Footnote Number Eleven
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III, Part 4
It is equally wrong to suggest that erroneous reasoning is the fault of those of lesser understanding and is not the fault of perfect reason itself. It is obvious that reason cannot function in its absolute totality; for, it is a ‘universal’ and can only be instantiated through particular individuals. Indeed, the nature of ‘universals’ can be known only through their ‘particulars’. Can anyone show us a perfect individual who, by following reason alone, has never erred in his self-conceived beliefs or has not stumbled in his views about theological truths? Where is the protagonist of reason whose belief in the Creator of the universe and in matters pertaining to the Hereafter has reached the level of ‘is’, whose belief in
God’s Oneness admits to no form of idolatry, and who has turned to God so completely as to overcome the cravings of the flesh. As I have already said, the philosophers themselves admit that man cannot attain perfect certainty about theological matters through unaided reason; all he can do is draw hypothetical and doubtful conclusions. It is obvious that as long as man’s knowledge remains in the realm of doubt and conjecture, and thus below the level of certainty, he will be as prone to err as a blind man is to lose his way.
To think that unaided reason may lead to error, but the error is always set right upon further reflection, is another one of the mistakes caused by the strange reasoning of the Brahmu Samaj, which they have not been able to dispel. As I have already pointed out, human reason, on account of its deficient insight, is bound to make some errors regarding supersensible phenomena sooner or later. No reasonable person will deny this. However (think carefully for yourself ), it is not necessary that every error will be realized and corrected. It is thus easily understood that what is bound to happen cannot possibly be prevented, at all times and under all circumstances, by that which is unreliable and uncertain. Rather, the only thing that can rectify such an inevitable error is that which, in comparison, possesses greater accuracy and certainty, and possesses the quality described in:
The reason why Tauhid cannot be understood in its pure form without divine revelation, and why one who denies revelation cannot cleanse oneself of the filth of paganism, becomes apparent when one reflects upon the reality of Tauhid itself. For, Tauhid means that we should believe that God’s being and His attributes are free of any association, and that those tasks which can be accomplished by God’s power and might cannot be accomplished by the power of anyone else. Fireworshippers, sun-worshippers, idol-worshippers, and so on, are called polytheists only because they reject this Tauhid and because they ask their idols and deities for such favours as can be bestowed only by God.
Obviously, those who deny revelation believe, like idol-worshippers, that creatures of God are invested with the attributes of God and that the powers of the Omnipotent God are possessed by human beings. For, they imagine that they have discovered God through their reason and also claim that it was human beings who first thought that a god should be appointed; it was by their efforts alone that God emerged from the state of obscurity, was recognized, and accepted as God of the people and worthy of worship; prior to this, He was unknown and no one was aware of His existence and it was through their wisdom that He came to be honoured. Are these beliefs different from those of idol-worshippers? Indeed not. The only difference is that idol-worshippers take other things to be their bestowers and benefactors and these people forsake God and consider their own clouded reason to be their guide and benefactor.
Now reflect further and you will realize that their case seems to be even worse than that of idol-worshippers. The idol-worshippers do believe that God has bestowed great powers on their deities who, by accepting a variety of offerings, bestow upon their worshippers that which they ask for. But idol-worshippers have never alleged that God was discovered by these deities, and the great blessing of recognizing the existence of God was attained through them alone. It was left to those gentlemen alone (who deny revelation) to go as far as including God in their list of discoveries, and to announce with great stupidity that the voice أنا الموجود [‘I am present’] has never been heard from God; and that it was their great achievement that, without being told or informed, they found Him on their own. He was absolutely silent like one asleep or dead and they discovered His track by the exercise of their own reflection and investigation. Thus, in effect, they repudiate any favour from God.
In a way, it is as if they grant a favour to God, in that, without having been informed that God exists and without complete certainty that disobedience to Him would subject them to such and such torment, and obedience to Him would attract such and such bounty, they have submitted to this fictitious god. That is to say, their entire discovery was what they had themselves concocted; but, God was so weak and infirm that He could not announce His own existence and could not provide any reassurance concerning His promises. He was hidden and these people disclosed Him; He was unknown, and they made Him known; He was silent, and they performed His work. That is to say, His Godhead has become known only recently, and that too, through their efforts.
Every wise person would appreciate that such a statement goes beyond even that which idol-worshippers allege. For, idol-worshippers believe their deities only to be their bestowers and benefactors, but those who deny revelation have crossed all limits by alleging that their deity (which is reason) is the benefactor not only of people but also of God, inasmuch as God became known (according to them) through the exercise of reason alone. Hence, it is patently obvious that by denying revelation they have erred, not only because their belief in the existence of God is based on doubtful conjectures and they are entangled in diverse errors, but also because they are deprived of belief in the absolute Oneness of God and are tainted with polytheism. After all, what is polytheism. It is nothing but attributing to others the favours and bounties that have been bestowed by God.
At this point the Brahmu Samajists may counter that they do consider reason to be a gift of God and they do acknowledge His grace and munificence. This, however, is a grave error on their part. It is the nature of man that he attributes to himself all that is under his control and power, or whatever he achieves through his labour. Whatever rights of man are established in the world, their genesis is the thought that everyone who achieves something by his labour, he or she regards it his or her property and wealth. If a person were to genuinely feel that whatever he possesses does not belong to him but to God, and that he has no right over it, why then would he run after a thief, or why would he demand that his debtors return his money. Without doubt, man claims possession of that which he achieves through his efforts. This is the law God has ordained for the functioning of the world and this is how everyone’s nature is inclined. A labourer expects dues for his labour; a servant has the right to demand wages for his services. An unlawful interference in others’ rights makes one a criminal.
In short, it is next to impossible that, say, a person who keeps awake all night without a wink of sleep to irrigate his land in a deserted place, enduring hunger and thirst in extremely cold weather, should be as grateful to God as he would be when, after a deep and comfortable sleep all night at home, he goes out early in the morning to his lands and finds that the clouds formed at night, it rained heavily, and filled his fields with just the required amount of water.
Thus, it is obvious that anyone who does not believe that God—finding man weak, powerless, imperfect, ignorant, overwhelmed by his evil self and prone to forgetfulness and error—mercifully showed him the right way through His revelation, and instead believes that he has come to recognize and find God solely through his own work and effort, cannot feel the same sense of indebtedness towards God as one who believes from the depths of his heart that God showed him the right way by His sheer grace without any labour and effort on his part. He was asleep, God awoke him; he was [spiritually] dead, God quickened him; he was undeserving, God Himself came to his assistance. It is clear from this discussion that the deniers of divine revelation are bereft of the true concept of Tauhid and it is not at all possible for their souls to cry out like true believers and say:
All praise belongs to Allah who guided us towards paradise and showed us the way. We could not have achieved our desired objective by ourselves had He not guided us.
Just look at how these people have ‘revered’ God Almighty: they ascribed to their own reason the very attributes that belong to God; they feigned to possess the glory that should have been proclaimed for Him; and claimed for themselves the powers that are exclusive to Him. Truly does the Gracious God say of them: