Footnote Number Eleven
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part IV, Part 3
Thus, by looking at all of these matters, a wise person can reach the conclusion that God has cast human nature in this particular mould; and this very mould indicates that it was not the will of the All-Wise to leave man, feeble as he is, to the mercy of his own imagination and conjecture. Rather, the kind of counsellors and advisors who can grant him satisfaction, comfort, suppression of passions, and removal of spiritual restlessness; He has created all of those advisors for him, and has provided him with the Word that can cure his illnesses and maladies. No different methodology is needed to prove the need for revelation, as God’s own law of nature proves it.
Is it not true that millions of people in the world who are mired in misery, sin, or heedlessness are constantly influenced by other counsellors and advisers, and that one’s own knowledge and thinking are certainly not effective in every case? Moreover, the fact is that the speaker’s words provide satisfaction and comfort to the same degree that the speaker’s status and eminence are established in the eyes of the listener. Only the promise of such a person—who, in the eyes of the listener, is truthful in his promises and is also capable of fulfilling them—grants comfort to the mind. In this scenario, who can doubt the obvious fact that, concerning matters of the life to come and matters beyond physical perception, the highest degree of satisfaction, solace, and comfort to the mind, which is capable of averting carnal passions and spiritual misfortunes, can only be obtained from the Word of God?
Reflection upon the law of nature cannot establish any better means of comfort and satisfaction. When a person believes wholeheartedly in the Word of God and there is no intervention of any overt or covert aversion, the Word of God saves him from fierce whirlpools, fights off intense carnal passions, and affords him patience during the most terrifying calamities. When a wise person, at the time of any difficulty or arousal of carnal passion, finds a promise or warning in the Word of God, or someone else explains to him what God has commanded, he is immediately affected so deeply that he goes on repenting uncontrollably. Man is in dire need of being comforted by God. Very often he is overtaken by such misfortunes that he would have been so discouraged as to possibly deny the very existence of God, would have cut off his relationship with God altogether in his hopelessness, or would have perished from the shocks of grief, had the Word of God not been revealed and had it not provided him with this glad tiding:
In the same way, carnal passions are such that God’s Word is needed for dissipating their boiling upsurge. At every step, man encounters circumstances which can be remedied only by the Word of God. When a person desires to turn to God, hundreds of impediments block his attention—sometimes the pleasures of this world come to his mind, sometimes the company of his close friends pulls at his cloak, and sometimes he is intimidated by the difficulties of this path. Sometimes old habits and prevailing customs become his stumbling blocks and sometimes honour, fame, authority, or power try to obstruct him from this path. Sometimes all of these gather together like an army and pull him in their direction and present him with the excellences of their immediate benefits. Thus, their combined strength and thronging effect develop such force that one’s self-conceived ideas are unable to repulse them—indeed, they cannot withstand them for even one moment. On the occasion of such a battle, the powerful guns of God’s Word are needed to disperse the enemy lines by the firing of just a single shot.
Can any task be accomplished one-sidedly; hence, how is it possible that God should perpetually remain silent like a stone, while His servant continues to progress on his own in his loyalty, sincerity, and steadfastness; and only the notion that there must—after all—be a Creator of heaven and earth, grants him never-ending strength and draws him ever-forward in the fields of love? Ideas based on conjecture can never take the place of ideas based on facts, nor have they ever done so. For instance, suppose that a truthful wealthy person promises a poor debtor that he would pay off all of his debt when the payment is due, and there is another poor debtor who has been given no verbal promise by anyone but gives free rein to his imagination that perhaps he, too, would receive the necessary funds at the due time. Can these two be equal in their satisfaction? Certainly not! Certainly not!
All of these are the very laws of nature. Which true verity lies outside the laws of nature? But woe unto those people who, while claiming to abide by the laws of nature, violated them, ran over to the other side, and acted contrary to what they had affirmed. O Brahmu Samajists! Even if you cannot pay heartfelt attention to religious matters and even if you have no concern whatsoever for the life that is yet to come, has it not been proven to you with regard to worldly matters that reason by itself has not carried any of your worldly tasks to completion? Is there any room left for you to deny the verity that intellect never had the ability to carry any task to its completion in the best and perfect manner on its own, without being paired with a companion? Speak the truth! Have you still not experienced that whatever task relied exclusively upon intellect remained doubtful, conjectural, and incomplete; and until a portrait of the events was sketched by a recorder, the entire effort of intellect and conjecture remained incomplete and unreliable? Speak with justice! Are you still unaware that it has always been the practice of the wise that they strengthen their theories—sometimes with experience, sometimes with history, sometimes with maps depicting the geography of a place, sometimes with letters and epistles, and sometimes with their own faculties of seeing, hearing, smelling, touching, and so on? So now reflect for yourselves, weigh it in your own minds, and estimate it duly in your observation: Given the condition that other companions are required for [understanding] the matters of this world, which are observable and perceivable, then how much greater is that need for those matters that transcend this world, are the most hidden of the hidden, and are the most concealed of the concealed? And given that reason by itself does not suffice even for the easy and simple matters of the world, how can it be sufficient to fathom matters relating to the life to come, which are the most abstruse and subtle?
Moreover, since you do not consider conjecture and intellect, alone, to be sufficient for the fickle and mundane matters of daily life—whose gain and loss are but a transient matter—how can you sit complacently, relying on the same defective intellect in matters of the Hereafter, whose impact is everlasting and whose dangers are irremediable? Is this not the best proof of this fact, that you have thrown all regard for the Hereafter behind your back, and you find the carcass of the world so delicious and palatable? Otherwise, how can it be believed that God has not given you even this minimal understanding that when the Perfectly Noble God has not left man’s reason alone with respect to the transitory matters of the world—on the contrary, He has strengthened it with many companions—then why did His eternal and everlasting attribute of great mercy disappear when it was needed for the subtle and intricate affairs of the abode of the Hereafter, which are everlasting and permanent? Why, in this case, did He not strengthen the weak and confused reason by joining it with a perfect companion; and why did He not grant it a partner personally acquainted with this realm in its macro and micro details, who could provide information like an eyewitness so that reason and experience, having been paired, could serve as the fountainhead of multifarious blessings and convey the seeker after truth to the stage of perfect cognition, the eagerness for acquiring which is ingrained in his nature?
I do not know who has misled you into thinking that there is somewhat of an incompatibility between reason and revelation, on account of which the two cannot coexist together. May God open your eyes and remove the veils over your heart. Can you not understand the simple fact that since reason attains its perfection by virtue of revelation, is warned of its errors, discovers the best course for its intended journey, is delivered from random wandering and confusion, is relieved of useless effort, vain toil, and fruitless travail, converts its dubious and supposed knowledge into definite certainty, and, advancing beyond mere conjecture, is informed of true facts and is comforted and finds peace and tranquillity; then, under these circumstances, is revelation a benefactor, helper, and educator of reason, or its enemy, opponent, and assailant? What kind of bigotry and what type of blindness is it to imagine the venerable educator, who clearly serves as a leader and guide, to be a highwayman and obstructor, and the one who pulls out of a pit to be the one who pushes into the pit?
The whole world knows—and all with eyes are observing, and perceptive minds are discerning—that there were, and still are, hundreds of thousands of people in the world who believed in the merits and greatness of reason, and despite believing in the ‘apostle’ of reason, and being called ‘wise’, and believing intellect to be a precious commodity and their guide, nevertheless they remained in denial of the existence of God and died in that very denial. However, show me just one person who believed in revelation, yet remained a disbeliever in the existence of God.
Hence, insofar as revelation is the only condition for firm faith in God, it is obvious that where this condition is lacking the result contingent upon it will also be lacking. So it now stands clearly proven that those who have denied revelation have deliberately chosen the ways of faithlessness and have deemed it proper that the doctrine of atheism should spread and be propagated. These ignorant ones fail to reflect that since the Utmost Hidden Being [of God] cannot be seen, nor smelt, nor touched—and should the faculty of hearing be similarly deprived and unaware of the Word of the Perfect Being—how can one then believe in the existence of that Imperceptible Being? Should the thought of a Creator even arise in the mind by pondering over the universe, but despite a lifelong effort, the seeker after truth never sees the Creator with his eyes, nor is aware of His Word, nor discovers any indication about Him that characterizes a being who is alive and well; then would the doubt not eventually befall him that perchance his deliberation erred in concluding the existence of the Creator, and maybe the atheists and naturalists are right, who conclude that certain elements of the universe are creators of certain other elements, and think that there is no need for any other Creator?
I know that if a follower of mere reason gives free rein to this line of thinking, his mind will certainly be seized by the doubt mentioned above, for, it is not possible for him to escape such doubts if, in spite of his utmost search and exertion, he fails to find a personal sign of God. The reason is that it is the inherent and natural habit of man that if he considers something necessary and indispensable through presumed conjecture, but fails to discover its existence externally despite the utmost search and diligent inquiry, he begins to doubt and, indeed, deny the validity of his conjecture, and hundreds of doubts opposed to his conjecture arise in his mind.
Time after time, all of us indulge in conjectures with regard to an unknown fact, thinking that it could be this or that, but when the details are revealed, it turns out to be something altogether different. These daily experiences have taught man the lesson that it is the height of foolishness to rest assured with mere conjectures.