Cover Page

Christianity - A Journey from Facts to Fiction, Part 10

which is very difficult to believe and conceive for human beings, many of whom have lived long with Christian dogma without questioning it, and have somehow shut their eyes to such glaring violations against the human intellect, which was supposedly created by God himself.

The Holy Ghost and Creation We do not observe any role played by the Holy Ghost or Jesus as Christ in the divine plan of creation: In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth (Genesis 1:1). Obviously it is ‘God the Father’ who is referred to in the Old Testament without as any hint of a reference to Christ or the Holy Ghost In the entire pre-Christian era, among all the Jews who believed in the Old Testament and must have heard this verse hundreds of thousands as of times, there was not one who could read the name of Christ or that of the Holy Ghost in the story of the creation of the Universe. In his Gospel, St John suggests ‘Word’ to stand for as * Jesus (John 1:1) . It is strange that such an important subject has been taken up by the author of only one Gospel; by someone as who was not even a disciple of Jesus . Even if one accepts his word to be the word of God, still it can only be understood to mean the Will of God; this is a concept that is common to many religions with reference to Creation.

* In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. (John 1:1) === PDF-Seite 90 === 62 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

as Surprisingly, the secret of Christ’s and the Holy Ghost’s par- as ticipation in the Creation remained a secret to Jesus himself. We as read not a single statement of Jesus Christ in which he claims to as be the ‘Word’. Therefore, neither Jesus nor the Holy Ghost had any part to play in the shaping and making of Creation. Again it was God the Father alone, we are told, who fashioned man from dust with His own hands. I have never read anywhere in any as Christian writings that the two hands belonged to Jesus and the Holy Ghost Hence God created everything without the slightest as help from, or participation of, Jesus or the Holy Ghost Were they passive observers generally in agreement with what God was doing or did they actually participate? If the latter is more accept- able to Christian theologians then immediately the question arises whether each of them was individually capable of creating, without the help of the others, or were they only capable in their totality? And again, if all three were essentially needed to pool their functions together to create, then was their share equal, or did one have a larger share of the labour put into the process of creation? Were they three persons with different powers both in intensity and kind, or did they share their powers equally? One has to admit that whichever of the two options is taken, each of the components of Trinity becomes incompetent to create any- thing by itself. If the same argument is extended to other Divine functions, the same question will continue to plague the Christian theologians. At the end of the day Christians will have to admit that they do not believe in one simple entity of God, with three aspects and expressions of one single central power and majesty. But rather === PDF-Seite 91 === The Role of the Holy Ghost 63

that they believe in three complementary components of God- head that are three segments of the body of God. The question of being equal or unequal would then be assigned a relatively minor status. Take, for instance, the attribute of Justice and Forgiveness. The ‘Son’ appears to be more compassionate whereas God the Father appears to be less just than the Holy Ghost, who took no part in the injustice on the part of God the Father. as The second possibility we mentioned was that Jesus and the Holy Ghost played an inert role in the processes of creation and the government of the laws of nature. That being so, it raises many more questions. First of all, what is the assigned role of the two partners of God in the discharging of their Divine functions? If they are passive, silent observers, like sleeping partners, then they are automatically relegated to a secondary, inferior position where they coexist with God but without, in practicality, sharing His Powers. This concept of God having two non-functional appendices is very bizarre, to say the least I wonder whose con- science it can satisfy. Rationally it is, of course, unacceptable and does not harmonize with the Christian concept of ‘Three in One’ and ‘One in Three’. The oneness in three cannot be reached, or even remotely conceived of, without there being a total merger of will, of powers and of whatever experience of life that can be attributed to a single living entity. In the case of Holy Ghost, being a separate person, unless that person merges completely and irrevocably, losing all its identity in the other two, there remains no future hope of the emergence of === PDF-Seite 92 === 64 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

a hydra-headed god with single thoughts, a single will and a single body.

Mystery or Paradox It is acceptable for a person to believe in something not fully understandable to him because of some irrefutable evidence in its favour. For example, many people do not understand the phe- nomena which collectively make it possible to create radio transmission and receptor sets, and also the transmission of electri- cal audio-video pulses that are converted into televised pictures and sound. Yet even the most unlettered person would have to believe in the reality of radio and television. Similarly, most of us do not understand how computers work, yet very few in this contemporary age would dare to deny the existence of computers simply for this reason. Such cases may be classified as mysteries, but there is no question of denying their existence or deriding those who believe in them, provided of course, that they are fully backed up and supported by irrefutable evidence. We also accept that a much more lenient attitude can be, and is exercised, regarding many mysteries which exist in the form of religious dogmas. A very large number of human beings believe in such dogmas without being able to understand or to explain them. They seem to inherit such doctrines through generations and acquire a taken-for-granted attitude towards them. But when the elements of contradiction and paradox find their way into religious dogmas, no excuse in their favour can be accepted on the plea that belief in perplexing mysteries also provides justifica- === PDF-Seite 93 === The Role of the Holy Ghost 65

tion for believing in paradoxes. It is here that the problem be- comes complicated. I can believe in something that I do not understand, but I cannot believe in something that is contradic- tory in itself, nor I hope, can any other person in his senses. For instance, I cannot understand how a watch is made; that is alright, but I have no right to believe that a watch is simultaneously a live barking and kicking dog. This is not a mysterious dogma, but simply a glaring contradiction. When there is any contradiction between two or more attrib- utes of God, or when there are inconsistencies between the word of God and the act of God, then the limits of mystery are trans- gressed by a large margin and one finds oneself drifting out of the sphere of mystery and into a world of fantasy. When so proved, it is but natural to expect that the believers in contradictions should make amends in their beliefs and accordingly effect a reform in their faith. Unfortunately, however, in our dialogues with some Christian ministers we find them tenaciously holding the view as that belief in Jesus as a god and simultaneously as a man is not contradictory. Nor does it appear contradictory to them that one person can be three persons simultaneously without there being the slightest difference in their character. They insist that to believe in one God and also to believe in a three pronged god- head, composed of God, the Holy Ghost and the Son, is not a paradox but simply a mystery. They shut their eyes to the contradictions in their claim that God remains a single entity despite the fact that the person of as God, ‘The Father,’ is distinctly different from the person of Jesus , the ‘Son’, and the ‘Holy Ghost’. When we point out to them, in === PDF-Seite 94 === 66 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

amazement, that we are talking of three persons, and not about the different aspects, moods and attributes of a single person, and that God being ‘One in Three’ and ‘Three in One’ is certainly not a mystery but a glaring contradiction, they nod their heads in sympathy with us and politely ask us to step into contradictions operating in another area of discussion. They require us to first believe in the unbelievable and then to progress from there, to develop a faith in contradictions, or mysteries as they would much rather call them. A non-Christian therefore cannot understand the contradictions of Christian dogmas and to understand what he cannot believe in, he must believe without understanding. This is the world of Christian fantasy into which we, non-Christians, are advised to enter. But this magic flying carpet of fantasy refuses to take flight if a non-believer steps onto it. === PDF-Seite 95 === chapter four

crucifixion

Before turning to the biblical description of events relating to as Christ and his crucifixion, perhaps it would not be out of place to mention here, in brief, the Ahmadiyya Muslim understanding as of what happened during and after the crucifixion of Jesus Christ . This issue will be briefly touched upon here and a detailed discus- sion will follow later. as We believe that the crucifixion of Jesus was an attempt made on his life, like any attempted murder. Crucifixion was only the weapon used in that murderous attempt. However, the attempt to crucify him failed in inflicting death. This is tantamount to saying that they failed to crucify him. When we say this, we express ourselves exactly as we would in any other case of attempted murder. If an attempt is made on someone’s life and the attempt fails, it cannot be said that the intended victim was murdered. For instance, if such an attempt is made with a sword, and the attempt fails, no one can say that the intended victim was put to the sword. So we believe, as Muslims, that only an attempt to murder as Jesus was made: crucifixion being the instrument of the at- tempted murder. After a few hours of intense suffering upon the cross, before death could overtake him, he was taken down from === PDF-Seite 96 === 68 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

the cross in a state of deep coma from which he was revived later on. As no state can permit a person who is condemned to death legal cover and protection if he somehow escapes execution, so also under the Roman law, no immunity could be extended to as as Jesus beyond the point of his crucifixion. That provided Jesus with enough cause to escape from the Roman territory to a land of freedom. But he also had to perform a commission and had a prophecy to fulfil. There were those lost sheep of Israel, who after their exodus under the Babylonian and Roman invasion, scattered in many eastern lands and were awaiting his ministry. This was as the other very strong reason for Jesus to have immigrated from the land of Judea to those foreign lands where the Jews had settled over a period of many centuries. This much should suffice for the time being. I want to make one thing clear to those who demand from us a as proof of the natural death of Jesus Christ after he was saved from the cross. They are shifting the burden of proof on us without justification. There are natural phenomena known to man which are universally understood. We know that the life span of man on earth does not extend beyond a hundred and fifty years or so; certainly it is not a thousand years or more. This is a common experience relating to the span of human life on earth. If someone thinks that something contradictory to this rule has happened, then the burden of proof falls on his shoulders, not on someone who believes in the rule rather than the exception. This should be applied to the situation enveloping the life and death of Jesus as Christ . Those who believe that he did not die must provide the proof. But those who claim that he must have died, only follow === PDF-Seite 97 === Crucifixion 69

the laws of nature and should not be required to prove it beyond that. Otherwise, anyone could say that his great great great... grandfather has not died. If such a claimant goes around challeng- ing everyone to prove otherwise, what would be their reaction? How can a poor listener meet such a challenge? He can only point out that the laws of nature operate on every human being and spare no one. So if someone is making claims against the laws of nature, the onus of proof is on him. This is the first answer. But I will now make another humble attempt to try to make things clearer from a different viewpoint. Whatever his relation- as ship with God, was it beyond Jesus Christ to die? The Christians them-selves believe that he died. If it was against his nature to die, this could not have happened in the first place. Yet we all agree that he died at least once. The remaining part of the enquiry would be as to when he died. Was it on the cross or was it afterwards.

The Sign of Jonah We can prove from the Bible that God did not abandon him and saved him from the ignoble death upon the cross. This can be studied in the light of the facts relating to the period before the Crucifixion, as well as the facts of the Crucifixion itself and after it, as related by the New Testament. as Long before the Crucifixion, Jesus promised that no sign as would be shown to the people other than the sign of Jonah . === PDF-Seite 98 === 70 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

Then some of the scribes and Pharisees said to him, "Teacher, we wish to see a sign from you." But he answered them, "An evil and adulterous generation seeks for a sign; but no sign shall be given to it except the sign of the prophet Jonah. For as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of the whale, so will the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth. The men of Nin´eveh will arise at the judgment with this generation and condemn it; for they repented at the preaching of Jonah, and behold, something greater than Jonah is here." (Matt 12:38–41) as So before we determine what happened to Jesus , we must as as understand what happened to Jonah , because Jesus claimed that the same miracle would be repeated. What was the Sign of as Jonah ? Did he die in the belly of the fish, and was he later on revived from death? There is unanimity among all Christian, as Jewish and Muslim scholars that Jonah did not die in the belly of the fish. He precariously hung between life and death and was miraculously saved from that situation, while any other person in his place would have died. Yet some subtle laws of nature, under the Divine command, must have conspired together to save him from death. Remember, we are not debating the issue of that as being possible or not. We are only pointing out that Jesus , when as he said that the like of what happened to Jonah would also happen to him, could only have meant that what everyone as understood to have occurred in the case of Jonah would occur in his own case. No one in the entire world of Judaism, whether in the land of Judea or anywhere else the Jews had dispersed and settled, would have received a different message from this claim of === PDF-Seite 99 === Crucifixion 71

·

10 of 10 left today