Footnote Number Eleven
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III, Part 3
Considering that it is a great blasphemy to think about God in this way, the opposite, which befits God’s glory and conforms to man’s needs, must be accepted as true; namely, that in order to grant salvation and complete cognition to mankind, God must have revealed a book which, being peerless, would lead to perfect cognition—something that reason alone cannot do. So let it be known that this Book is the Noble Qur’an, which not only claims such absolute perfection, but also proves it to [one’s] satisfaction.
The Furqan [Holy Qur’an] is the sun of knowledge and faith,
So that it may save you from going astray and may lead you to certainty.
The Furqan is a strong rope of Allah,
So that it may pull you to the Lord of all the worlds.
Allah has made the Furqan shine like a bright day,
So that it may bestow upon you spiritual light.
The revelation of the Furqan brings the dead to life,
And imparts hundreds of secrets about ‘irfan [the world of cognition of God].
It opens such vistas of the realm of certain knowledge,
Which one cannot find in a hundred worlds.
In this context, the Brahmu Samajists have taken great pains to contrive a few objections to justify their refusal to accept the Divine Book, and to somehow prove that the structure of religion has been left incomplete and imperfect. They do not wish to admit that the Merciful and Benevolent God, who created the sun, the moon, and much more, in order to provide food for the physical development of mankind, also took care of their spiritual development by revealing His Books in order to arrange for their guidance. Since these people accuse the Benevolent and Merciful God of miserliness, unkindness, and mismanagement, and their misguided doctrines contain much that is blasphemous, derogatory, and insulting to Him, I deem it appropriate to address their objections that relate to the subject at hand. Therefore, they are presented, along with their answers, as follows:
First Objection: The question of whether a revealed book is beyond human power [to produce] is only part of the basic question of revelation. It is proven that according to reason there is no need for revelation; and since there is no need for revelation, it is meaningless to discuss whether or not human faculties can produce the like of a [revealed] book.
Answer: I have already dealt with this objection by stating that any thought and reflection about God and the Hereafter, based [only] on rational hypotheses, can never lead to perfect certainty and enlightenment. The kinds of doubts that rattle the minds of those who are in thrall to rational arguments cannot be removed except through revelation. For, even if nature leads us to conclude that the universe must have a creator, who can say that the Creator actually exists. It is true that when we see a building we are convinced of the existence of a builder, but this is only because of our common experience whereby we see both the building and the builder. But who can show us the Creator of the universe. In this situation we can be certain of His existence only if we have sure knowledge about Him, as we do about builders. Even if reason were to testify that there should be a creator of this universe, the same reason would be confounded that if its assumption is indeed valid, why has this Creator not been found so far.
Thus, if reason guides us to some extent to the existence of the Creator, it also waylays and misleads us. It has turned some into atheists and others into naturalists; some inclined to one view and some to another. How indeed can certainty come from mere intellectual inferences that have never been confirmed nor ever will be. If reason reaches as far as proposing that there must be a Creator, who can fully satisfy us that this conjecture is not a delusion and that we cannot explore this matter further. If reason were able to guide us fully, why would it leave us stranded halfway and refuse to lead us further. Is it the upper limit of our enlightenment and cognition of God to be content with the belief that there ought to be a Creator. Can such a conjecture help us attain the eternal bliss that has been prepared for those who have perfect certainty and perfect understanding and for which our souls cry out.
If reason were able to grant us such certainty, we would be justified in saying that there is no need for revelation, as we would have already achieved our goal; but it would be a mark of our misfortune if, despite being ill, we do not seek treatment nor try to find the means for attaining perfect health.
So, my brothers of the Brahmu Samaj!! When God has blessed you with eyes to observe and behold, use them to see whether there is any need for revelation or not. You can read more about this at its appropriate place where a further elaboration is given upon this subject in the context of rational arguments in support of the Holy Qur’an. If then you fear God, opt for the right path, and let the station of guidance be the prerogative of God alone, this will be a sign of your great fortune. Otherwise, if at all you can, do try to counter these arguments logically, but do not act like madmen who merely keep babbling and do not listen.
I wonder about the countless veils that cover your hearts, which refuse to be lifted even though you are being continuously cut down in all your arguments and at every step you are stopped in your tracks. What sort of hearts are these that do not understand. In what niche have you placed the yardstick of reason, and then forgotten about it, so that you regard right to be wrong and wrong to be right. Anyone can indulge in conjectures; why pride yourself in this ‘gift’. I am at a loss to understand why the doors of your hearts refuse to open, and your eyes are unable to see. Look at how reason has betrayed you, its worshippers, and fled away from you.
Gentlemen!! Think hard and you will realize that to arrive at complete certainty without revelation is not possible. Nor is it possible to escape error, or to base oneself truly on Tauhid, or to overcome one’s passions. It is revelation through which we are able to affirm that God ‘is’, and the whole world is proclaiming that ‘He is, He is’. It is revelation which, from the very beginning, has inspired the hearts with the assurance that God ‘is’. It is through revelation that worshippers find delight in worship and the faithful are satisfied with regard to the existence of God and life after death. It is revelation which enabled millions of righteous people to leave this transient world with great steadfastness and with the passionate love of Allah. It is indeed revelation whose truth has been attested to by the seal of the blood of thousands of martyrs. Indeed, it was the magnetic pull of revelation that led kings to wear the garb of beggars and motivated many a wealthy person to adopt the life of a hermit. Through its blessings, countless unlettered, illiterate and old women left this world with the intense zeal of faith. This is the sole ark that carried many over the troubled waters of creature-worship and scepticism, and landed them upon the safe shores of Tauhid and perfect certainty. It alone is the friend of one’s last moments, and is the helper in times of crises. However, the harm done to the world by the veil of reason alone is not hidden from anyone. Tell me what was it that made Plato and his followers deny that God is the Creator? What made Galen doubt the survival of souls after death, and reward and punishment in the Hereafter? What made philosophers deny that God has knowledge of everything down to the last detail? What made great philosophers worship idols? What led to the sacrifice of roosters and other animals before idols? Was this not due to reason unaccompanied by revelation.
It is incorrect to state that there were many people who followed revelation and yet they became pagans and fashioned new gods for themselves. This was not the fault of true revelation. Rather, it was the fault of those who mixed falsehood with truth and preferred the worship of their own evil desires to the worship of God. Yet, divine revelation has not remained indifferent to redressing their errors and has not ignored them. In fact, it was fresh revelation that reformed the matters which had led them astray.