachings, his spiritual influence, his reformation of many mischief-makers, and the implicit and explicit Divine support he enjoyed, our sense of justice compels us to admit that all these accomplishments are undoubtedly miraculous in nature and are beyond the realm of human power, and these signs are potent and powerful enough to prove the truth and authenticity of someone’s Prophethood. No man, unless God is with him, can ever succeed and become perfect in these matters, nor can he be accompanied by such unseen support.
The objections raised by the Christian gentleman are not three objections, they are, in fact, three misunderstandings which have found their way into his heart through lack of deliberation. To these three misunderstandings we will turn one by one.
The answer to the first misunderstanding is that it is never a distinctive sign of a true Prophet to know everything of the unseen, just like God. It is solely God’s prerogative to possess the knowledge of the unseen in His own right and as a personal attribute. Since time immemorial, men of God have believed the Necessary Being to be the Knower of the unseen, and have believed all other existents to be excluded from this knowledge. That is to say, they believed that God has to be the Knower of the unseen, and that this attribute is the exclusive prerogative of His Being. It is not the prerogative of all existents—whose being is liable to pass into non-existence and non-reality—to share with God this or other such attributes. Just as no one can be the partner of God in His Person, the same prohibition stands in respect of His attributes. Therefore, all other existents are barred from the knowledge of the unseen, regardless of whether they are Prophets or Muhaddathin or Saints. Yes, receiving knowledge of the unseen through Divine revelation has always been the privilege of His chosen ones, and today we find it only in the followers of the Holy Prophet (sa) and in no one else.
It is the way of God that, from time to time, He favours His chosen ones with some of His special secrets, and the bounty of the knowledge of the unseen rains down upon them at the appointed and predetermined time. In fact, those who are truly close to God are tested and recognized by the fact that they are given knowledge of some future events, and some hidden secrets are revealed to them. But all this is not by their own authority and their own choosing, rather these bounties are given to them by the will and choice and authority of God.