Reply to Doubts of Rashid Ahmad Gangohi

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part V, Part 6

In this verse, Allah the Exalted refutes the divinity of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, and says that all Messengers before him have died. To think, despite this fact, that the Messiah is sitting alive in heaven, is a fallacy. How can this argument be used to prove his divinity when the argument itself is false, for the truth is that death did not spare anyone and they all died. The second argument for him being a human is that he had a mother of whom he was born, while God has no mother. The third argument for him being a human is that when he and his mother were alive they both used to eat food, whereas God is in no need of food. That is, food restores the body as it wastes away, while God is free from the attribute of wasting away. But the Messiah continued to consume food. Thus, if he is God, then does the body of God, too, continue to waste away? This refers to the fact that, according to physiological research, the human body is replaced completely in three years, as earlier cells are broken down and new cells develop as their replacement. But this imperfection is by no means to be found in God. This is the argument invoked by Almighty God to prove that Hadrat ‘Isa was a human being.

But alas for the people who, having raised Hadrat ‘Isa to heaven, believe that his body does not possess this trait that, like all human beings, the process of dissolution should continue in him, and believe that his body would have remained safe from annihilation even without obtaining the replacement for the dissolution through food. They wish to break thereby the argument given by God and the reasoning put forth in the above-mentioned verse. God, on the other hand, gives the argument to prove that Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, was human. Namely that, like other human beings, he too was dependent on food, without which his body could not have sustained itself, and that it required replacement for what was being consumed. The people who raise Hadrat ‘Isa to heaven with his elemental body, hold the belief that his body can continue to exist without food, and in this manner they present an argument for the divinity of ‘Isa in contradiction to Almighty Allah’s purport.

It is shameful that these people disrespect the argument that God has presented with the purpose of proving that Hadrat ‘Isa was human. While Almighty God refutes that the Messiah had the attribute on the basis of which he could be deified, these people assert that he does possess that attribute. This is disrespect of the consummate argument that God puts forth with regard to Hadrat ‘Isa being human. If it is true that Hadrat ‘Isa, despite possessing his elemental body, does not require food, and that his body is able to continue to exist on its own, like the person of God, then this would be an argument for his divinity, which that the Christians have put forth since ancient times. It is not enough to say, in response to this, that he used to eat food while he was on earth though he does not eat in Heaven, as the opponents can say that his eating while on earth was by his own volition and that he was not dependent on food as human being are, otherwise if he was dependent on food on earth he would also be dependent on it in heaven. I deplore these people who, time and again, while God cites the eating of food as evidence that Hadrat Masih was human, believe that though Hadrat Masih did eat food for thirty years while on earth, he is subsisting without food in heaven for 1,900 years.

Yet another argument for the death of Hadrat ‘Isa (as) is the following verse of the Holy Qur’an, where God says:

(Translation) ‘You [children of Adam] shall live out your lives in the earth, and shall die in the earth, and shall be raised from earth too.’ In the presence of such a clear statement, how is it possible that for about 2,000 years, or an even longer and undetermined period, Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, should stay in heaven—for this necessitates rejection of the Holy Qur’an.

Again, another argument for the death of Hadrat ‘Isa, is this verse of the Holy Qur’an:

(Translation) ‘Your abode shall be on earth, and until the day of your death, from within the earth shall you find things for your comfort.’ This verse has the same import as the previous one. How is it possible that Hadrat ‘Isa should live on earth—the abode for human beings—for just thirty-three years, and yet he should maintain his residence in

himself that bears testimony to his death. In answer to Almighty God’s question, ‘O ‘Isa , did you teach people to take you and your mother as gods?’, the reply Hadrat ‘Isa gives is recorded in the Holy Qur’an and that is the verse:

Meaning: ‘I was a witness over them only as long I was among them, but when You caused me to die, You were then the Guardian over them’ [Surah al-Ma’idah, 5:118]. In this verse Hadrat ‘Isa links the Christians remaining on the side of truth with his own lifetime. Hence, if Hadrat ‘Isa is still living, it follows necessarily that the Christians are still upon the truth. And this verse

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

also proves that Hadrat ‘Isa will not return to this world before the Day of Resurrection, otherwise it follows necessarily that—God forbid—he would lie in the presence of God that he had no knowledge of his people going astray. (Author)

heaven—which is not an abode for human beings—for 2,000 years or for an even longer, unknown period. This will lead to the impression that he is perhaps not a human being, particularly when there is no other human being who is his equal in displaying such superhuman qualities.

Then, another argument for the death of Hadrat ‘Isa is this verse of the Holy Qur’an:

(Translation) meaning: ‘Allah is the God who created you in a state of weakness, and after weakness gave you strength; then, after strength, gave you weakness and old age.’ Obviously, this verse applies to all human beings, to the extent that even the Prophets are included in it. Even our Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, who is the Chief of the Prophets, is not outside its scope. The signs of old age became manifest even in him, and some grey hair had appeared in his blessed beard and he felt the effects of the weakness related to the old age in his final years. But, according to our opponents, Hadrat ‘Isa is excluded from this, too. They say that this is one distinction of his which is extraordinary. Indeed, this is the argument for his divinity.

Thus, there are five arguments, and not just one, for the divinity of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, which—according to the contention of the Christians and the doctrine of my opponents from our own people [i.e. the Muslims]—exist today and which cannot be refuted without first falsifying that special attribute of his. It is believed that Hadrat ‘Isa holds the sole distinction of going to Heaven with his elemental body, something that no other human being shares with him; and possesses a second distinction, that he alone is acknowledged to have lived in Heaven for hundreds of years without food or water, which also no other human being shares with him; and hold a the third distinction, that he is the only one who is acknowledged to have stayed in Heaven free from old age and its accompanying debility for such a long period of time, which is also something no other human shares with him; and possesses a fourth distinction, that he is the only one acknowledged to descend from Heaven in the company of angels after a protracted period, and not a single human shares this quality with him either. Given this, one should ponder these four distinctions—which are assigned solely to his person, and he is considered to be unique and without any co-sharer in them—just how much of a trial this doctrine can prove to be for the masses.1 ٭ Moreover, consider how many rea-

and ignorantly assign a fifth distinction to Hadrat ‘Isa and it is that, out of all the Prophets, he is the only one who is free from the touch of Satan—to the exclusion of all other Prophets. A sixth distinction is that the Holy Spirit accompanied him at all times and the Holy Spirit did not accord such constant company to any other Prophet. But all these are their fallacies. Little do they realize that all Prophets are free from the touch of Satan. Moreover, when God, through the saying of His Messenger, speaks of Hadrat ‘Isa (as) and his mother being free from the touch of Satan, the wisdom in it is that the inauspicious Jews accused Hadrat Maryam Siddiqah [Mary the Truthful] of adultery and considered Hadrat ‘Isa to be an illegitimate child—God forbid—and God desired to exonerate them of these charges. Accordingly, He exonerated them in this way, that the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, said that both of them were free from the touch of Satan. In other words, fornication is a satanic act, and both Hadrat ‘Isa and Maryam are free from this satanic act. It does not, however, mean that only they are free from it, and other Prophets are afflicted. Likewise, the Jews believed that, being an unlawful child, Satan was the companion of Hadrat ‘Isa , and this was their belief on the basis of the Torah. And it was to refute them that Hadrat ‘Isa’s companionship of the Holy Spirit was mentioned. It is also not correct that Hadrat ‘Isa possesses the distinction that he was conceived through the influence of the Holy Spirit, because it has been established from the Holy Qur’an and the Torah that some people are born in the shadow of Satan and have satanic qualities, while some are born in the shadow of the Holy Spirit and have virtuous qualities. As for those who are unlawfully begotten, they are conceived in the maternal womb in the shadow of Satan. It was, therefore, essential to refute that Hadrat ‘Isa ’s birth was unlawful, and so the Gospel also speaks of the shadow of the Holy Spirit to make it known that he was not born in the shadow of Satan and that he was not unlawfully begotten. (Author)

sons it provides to those who deify Hadrat ‘Isa—reasons that stand as ‘proven’ by the admission of the Muslims themselves.

Had Almighty God had not refuted all these distinctions by declaring Hadrat ‘Isa to be dead, another way to refute them was that Almighty God should have provided some precedents that would show that certain other human beings also shared these extraordinary qualities with him, just as God had provided the precedent of Adam in being fatherless. But if God neither declared Hadrat ‘Isa to be dead nor refuted all these distinctions, then in this context God became, as it were, dumbfounded in the face of the Christians’ argument. And if you say that you also believe that Hadrat ‘Isa will return in the Latter Days and then die after a while, then Christians do not accept this assertion. They convict you by your own admissions. And they are not obligated to accept your unsubstantiated claim. For, if Hadrat ‘Isa were to remain alive till the Day of Judgment, and were to have all the features of godhood in him—such as raising the dead—then it is possible that he should remain immune to death. And this is, in fact, what the Christians believe—that Hadrat ‘Isa will not die after descending from Heaven; rather, in his capacity as ‘God’, he will reward and punish people. So in the scenario, where these four distinctions of Hadrat ‘Isa are proven according to your own admission, the Christians will get the better of you, because, according to them, these four distinctions are sufficient to make Hadrat ‘Isa God.

·

10 of 10 left today