Reply to Doubts of Rashid Ahmad Gangohi

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part V, Part 5

body be elemental; in fact, a body that is not elemental is required, because the fruits etc. of Paradise are also not elemental, but rather, are a new creation, so the body will also be a new creation that will be different from the earlier body. It is, however, essential that the believers are given bodies after death. It is not only the phrase ‘of Paradise’ that points to this, but also the fact that on the night of the Mi‘raj, the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, did not merely see the souls of the Prophets; rather, he saw the bodies of all of them, and body of Hadrat ‘Isa was not of a different kind from them. (Author)

eating the fruits of Paradise’ [narrations] are such well-known ahadith that it is no secret to anyone. Almighty Allah says too:

Meaning: ‘Do not imagine, with regard to those who are slain in the cause of Allah the Almighty, that they are dead. Rather, they are living, they are provided with food from God Almighty.’

The same is proven by the earlier Scriptures. Thus, when the entrance of the souls of the pious and sinless into Paradise is proven—and it is obvious that Paradise is the place which will also have material delicacies of diverse types and fruits of many kinds, and entry into Paradise indeed means that one would partake of those delicacies—in such case the entry of only the soul into Paradise is meaningless and useless. Will it, after entering into Paradise, keep sitting destitute and not benefit from the bounties of Paradise?

Thus, the verse, shows clearly that a believer is bestowed a body after death.3 ٭For this

‘Isa [Jesus, the Messiah] was not raised to heaven with his elemental body, but he was bestowed a glorious body after death. Hence it is a pity—rather, a grievous pity—that Muslims of the Dark Ages who were born three centuries after [the Holy Prophet s (as)] do not uphold the belief of the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, regarding this issue—for all the Companions (ra) had come to consensus that all the Prophets of the past, which includes Hadrat ‘Isa, had died. Nor do they agree with the Jews on this issue because the Jews, by declaring ‘Isa to be accursed—God forbid—deny only his spiritual exaltation, which is essential for a believer, because the only consequence of being crucified is to be deprived of spiritual exaltation and to become accursed and reason, all Imams and Sufis are agreed that the believers who are pious and sinless are invested with a holy and glorious body upon death, through which they enjoy the bounties of Paradise. To reserve Paradise for martyrs alone is an injustice, indeed it is a heresy. Can a true believer utter such an impertinence as to say that the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, under whose grave Paradise lies, is still outside Paradise, but those who acquired faith and righteousness

nothing else. Nor do they agree with the Christians on this issue, because while the Christians do believe in ‘Isa’s physical ascension they do not believe, like they [Muslims] do, in ascension with the elemental body. Rather, they believe in the ascension of the glorious body which, in their view, was bestowed upon ‘Isa after his death. And we cannot deny that Hadrat ‘Isa (as) could have been granted a glorious body after death, which is not the earthly body, because it is granted to every believer after his death as is testified by the verse وَٱدۡخُلِي جَنَّتِي [enter My garden]. This has to be so because the soul on its own is not suited to enter Paradise. Thus, Hadrat ‘Isa (as) has no distinction in this regard. Where the Christians err, however, is in believing that the glorious body was bestowed upon ‘Isa after his death on the cross, because ‘Isa never died on the cross; otherwise, he would be considered to have lied in equating himself with the Prophet Yunus [Jonah], God forbid, and would also have come under the purview of the purport of la‘nat [curse]. An accursed person is he whose heart, like that of Satan, has become estranged from God and becomes God’s enemy and God becomes his enemy, and who, like Satan, is barred from the divine threshold and becomes rebellious of God. Can we attribute such a connotation to ‘Isa? Absolutely not! And can any Christian commit the affront that after his crucifixion ‘Isa became estranged from God and developed a bond with Satan? This is the meaning of la‘nat that has been put forward from time immemorial and is agreed upon by all peoples. Alas, the Christians have never reflected on this connotation, or else they would have discarded such a belief with utmost disgust. Moreover, it is evident from the events presented by the Gospels that after deliverance from the cross, only the earthly body of ‘Isa was witnessed. For instance, when the apostle Thomas doubted as to how ‘Isa could have been delivered from the cross, ‘Isa showed him his wounds to prove it, and Thomas put his finger in them. Could wounds have remained in the glorious body, too? Can we say that he was granted a glorious body and yet could not remove his wounds? The fact is that the body that was glorious was the one bestowed after his death in Kashmir. (Author)

through him and became martyrs are dwelling in Paradise due to their martyrdom and are eating the fruit of Paradise? The truth is that those who devoted their life to the cause of Almighty God have already become martyrs. So by this token, our Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is the foremost of martyrs. Inasmuch as this is established, we, too, say that the Messiah was raised to heaven with his body (but with a body that differs from his elemental body), and then he entered among Almighty God’s servants and entered Paradise.

From this perspective, the point of contention between our opponents and us turns out to be only in terminology. And when, with this perspective, bodily exaltation is proven, why then must Hadrat ‘Isa be considered to have risen to heaven with his earthly body while it contradicts the established divine practice with regard to all Prophets, of being bestowed glorious bodies? And if the contention is that he too was bestowed a glorious body—as was bestowed upon Hadrat Ibrahim (as), Hadrat Musa (as), Hadrat Yahya (as), and other Prophets—and with it he was raised to God Almighty, this is not something we ever deny. We agree to Hadrat Masih’s exaltation to heaven with such a body with all our heart and soul. [As is said:]

[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]

[We are content and happy.]

While the aforementioned verses are clear, explicit, and conclusive regarding the death of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, if the Holy Qur’an is perused carefully, we would find that there are many more verses which prove the death of Hadrat ‘Isa , may peace be upon him. Among them is the verse:

Meaning that: ‘Hadrat Muhammad, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is only a Messenger. And all Messengers have passed away before him. If then he dies or is slain, would you give up the religion of Islam?’

As I have just explained, it is not right that the word خَلَت [khalat], when applied to all other Prophets, means ‘to cause to die’, but when it comes to Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, it means that God Almighty raised him to heaven with his elemental body. Such claim is utterly baseless, and no evidence has been presented to support it.

In fact, everywhere in the Holy Qur’an that the word خَلَت [khalat] has been used, it has only been used to connote death. No one can produce a single example from the Holy Qur’an where this word has been used to mean that someone was raised to heaven with his elemental body. Moreover, as I have just explained, in these very verses Almighty God has Himself explained the word خَلَت [khalat] and has confined it only to death or murder. And this is the noble verse on whose authority the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, reached the ijma‘ [consensus] that all the Prophets and Messengers had died and none of them was going to return to this world. In fact the real purpose of this ijma‘ was to assert that it is not possible for anyone to return to this world. The objective of this ijma‘ was to dispel the notion that had developed in the mind of Hadrat ‘Umar, may Allah be pleased with him, that the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, would return to this world and cut off the noses and ears of the hypocrites. This being the context, it is obvious that had Islam admitted the possibility of any Prophet to return to this world, it would not have been possible to dispel the thought of Hadrat ‘Umar ra by reciting this verse, not to mention that it would entail a denigration of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. Indeed in such a case it would have been out of place for Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) to even recite this verse. In short, this verse is also one such wonderful verse that proclaims aloud the death of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him. فالحمد ہلل علـٰی ذالك۔ [God be praised for this].

Then there is another verse that proves the death of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him. Allah the Exalted says:

Meaning: ‘Isa, Masih [ Jesus the Messiah] is but a Messenger; all Messengers before him have died. And his mother was a pious woman, and both of them used to eat food when they were alive.

·

10 of 10 left today