Footnote Number Eleven

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III, Part 2

When a person says by way of conjecture that such and such a thing ‘ought to be’ he means to say only that it has to exist so far as his reasoning is concerned, but he is unable to say whether or not it actually exists. This is why all those who have restricted themselves to the study of nature have never agreed upon a conclusion—neither do they now, nor will it be possible in the future. Granted, if it were written somewhere in the heavens in bold, bright letters, ‘I am God, the Matchless and Peerless, who has created these things, and shall reward the good and punish the evil for their deeds,’ the study of creation would then result in perfect certainty regarding God’s existence and His reward and punishment. It would not have been necessary, then, for God to provide any other means of arriving at perfect certainty. But this is not the case; no matter how deeply one may study the universe, one will not find such a writing, and will have to depend on one’s own speculation and nothing else.

This is the reason why all the sages agree that pondering over the heavens and the earth does not provide factual testimony regarding the existence of the Creator. All one obtains is speculative evidence to the effect that the there ought to be a creator; and even this evidence will only be valid in the eyes of those who believe that it is impossible for things to come into existence by themselves. It will not, however, stand in the eyes of an atheist who believes the universe to be eternal, and contends that if nothing can come into existence without a creator, then how can God come into existence without a creator; and if this is possible, why then should it not be assumed that all creation, which no one has witnessed being created, came into existence without a creator.

I would like to point out that the reason why an atheist is able to argue with a rationalist regarding the existence of the Eternal God is that the study of creation does not provide factual testimony of His existence; that is, it does not prove that the Creator actually exists, but only that He ought to exist. Thus, evidence regarding the existence of the Creator of the universe, based only on reason, becomes ambiguous in the eyes of an atheist. As such, I have already discussed this point to some extent in Footnote Number Four, where I have proven that reason can at best prove the need for something, not its existence; and that proving the necessity of a thing and to substantiate its very existence are two things altogether different.

Therefore, anyone whose understanding of God is limited to the study of creation alone is in no position to affirm that God actually exists. Rather, the reach of his knowledge extends only to the possibility that He ought to exist, and that, too, if the person is not inclined towards atheism. This is the reason why past philosophers who confined themselves merely to rational arguments fell into grave errors and created hundreds of controversies but passed away without resolving them. Their lives came to such a restless end that they, having harboured thousands of doubts and misgivings, died as atheists, naturalists and heretics, and the paper boat of philosophy was unable to carry them ashore. For, on the one hand, they were overwhelmed by the love of the world, and on the other, they did not possess any definite knowledge of the Hereafter. So they departed from this world in great anguish, having been deprived and far removed from true certainty.

They themselves admit that their knowledge of the Creator of the universe and of the Hereafter is not by way of certainty; rather, it is based on plausibility. That is, their ‘knowledge’ is like the knowledge of someone who, without any factual basis, conjectures that something should be like this, whereas he really does not know whether it is like this or not. Likewise, philosophers first presume that, under given circumstances, certain facts should exist, and then concoct those facts in their own imagination and jump to the conclusion that they do exist. This is like someone saying, for example, that Person X ought to visit him, and then arbitrarily concluding that Person X must surely be on his way. Then he imagines that Person X ought to come on horseback and proceeds to believe that he must indeed have come on horseback. Such have been the conjectures employed by these philosophers. Never did they have the good fortune of being certain that God truly exists. Their intellect, even when it moved in the right direction, could only arrive at the conclusion that the universe calls for a creator.

In fact, even with regard to this weak inference they always remained in uncertainty and doubt, like those devoid of faith, and they never walked the path of truth. Some of them do not believe that God is the Regulator of affairs and the Creator who creates as He wills. Others took primordial substance to be co-eternal with God. Some declared all souls to be eternal and virtually partners with Him—a doctrine advocated by the Aryah Samajists to this day. Others refused to accept the survival of the human soul [after death] or the next life of reward and punishment. Some regarded time to be the prime mover, like God.

Some denied God as being the Knower of everything down to the last particle. Others offered sacrifices to idols and prayed to artificial gods. In short, many of the great philosophers remained in denial of God’s existence and none managed to steer clear of these pitfalls.

Returning to the original subject, let me reiterate that the study of creation alone can never lead to perfect certainty, nor has it ever done so. Rather, what can be achieved, and perhaps was achieved by some, is only the belief that something ‘ought to be’. And this belief, too, is limited only to the existence of the Creator of the universe. The belief in His reward and punishment etc., does not amount to even that much. Having thus failed to obtain perfect certainty from the study of creation, we must choose one of two possibilities: either that God never intended to bestow perfect certainty at all, or that He must have provided some other means of arriving at it. The first proposition is, however, obviously false and no reasonable person doubts its falsity. The second, whereby we acknowledge that God must have provided some perfect means for the salvation of His creatures, is only possible if we believe the perfect means to be a revealed book that is matchless and incomparable in itself and explains every abstract law of nature. If the criteria for this perfect means is that it should be matchless and incomparable, and a bearer of unmistakable written testimony to its divine origin and its religious teachings, then all these qualities can be found only in a revealed book that is without any match. Nothing else can combine all of these qualities, because this merit can only be found in a revealed book, which through its discourse and its peerless nature, can lead to the stage of perfect certainty and perfect enlightenment.

It may be possible for an unfortunate atheist to assert that the heavens and the earth are eternal [precluding the need for the Creator]. But how can anyone who accepts a text to be beyond the power of man to create, have any option but to admit that God, who has revealed the text does indeed exist. And, in this case, the admission of God’s existence is not merely based on conjecture; rather, the Book itself provides testimony to the fact that God exists and to the truth of the Day of

Reckoning. Thus, the perfect certainty that a seeker after truth looks for in the earth and in the heavens—and does not find there—is achieved here [in the divinely revealed book]. Hence, to convince an atheist of the existence of God, the best remedy is provided by a matchless book and not the observation of the earth and the heavens.

It should be borne in mind that a person who relies exclusively on rational argumentation has a vein of atheism in him. The same vein becomes bloated and prominent in an atheist, while it remains hidden among the rest. This vein can be severed only by such a revealed book as is truly beyond the capacity of man to produce. For, as I have already mentioned above, people have always arrived at different conclusions from [the study of ] the heavens and the earth. Some have understood it in one way and others in another. Such difference, however, cannot arise with regard to a matchless book. No one, not even an atheist, can suggest that a matchless word has no speaker and has existed by itself since time immemorial, like the earth and the heavens [as he believes them to be eternal]. An atheist will debate about a matchless book only for as long as he denies its being matchless. As soon as he admits that, in fact, writing such a book is beyond human powers, a seed of belief in the existence of God will be planted in his heart. This is because, in this context, there is no room to imagine that the existence of the speaker is hypothetical and not real, since a word cannot exist on its own without a speaker.

Moreover, another excellence of the matchless Book is that it gives within it—in factual terms—whatever knowledge of the origin of the universe and the Hereafter is needed for the complete development of the self. This characteristic is absent in the heavens and the earth because, first of all, one cannot discover the secrets of religion at all from their study alone; and the little that may be discovered is quite dubious, and reminds us of the proverbial mother who alone could understand the sign language of her dumb child. All this goes to illustrate that the uniqueness of the Divine Word is essential not only for the comprehension of the system of the laws of nature, but also because without it, the very concept of salvation remains incomplete. For, if one does not have perfect certainty regarding God, the question of salvation does not even arise. Those who do not believe that the Word of God must be peerless, think ill of the All-Wise, [and imagine] out of sheer ignorance, that although He revealed His Books, they have served no purpose and that He did nothing to help mankind reach perfection in faith. Alas, they do not reflect that God’s laws of nature are so encompassing that He has granted uniqueness even to insects that seem to serve no grand purpose. So would not the wisdom of God be open to the criticism that He held back at the most important stage of His creation, putting the whole ark of mankind in danger of capsizing, and leading people to think that He had no interest whatsoever in granting salvation to anyone.

·

10 of 10 left today