Reply to Doubts of Rashid Ahmad Gangohi

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part V, Part 7

It is far from the wisdom of God Almighty that He should bestow these four distinctions on someone who is being deified by 400 million people. At the time of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, the Christians had presented just one feature as the distinction of Hadrat ‘Isa—that he was born without a father—and Allah the Exalted at once countered it and said, meaning: ‘The case of ‘Isa with Allah is like the case of Adam. God created him out of dust, then He said to him, ‘Be!,’ and he became alive and vibrant.’ This meant that being born without a father was not something peculiar to Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, as that would necessarily imply that he was God, for Adam has neither father nor mother.

Hence while divine honour demanded that Hadrat ‘Isa should not remain peculiar in the distinction of being fatherless so that it may not be claimed as evidence for his godhood, how then is it possible that God should have accepted four supernatural distinctions in Hadrat ‘Isa? Of course, if God has cited some precedents to refute these distinctions, then those precedents should be presented, otherwise it will have to be admitted that God could not answer the claim of the Christians, for these are indeed the distinctions that the Christians cite and declare these distinctions to be the proof of the godhead of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him. So, while God has not refuted these four distinctions by citing some precedents, as He did in the case of Adam’s birth, then it would have to be confessed that God has accepted the Christian claim. But if He has refuted it and has cited some precedent of these four distinctions, then present those verses from the Holy Qur’an.

Among the verses that categorically prove the death of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, is this verse of the Holy Qur’an:

Meaning: ‘Those who are worshipped in place of God cannot create anything; rather, they have themselves been created, and they are all dead, not living, and they know not when they will be raised.’ One ought to ponder carefully as to how vividly these verses demonstrate the death of Hadrat Masih and all other people whom the Christians,

Jews, and some Arab sects held as deities and worshipped. Keep in mind that this is the declaration of God, and God Almighty is above and free from saying things that are contrary to facts. So when He says in clear and explicit words that all human beings who are worshipped and taken as ‘God’ by different faiths are dead—and not one of them is alive—then what level of defiance, disobedience, and contradiction of the commandment of God is it to consider Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, to still be alive. Is Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, not among those who have been deified or those who are beseeched to help resolve difficulties? Indeed he is the foremost among those people, because the insistence and exaggeration with which 400 million people are striving claim divinity for Hadrat ‘Isa, is not to be found in any other faith.

All the verses that I have quoted here are sufficient to prove the death of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him. And the same is also substantiated when we look at the blessed ahadith of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him—the only difference being that, while God testifies to the death of Hadrat ‘Isa with His Word, the Holy Prophet, may peace be upon him, does so through his eyewitness testimony. Thus, God with His Word, and the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, with his action—i.e. by his eyewitness account—have put a seal on the fact that Hadrat ‘Isa has died. For the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, testifies by his eyewitness account that on the night of the Mi‘raj [Spiritual Ascension] he saw Hadrat ‘Isa in Heaven among the previous Prophets who had passed away from this world and had reached the next world. Not only that, but he saw the same kind of body for Hadrat ‘Isa as those for other Prophets, may peace be upon them. Moreover, I have already explained that it is an error to think that it is only the souls of the earlier Prophets, may peace be upon them, who have passed away from this world that are present in Heaven; rather, they have with them luminous and glorious bodies with which they were raised from this world after their death—and the verse 1

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

represents a clear statement with regard to it. This is because a body is required to enter Paradise, and the Holy Qur’an time and again says clearly that people who will enter Paradise shall have their bodies with them; no soul shall enter Paradise just by itself.

Thus, the verse 2

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

shows clearly that every righteous person who enters Paradise after death is necessarily granted a body after death. The second testimony to the bestowal of a body is the observation of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. For, on the night of the Mi’raj, he did not see merely the souls of the Prophets, but rather, he saw their bodies as well; and he did not see any novel body for Hadrat ‘Isa. He saw the same kind of body for Hadrat ‘Isa as he saw for other Prophets. Therefore, if one does not insist unfairly on following falsehood, it is very easy for him to understand that the body with which Hadrat ‘Isa was raised was not the physical one, but was the body that is bestowed upon every believer after death, because God Himself bars the physical body from going to Heaven, as He says:

Translation: Have We not created the earth in a manner whereby it is drawing people’s bodies, whether dead or alive, towards itself, and does not let any of them climb to Heaven?

On another occasion He says:

Meaning that: When the disbelievers asked the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, to climb to Heaven—in that he need show only the miracle of climbing to Heaven with his physical body—they were told:

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

. Meaning: Say to them, it is unworthy of my Lord to go against His word and promise, and He has already said that no earthly body will go to Heaven, as He said:

and and

This was mischief on the part of the disbelievers of Arabia, that they sought a miracle that was contrary to the divine promise and pledge, and they knew quite well that such a miracle would never be shown for it was against the aforesaid word of Almighty God. And it is not worthy of Almighty God to break His promise. And then Almighty God said, ‘Say to them that I am but a human being, and it is forbidden for a human being that his earthly body should go to Heaven.’ Pious people can of course go to Heaven, just in a different body, in the same way as the souls of all Prophets, Messengers, and believers

al-Mursalat, 77:26–27) [Publisher]

[Publisher]

go to Heaven after death, and it is specifically with regard to them that Allah the Almighty says:

Meaning that the gates of Heaven shall be opened for the believers. Take note that if there had been only souls, the pronoun لهم [lahum] would not have been used for them. This usage strongly supports that when a believer is raised after their death, it is along with a body, but the body is not an earthly one. Rather, the soul of the believer is granted a different body that is pure and glorious and is immune from the suffering and defects that form a necessary part of the physical body. In other words, it is neither dependent on earthly food nor is it in need of earthly water. All those who are granted a station close to Almighty God receive similar bodies. It is our belief that Hadrat ‘Isa received a similar body after his death and he was raised towards God with that body.

Some ignorant people present the following verses of the Holy Qur’an:

and

Then they raise the objection: ‘These verses of the Holy Qur’an clearly

Ma’idah, 5:118). [Publisher]

(Surah al-Ma’idah, 5:118). [Publisher]

specify that Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, will plead before God that people went astray after his death and not in his lifetime. Therefore, if this belief is correct, that Hadrat ‘Isa escaped the cross and went to Kashmir and lived there for 87 years, it would be incorrect to say that his people went astray after his death; and he should instead have said that people had gone astray after his journey to Kashmir, for his death occurred 87 years after incident of the cross.’

So, keep in mind that such a doubt is born only out of lack of reflection. Otherwise, the journey to Kashmir is not in contradiction with this statement, because the meaning of

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

is, ‘As long as I was among my people who had believed in me,’ and does not mean, ‘As long as I was in their land,’ for we do accept that Hadrat ‘Isa had migrated from the Levant to Kashmir, but we do not accept that the mother of Hadrat ‘Isa and his Disciples remained behind. Instead, it is evident from historical records, that the Disciples came and joined him, some accompanying Hadrat ‘Isa and some arriving later. For instance, Thomas went with Hadrat ‘Isa, while the other Disciples came afterwards. Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, chose just one person, Thomas, to accompany him, just as our Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, chose only Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) at the time of the migration to Madinah.

The Roman Empire had declared Hadrat ‘Isa to be a rebel, and even Pilate had been assassinated on the order of Caesar due to the same accusation, because he was a secret supporter of Hadrat ‘Isa and his wife was also the follower of Hadrat ‘Isa. Hence, it was necessary that Hadrat ‘Isa should depart the country secretly and not take a group with him. Therefore, he took only Thomas with him on this journey, just as our Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, took only Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) with him in his journey to Madinah. And just as the rest of the Companions of our Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, joined him in Madinah having taken different routes, so did the Disciples of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, join him through different routes at different times. And as long as Hadrat ‘Isa remained among them—in keeping with the purport of the verse 1

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

—they all remained firm on Tau hid [the Oneness of God]. Their progeny went astray after the death of Hadrat ‘Isa. It is not known in which generation they fell into this error. Historians maintain that the Christian faith was still on its original principles till its third century. In any case, it appears that all those people returned to their homeland after the death of Hadrat ‘Isa; perhaps because the Emperor of Rome became Christian, so it was no longer necessary for them to remain in exile.

·

10 of 10 left today