Footnote Number Eleven
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part IV, Part 7
Look at the entire enterprise of the world and you will realize that the utmost that intellect can do is to suggest some instrument to the human mind for performing a task. For instance, when reason thought of an instrument needed to cross the river, the idea of a boat came to mind; then a suitable material that does not sink into water, but floats on it, became available for building the boat. And thus the boat was built with this material. By the same measure, there are thousands of instruments that are required for running the affairs of the world. In all cases the function of the intellect is only to prove the need of an instrument and suggest the kind of instrument needed, but it cannot do the work of the required instrument.
Thus it should be understood that sane reason determines it as being plainly evident that to have unequivocal knowledge of the events of the Hereafter, the existence of the Creator of the worlds, His pleasure and displeasure, the quality and quantity of reward and punishment, and attaining definite information about the soul’s immortality and eternal existence, is such a fine and subtle matter that it cannot be truly and certainly known without a heavenly instrument. As reason has proven the need for thousands of instruments to properly manage worldly affairs, so has sane reason proven the need for a heavenly instrument to know the unseen world with certainty, so that the Omnipotent’s Being—whom hundreds of thousands of the wise have erred in recognizing—may be known with conviction and certainty; and the realm of reward and punishment may also be known with certainty so that a seeker after truth should advance beyond conjecture and, in this very world, see
God, the Exalted, the Maker, and also His perfect attributes, as well as the Hereafter, with the eye of certainty. And the instrument that leads to this highest stage of certainty is the Word of God, through which man comes to know with absolute certainty about the existence of God and His perfect attributes as well as the world of reward and punishment. By bestowing this stage of perfect cognizance upon hundreds of thousands of people, God Almighty has proven that this instrument for recognizing God does, in fact, exist in the world. Anyone who does not obtain light from this heavenly instrument is like a blind person who treads a path with ditches everywhere and huge pits all around, and he does not know where the path to safety is, nor does he know which side is safe for him. Nor is he aware of the consequence of taking a step. Neither can he himself see, nor does he hold on to a guide. He does not know where he will end up, nor has he any surety that he will achieve the objective for which he is going forth. Rather, his eyes are blind, and so is his heart.
Another doubt which assails the mind of the Pundit is that a revealed book cannot be the basis of anyone’s faith. Why can it not be the basis? In support of this argument, he writes:
Prior to accepting a revealed book, it is necessary that one
should have a firm belief in God; and every Prophet or Rishi upon whom the word of God descended had first believed in the Speaker of the word and then believed in the word itself, because it is necessary that before one believes in the word, he
should believe in the Speaker of the word. Thus, [he concludes that] it is evident that the Prophets did not believe in the existence of the One who sends down the word through the same word. Rather, before it was revealed, they already had that cer-
tainty of belief on the basis of the testimony of their own inner nature. It seems that the Pundit has employed every last bit of his intellect in offering the argument that the Word of God is not necessary. However, it will be evident to every wise person upon due reflection that this is a mere delusion that has arisen in the mind of the Pundit from his misunderstanding a truth, which is that he regards the following two matters as a combination of two contradictions—namely, that the word of God should be revealed to a person who is ignorant of the existence of God and of His attributes, and on the other hand, the All- Powerful God should Himself convey the information of His existence through His Holy Word. These two matters, in the view of the Pundit, are opposites of each other and cannot coexist. As a matter of fact, their being true at the same time, according to the wise, does not constitute a coexistence of opposites. Given that a man can inform another man of his existence through his word, why then should it be impossible for God Almighty to do the same? Does the Pundit believe that God does not have the power to inform of His existence through His perfect and powerful word that comprises divine manifestations? If the Pundit harbours the doubt that all Prophets who appeared undoubtedly believed in God before the divine word was revealed—and this proves that they attained this belief from their own nature and reason—it should be clear that this doubt arises merely from the lack of reflection, because it is absolutely impossible that such belief can be attained by either reason or nature alone. The Prophets were not born in isolation in a jungle to justify the conclusion that they had not heard the name of God before receiving revelation, even through the chain of verbal reports—the foundation of which had been laid down by divine revelation—and therefore, they believed in the existence of God only on the basis of their own nature and reason.
On the contrary, it stands clearly proven that the existence of God was well-publicized in the world through the divine word that was revealed in the beginning to Hadrat Adam [Adam]. Then, all of the Prophets who were raised from time to time for the reformation of the world after Hadrat Adam were made aware of the existence of God, prior to receiving revelation, by the same well-publicized verbal reports founded by the scripture of Hadrat Adam. It was the widely publicized verbal reports which the ready, worthy, and eager natures of the Prophets readily accepted; then, God elevated them to higher stages of certainty and cognizance through His special word, and thus He made up for the loss and defect which was inherent in merely following verbal reports.
I have already written that the existence of God Almighty has been continuously publicized by verbal reports, and the foundation of this chain of verbal reports is the revelation that was sent down by God Almighty in the beginning to Hadrat Adam, the father of mankind. Sufficient proof of this is that it is obvious that the Omnipotent God’s existence came to be known in the beginning through something which has the everlasting power to make it known even today. That everlasting power exists only in the word of God, because this power is present and witnessed in the word of God even now. It can give accurate and true knowledge of secret matters as it should, can disclose news of the past, and can also bestow veritable indications of the Maker’s Unseen Being. It can also bestow complete certainty about Him in its miraculous ways and can also give detailed knowledge of the realities and the circumstances of the Hereafter, as is being attested in the present age by the authentic experiences of recipients of revelation.
This essential quality is not present in intellect. Accordingly, it has been proven that if a newborn infant, being totally deprived of the knowledge of verbal reports, is left only to his intellectual abilities for the recognition of God, he remains completely unaware of the existence of God, His perfect attributes, and the world of reward and punishment. Hence, the ability to teach true cognizance [of God] is proven only in the word of God, and not in reason; therefore, every wise person will have to admit that the word of God is the basis of belief and faith and that by no means can the ideas of reason be their basis. Although rational capacity is inherent in human nature, this capacity is useless without the guidance of the divine word—as is the case with visual capacity, which is inherent in the eyes, but is meaningless without the sun. And just as the light of the sun proves its own existence as well as guides towards the existence of the sun, so does the Word of God prove itself to be from God by virtue of its intrinsic light, truthfulness, and matchlessness, and at the same time guides, certainly and conclusively, towards the existence of God Almighty.
Again, in the January 1883 issue of Dharam Jiwan, the Pundit has claimed that a wise man can write a book equalling the excellences of the Holy Qur’an or even better. Now, since the Pundit is himself a wise man, and indeed, claims to be a reformer and champion of his people, the onus of proof is on him that he should come forward to write such a book. As the Holy Qur’an, despite its perfect brevity, is comprehensive of all truths and subtleties, and as the Holy Qur’an, despite its adherence to truth, wisdom, and verities, is most eloquent and fluent, and as it is replete with prophecies of a high stature and matters of the unseen, and as the Holy Qur’an enlightens sincere seekers after truth with heavenly light, and grants them special blessings, which are not found in other faiths, by purifying their hearts through its holy effects—all of which I have proven with conclusive proofs in my book—the Pundit should come forward with another book possessing the same qualities and excellences.
Had you not spoken, nobody would have had any contention with you, But now that you have spoken, you must come forward with your proof.
Nevertheless, I would like to make it clear to the Pundit that it is absolutely impossible for any man to embellish his discourse with the above-mentioned qualities, as they are beyond human capabilities. As for the Word of God, however, it is not only permissible but also necessary that all of these qualities should be found in it, in their totality, because as God is Inimitable and Incomparable, likewise whatever proceeds from Him should be inimitable and incomparable, whose likeness man cannot have the ability to create. Hence, the claim that the