Footnote Number Eleven

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part IV, Part 4

In short, as long as conjectural speculations are not supported by the facts of the matter, the entire display put on by reason is a mirage and nothing more, the ultimate outcome of which is atheism. So if you desire to be an atheist, do as you please; otherwise, the only way you can be delivered from the fierce flood of doubts—which has swept thousands of intellectuals far superior than you into the depth of degradation with a single surge—is to take a firm hold of the strong handle of true revelation. However, it will never happen that, by advancing your ideas on reason alone, you will find God sitting somewhere. Rather, the only result of the progression of your thoughts will be that you will ultimately find God without a visible sign and without the perceptible characteristics of living beings, and after becoming helpless and frustrated in your quest for Him, you will end up joining hands with your atheist brothers.

Do not be deceived by thinking that if the consequence of following mere reason is atheism, then why do the Brahmu Samajists still have some faith in the existence of God and why do they not become His deniers en masse? There are two reasons for this. The first is that they have not yet achieved the full progression of their ideas, and they are holding on to the belief in that Being who is the internal product of their hypothetical reasoning. They have not yet stepped forward to search for the actual existence of that hypothetical Being somewhere externally. But bear in mind that as soon as they progress in their ideas, the first effect of their progression will be a rankling within their minds as to where and in which direction that Being is, whom they believe to be the Self-Subsisting, All-Sustaining, and Omnipresent, and that if He really does have a physical existence externally, then why is He not found and why does He not reveal His Being to those who are searching for Him? And as soon as this doubt emerges, they will either end up believing in true revelation and thus deliver their selves from the whirlpool of doubts or, if that is not the case, let the ideas evolve, and see for yourself whether or not they become staunch atheists.

When the ideas of hundreds of thousands of their very own brothers, who conformed to reason alone, progressed, they died having become naturalists and atheists. These followers of reason are not unique. They will not escape becoming atheists with the progression of their ideas, nor will they see the crystal palace wherein God dwells! Undoubtedly, whatever consequence befell the earlier ‘intellectuals’ through the advancement of their ideas, the same consequence will someday befall these people as well. The delay is only that they are not yet fully engaged in their pursuit and quest for God. This world still appears dear and sweet to them and they remain obsessed with its gains day and night. They traverse the oceans to reach far off countries for it, and as yet the thought of the realm of the Hereafter has not crossed their minds, nor do they give any thought to the Lord of Sovereignty. However, God-willing, when the days come for them to decide through mere reason that if God exists where is He and why His Being cannot be perceived like all other existing objects, there will be such a decisive moment that it will force them to either believe in the Word of the Subtle Being, or to discard even the hypothetical assertion that created things ought to have a Creator.

The second reason which deters the followers of mere reason from hastening to become atheists is the blessing of the revelation of God and the rays of the sun of the Divine Word, which have proclaimed the existence of God throughout the world, and the perpetual rain of which has established hundreds of thousands of God-fearing souls upon a firm belief in the existence of God and has made a profound impact on millions of hearts. Since the loud voices of these solid and timeless testimonies have permeated the hearing faculty of all human beings and those lovely voices have so penetrated every chord of their hearing that even if an ignorant and unlettered man—who does not even know the word ‘reason’ nor is aware of what ‘argument’ is—is questioned whether God exists or not, he would consider the questioner to be absolutely stupid. He would be found to have such a strong faith in the existence of God that if all of the followers of mere reason were placed on one side of a scale and he on the other, his certainty of faith would weigh much heavier. And the irony is that, unlike the rationalists and philosophers, he is not aware of any argument; indeed, he is absolutely unaware of what it is that is called ‘argument’, ‘proof ’, or ‘clinching of the argument’, or ‘deductive reasoning’.

In short, it is by virtue of these blessings that the Brahmu Samajists, despite adopting egregious errors, have so far managed to maintain some semblance of belief in the existence of God. The immense publicity of the existence of God has also restrained their thoughts from wandering aimlessly. In conclusion, although someone may not be grateful for divine revelation out of the depravity of their nature, the reality is that its powerful hand and mighty arm enable the vessel of certainty and truthfulness to sail; indeed, it is the very captain in the ocean of divine cognition. If the atheists have remained deprived of the effects of its blessing, it is not its fault. Rather, the atheists are themselves like a person who is inherently blind or deaf, or are like a limb that has become putrefied and leprous.

Here it should be borne in mind that those who believe in reason alone are as defective and deficient in action, faithfulness, and sincerity of conduct, as they are deficient in knowledge, enlightenment, and certainty. Their group has not produced any such exemplars from whom it can be proven that they are faithful and elect servants of God like millions of holy ones whose blessings were so manifested in the world that through the preaching, admonition, prayer, attention, and interacting fellowship of each one, hundreds of people became pure of conduct and men of God, and completely turned to their Lord so as to pay no attention to the world and its contents. They severed themselves altogether from the delights, comforts, joys, renown, pride, properties, and kingdoms of this world, and followed that path of righteousness whereby hundreds of them lost their lives, thousands of heads were cut off, and the earth was drenched with the blood of hundreds of thousands of holy ones. But, despite all of these calamities, they showed such fidelity that, like devoted lovers, they remained smiling while their feet were shackled, were joyful while suffering pain, and were grateful in the midst of misfortunes. They abandoned their homes out of the love for that very One [God], chose disgrace instead of honour, bore calamities instead of comfort, accepted poverty in place of wealth, and were content with indigence, isolation, and destitution over every kind of relationship, association, and kinship. They put seals [of testimony] on the existence of God by letting their blood be shed, having their heads severed, and sacrificing their lives. Through the blessing of truly following the Word of God, such special light was generated within them as has never been found in others. These people were not only found in the past; rather, this exalted group continues to appear among the followers of Islam and has repeatedly confuted and silenced its opponents by its enlightened existence. Thus, I have conclusively proven to the deniers that, just as the Holy Qur’an conveys one to the highest degree of perfection in the ranks of knowledge, in the same way, one also attains perfection in the ranks of conduct through it. The signs and light of being accepted by the One True God have always appeared—and continue to appear—in those who follow this Holy Word, but they never appear in the others.

In conclusion, this proof which one can observe with one’s own eyes, is sufficient for a seeker after truth; that is, those heavenly blessings and divine signs are found only in the perfect followers of the Holy Qur’an, and all other sects who renounce the True and Holy Revelation—whether Brahmus, Aryas, or Christians—are deprived and destitute of this light of truth. Hence, I myself take the responsibility for satisfying every denier, provided such a one—being ready to embrace Islam sincerely—takes the trouble of approaching me for seeking the truth with good intention, steadfastness, patience, and sincerity. If someone does not desist from denial even now, his denial would be clear proof that he has no desire to accept the truth because of his love for the world, and all of his disputation is by way of enmity and malice and not by way of seeking the truth.

Now, O Brahmu gentlemen! Just open your eyes and see that this investigation of mine has proven and fully disclosed that revelation is neither impossible nor non-existent; rather, it is a clearly proven verity which is necessary and essential according to reason, and its existence is verified by research; and I have fully demonstrated its existence. Therefore, O gentlemen, it is now incumbent upon you to read this Footnote and also Sub-Footnote Number One, Number Two, and Number Three with the utmost attention. Read them over and over again. Then, in conformity with the fear of God, renounce the dark thoughts of misguidance after finding the bright torch of the path. Let not such a facade of bigoted modesty find a place in your hearts, as to why you should undo that which you yourselves had previously done. Indeed, it is obligatory for everyone who regards himself as just to now demonstrate his justice, and everyone who regards himself a seeker after truth to now make no delay in accepting the truth.

Of course, it will be difficult for a proud man to accept a truth that goes against his boasting. But O ye who possess such a nature! You too should fear the Omnipotent God by whom you will ultimately be called to account. Bear well in mind that a person who does not renounce the path of falsehood even after finding the truth, remains adamant in his opposition, regards the holy personages of the pious Prophets of God to be soiled with the greed of the world by judging them through the standard of his nafs-e-ammarah [the self that incites to evil]—even though he himself is proven to be false, contemptible, and disgraceful in contrast to the Word of God—will find that his soul testifies to his misery and misfortune and constantly accuses him. Undoubtedly, he will reap the retribution for his dishonesty in the presence of God, because a person who stands in severe and scorching sunlight cannot enjoy the comfort of thick shade. Therefore, even though admonition is not an arrow that pierces the target as soon as it is released, but may

I ask, why should those, who claim to follow the path of reason, do something in which worldly disgrace is clearly visible and misfortune of the Hereafter also cannot be averted?

In particular, I have great hope that the sagely nature of some of the courageous and decent people of the Brahmu Samaj, who are learned and capable, will enable them to accept with sincerity of heart all of the verities which have been proven to be true in this Footnote. In fact, I hope that they are convinced and rightly guided even before they finish thoroughly reading this entire footnote, because, during a controversy, a wise and noble person does not deliberately drag himself to the point of ignominy after realizing that he is confuted. On the contrary, he accepts the truth gracefully before his indignity is exposed and thus becomes worthy of respect in the eyes of those who possess the truth.

However, someone whose nature is impudent and shameless gives no thought whatsoever to ignominy and humiliation, nor does he entertain any fear for his disrepute. As a matter of fact, the world abounds with such people who, being totally devoid of any sense of shame, continue to persist in holding fast to self-evident falsehood with the utmost audacity. However much effort you exert in persuading them, they do not refrain from their obstinacy nor do they renounce their crooked ways. Knowing that it is day, they persist in calling it night, and fear not the least that people would call them blind and sightless. These are the very people who, on account of their extreme prejudice and lack of knowledge and ability, lie like corpses, failing to make the slightest advance towards truth and refuse to follow the path of steadfastness and rectitude. Strange indeed are all of their mannerisms and crooked is all of their speech. These are the very people about whom I have been writing repeatedly that they should come to their senses and, while claiming to be wise, they should not make fools of themselves. Such a man is absolutely worthless and mean who blatantly slanders the pious and holy ones, but becomes dumb at the time of speaking a word of truth. Had these people failed to understand a matter that truly comprised a subtle point, I would have appreciated that it was not their fault, and that they could not comprehend it because it was a subtle matter. But look at their bigotry! They refuse to accept things which can be understood even by a man of meagre mental capacity.

Take, for example, the debate about revelation. Let any honest man consider whether there is any difficulty in understanding that God, who possesses all perfect attributes, cannot be mute. Rather, it is a crucial necessity that as He sees, hears, and knows, He should speak as well. Since He possesses the attribute of speech, the beneficence of that attribute must grace the deserving members of humankind, because no attribute of God is devoid of imparting its beneficence. He is the Source of beneficence by virtue of all of His attributes, not just some of His attributes; and He is the Mercy for man by virtue of all His attributes, not just some of His attributes.

·

10 of 10 left today