A Brief Note for the Hasty Critics
Arba’in, Part 2
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
—[and verily, deeds are (judged) by intentions (Sahih al-Bukhari, Kitabu Bad’il-Wahi, Bab Kaifa Kana Bad’ul-Wahi ‘ila Rasululahi s (as), Hadith 1)]. Moreover, it was repeatedly advertised that anyone who cannot wait may ask for a refund of whatever money he had paid in advance. There was no reason to raise any objection unless one has a dirty mind. (2) The second objection is that my prophecies were not fulfilled. The only answer to this is:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
لَعْنَۃ [‘The curse of Allah be upon the liars’]. More than 100 prophecies have been fulfilled, for which there are thousands of witnesses. The prophecy concerning Atham was conditional and was fulfilled according to the condition. Tell me if that revelation was not conditional? To deny the truth is an act of the cursed. Even if I had an independent personal opinion that Atham would die within the prescribed time, you must first become an apostate from Islam to deny my right to hold such an opinion. The ijtihad [independent personal opinion] of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, according to his hadith,
[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]
ذ [(Sahih al-Bukhari, Kitabul-Manaqib, Bab al-‘Alamatin-Nubuwah fil-Islam, Hadith 3622)] also was incorrect. Then, according to your rule, you would also consider the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, false! First, reply to this question, and then you may criticize me. In the same way, the prophecy about the son-in-law of Mirza Ahmad Baig was also conditional. If you have any faith left, then why don’t you wait for this stipulation [to be fulfilled]? What kind of honesty was this that you didn’t even mention the prophecy about Lekh Ram in your entire book? Was that prophecy fulfilled or not? Did Ahmad Baig die within the stipulated time frame in accordance with the prophecy, or not? Only recently, upon my inquiry, your respected friend Deputy Fateh Ali Shah testified with great conviction that the prophecy about Lekh Ram had been clearly fulfilled. You belong to the same Jama‘at, but still, you are denying the truth! Author face death[and go before God]! Had they shown some sense of shame and integrity, they would have hated what Mehr Ali Shah Golarhvi did in my opposition.
Did I invite him to have a debate on religious tenets with him and then do his bai‘at? When I have already declared repeatedly that God has sent me as the Promised Messiah and has informed me which particular hadith is authentic and which hadith is not, and He has bestowed on me the correct understanding of the Holy Qur’an, then why should I engage with these people in a debate on religious tenets, when I have the same firm faith in wahi [revelations] that I have received as I have in the Torah, the Gospel and the Holy Qur’an? Do they expect me to discard my faith which is based on knowledge by the certainty of experience, and that I should accept their conjectures and collection of false narrations?
They, too, cannot leave their opposition because they have already published books full of falsehood against me. Presently, to revert from their opinions is worse than death for them. In such a dire situation, what is the use of getting into a debate with them? When I had already published the announcement that in the future, I would not enter into any debate on religious tenets with any maulawi; justice and good faith demanded that they should not even make a mention of these debates on religious tenets before me.
Could I have broken my promise? If Mehr Ali Shah’s heart was not rotten, then why did he request me for such a debate that I had already resolutely declared to have abandoned? Making such a request, he tried to deceive people by giving the impression that he was accepting my invitation. Look at the astonishing deception that he used: He wrote in his published announcement that first, I should enter into a debate on religious tenets with him, and then, if Sheikh Muhammad Husain Batalavi and two of his colleagues declare on oath that the beliefs presented by Mehr Ali Shah are correct, then without any hesitation I should enter in his bai‘at there and then in that meeting!
Now, look! Does any deception greater than this occur in the world? I simply challenged him to see a Sign or show a Sign, and I said that both parties should write commentary by way of a miracle in Arabic on any one of the Surahs [Chapters] of the Holy Qur’an. The party whose commentary and Arabic diction is proven to reach the calibre of a Sign from the perspective of eloquence and fluency would be deemed the recipient of God’s support. It was very clearly written that there would not be any discussions on religious tenets. The contest would be only to see and show a Sign. But Pir Sahib discarded my entire invitation and submitted a request for a debate on religious tenets and made it the basis for the final decision. He wrote [deceptively]that he had accepted my challenge with only one additional condition!
O deceitful man! May God hold you to account! In what way did you accept my invitation when, in fact you asked me to enter into your bai‘at depending on a debate on religious tenets, while you knew well that I could not accept it because I had already published an announcement of my pledge concerning that kind of debate. Then, how was it that my invitation was accepted? Furthermore, after having entered into your bai‘at, what opportunity would there remain to act upon my invitation? Is your deception such that people cannot see through it?
Without any doubt, they understood it, but then they slaughtered the truth intentionally! In short, this is the condition of their faith! After committing such injustice, they hurl thousands of abuses in their published announcements, forgetting that one day they have to die [and face God]! How joyfully they say that Mehr Ali Shah came to Lahore, and I did not contest him! What kind of cure can I provide for the hearts that God curses? My heart painfully awaits a verdict.
A long time has passed. My wish has still not been fulfilled that someone from those people desires to reach a verdict based on truth, honesty, and good intent, but sadly these people do not enter the fray with sincerity of heart. God is ready to make a judgment, and like a she-camel lifts her tail to deliver a calf, this age itself is demanding a verdict.
Would that someone from among them seek a judgment! Would that someone from among them be rightly guided! I invite them based on perfect discernment, but they reject me relying upon mere conjectures! Their fault-findings are also for the same reason that they may find some flaw.
O ignorant people! This Movement has been established from the heavens. Do not fight with God! You cannot annihilate Him. God always succeeds. What is in your hands other than a few ahadith that the seventy-three sects have cut into small pieces and divvied up amongst themselves? Where is truth and conviction seen? You accuse each other of lying.