Cover Page
Christianity - A Journey from Facts to Fiction, Part 9
"The Son of man will send his angels, and they will gather out of his kingdom all causes of sin and all evildoers, and throw them into the furnace of fire; there men will weep and gnash their teeth." (Matt 13:41–42)
Before we proceed further, it has to be very clearly understood what the New Testament means by the punishment of fire or the punishment of hell. Is it a fire which burns the soul, or is it a carnal fire which consumes the body and thereby tortures the soul? Do the Christians believe that after death we will return to the same body which the soul left behind to disintegrate to earth and ashes, or will there be a new body created for each soul and will the resurrected person experience a sort of reincarnation? === PDF-Seite 79 === Sin and Atonement 51
If it is carnal fire and a corporeal punishment, then one has to extend one’s imagination to the limit of its tethers to imagine as what may have happened in the case of Jesus Christ . Before being subjected to the Fire, was his soul re-imprisoned in the body of the man he had been haunting all his life on earth, or was he somehow relegated to an astral body? If the latter is the case then that astral body would have been beyond the reach of the carnal fire of hell to scorch, punish or destroy. On the other hand if we accept the scenario that the body of the man he had occu- as pied would be reconstructed for Jesus as a sort of medium through which he could suffer hell, then one cannot fail to notice another blow done to the principle of divine justice. Poor man, first of all he was practically hijacked for all his life by an alien soul, but then as a reward for the hospitality forced upon him he would burn in hell for no crime of his own. The credit of his sacrifice being totally monopolised by the alien occupant within him. Again, what about the soul of that man? Perhaps he did not as have a soul of his own. If he did not, then the man in Jesus and as the God in Jesus had to be one and the same person and the plea as that Jesus acted sometimes by his human impulses and sometimes by Divine Will is reduced to sheer hocus-pocus. The only for- mula acceptable to any intellect is that one soul and one body equals one person. Two souls and one body is a bizarre idea which can only be entertained by those who believe in people being haunted by ghosts or similar things. === PDF-Seite 80 === 52 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
Sacrifice and Spiritual Bliss If the second option is more acceptable to the Christian Theolo- as gians in that it assumes only the soul of Jesus to have entered hell and that hell to be a spiritual hell, then there seems to be no reason why we should reject this suggestion as nonsensical. However, spiritual hell is only created by pangs of conscience or a as sense of guilt. In the case of Jesus Christ neither was applicable. When you accept the penalty of another’s crime, being innocent yourself, it is not pangs of conscience which are generated but quite the opposite. The soul of such a person should vibrate with a sense of nobility and self-sacrifice, which would be tantamount to spiritual heaven rather than hell. Now we turn to the question of the body that was occupied by as Jesus , and the meaning of death in relation to that body and also to the meaning of revival in the same context. To the best of our as knowledge the body of Jesus Christ had to be an integral part of as the ‘Sonship’ of Jesus . Otherwise, he would have no common meeting ground left to him for his divinity and humanity to merge upon and play distinctly different roles under certain conditions. At times we should see the man taking charge of affairs, provided he had a separate soul himself, and at times we should observe the Divine asserting Himself and controlling the man’s faculties of head and heart. Again we emphasise that this can happen only if there are two distinct personalities locked up in a single being. === PDF-Seite 81 === Sin and Atonement 53
Meaning of Death in Relation to Christ Having clearly understood the different options regarding the as relative roles that the Divine and the Man in Jesus could have played, we try to comprehend the application of the word ‘death’ and its full meaning in relation to him. If he died for three days and nights, then death has to be under- stood in terms of the soul having been severed from the body, and the soul departing. This means that the soul must depart the body and break off its relationship so completely that only a very dead as corpse is left behind. So far so good. Jesus was at last relieved of his imprisonment in the carnal body of a man. However, libera- tion from this imprisonment should not be considered a punish- ment at all. The return of the divine soul of the ‘Son’ to the same sublime state of existence cannot be treated in any way like ordinary human death. Human death is fearsome not because the soul leaves the body and severs its ties by gaining a new con- sciousness, but the horrors of death are mainly on account of one’s permanently severing ties with many dear ones left here on earth, and leaving behind one’s possessions and different objects of love. Many a time it so happens that a man who has nothing to live for, prefers to die rather than live an empty life. as In the case of Jesus , the feeling of remorse could not have been present. For him the window of death was open only in one single direction, that of gain and not of loss. Why should his departure from the body be considered an extremely pitiable and agonizing experience? Again, if he died once and literally, not metaphorically gave up the ghost, as the Christians would have us === PDF-Seite 82 === 54 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
believe, then returning to the same body is the most unwise step attributed to him. Was he reborn when he returned to the body that he had abandoned during the hour of death? If this process is as only to be described as the revival or resurrection of Jesus , then the body should also have been eternalized. But what we read in the Bible is a completely different story. According to that story as Jesus was resurrected from the dead by entering the same body in which he had been crucified and that was called his regaining of life. That being so, what would be the meaning of the act of his abandoning the body once again? Would that not be tantamount to a second death? If the first departure from the body was death, then most cer- tainly the second time he is considered to have abandoned the human body, he should be declared eternally dead. When the soul abandons the body first time, you call it death; when it returns to the same body, you call it life after death. But what would you call it when the soul leaves the same body once again never to return—will it be called eternal death or eternal life according to the Christian jargon? It has to be eternal death and nothing more. Contradiction upon contradiction, a very nerve racking experi- ence indeed! If it is suggested that the body was not abandoned the second time, then we have a strange scenario in which God the Father exists as an infinite incorporeal spiritual being while the ‘Son’ remains trapped in the restricted confines of mortal existence. === PDF-Seite 83 === Sin and Atonement 55
Limited Suffering for Unlimited Sin It may be suggested that it is not always the pangs of conscience which create a miserable state of mind and heart in those who are sensitive to their faults. On the other hand, intense sympathy for the sufferings of others may also create a life of agony for someone who is totally or partially innocent of crime, but has that sublime spiritual quality of suffering for the sake of others. That would also create a similitude of hell. Mothers suffer for their ailing babies. The human experience stands witness to the fact that sometimes for a permanently disabled child the entire life of the mother is as turned into a living hell. So why cannot we concede to Jesus that noble quality of being able to suffer for the sake of others? Why not indeed! But why only three days and nights? Why not for his entire sojourn on earth, and even before and after that? Noble people do not suffer only temporarily for a very limited period of hours or days. Their hearts do not rest in peace unless they see misery mitigated or alleviated entirely. The hell which we are considering is not the prerogative of an innocent divine person only; it is a noble quality shared to some degree even by the beasts of the jungle for their near ones. After a few more remarks I shall rest my case, but I have one other important issue to briefly touch upon. The punishment as prescribed by God for Jesus Christ only lasted for three days and three nights, while the sinners for whom he was punished, had committed sins so horrible and for so long that, according to the Bible, their punishment was to be eternal suffering in hell. So what sort of a just God was it that when it came to the punish- === PDF-Seite 84 === 56 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
ment of those created by Him, people who were not His sons or daughters, they were to be punished eternally? But when it came to the punishment of His own ‘Son’, for sins he had voluntarily taken upon himself, suddenly the punishment was reduced to only three days and three nights. No comparison whatsoever. If this is justice then let justice not be. How would God look at the conduct of human beings, whom He has Himself created with His right hand, if they dispense justice as they learnt it from Him by applying different measures to their own children, and very different to those of others? Will God the Father watch this loyal imitation with ecstasy or horror? This is very difficult indeed to answer.
What did Atonement Change? as As far as the effect of the crucifixion of Jesus Christ in relation to the punishment of sin is concerned, we have already established as that faith in Jesus Christ has in no way reduced the punishment of sin, prescribed by God, for Adam and Eve and their progeny. All human mothers still bear their children with the pains of labour, and it is still with labour that man earns his bread. We can consider this from another angle, that of a broad comparison between the Christian and non-Christian world since the time of as as Jesus Christ . No believers in Christ can show a remarkable change, in any period of history, of their women delivering their children without pains, and their men earning their bread without labour. They do not show any difference in this regard in com- parison to the non-Christian world. === PDF-Seite 85 === Sin and Atonement 57
As far as the disposition to commit sins is concerned, the world as of believers in Christ compared with the world of non-believers does not record any evidence that the disposition to commit sin is totally obliterated among the category of believers in as Christ . In addition to this, one may indeed wonder why having faith in God is considered so inferior to having faith in His ‘Son’. This is especially relevant to the time before this tightly kept, age-old secret (that God had a ‘Son’) was disclosed to mankind. Of course there were people who had faith in God and His Unity. as Also innumerable people were born since Christ in every re- ligion and land of the earth who believed in God and His one- ness. Why did faith in God not bear any influence on human crime and punishment? Again why could not God the Father display that nobility of suffering for the sake of sinners which His nobler ‘Son’ displayed? Most certainly the Son seems to possess higher moral values (God forbid) than his less civilised Father. Is Divinity evolving and still in the process of attaining perfection, one may ask? === PDF-Seite 86 === === PDF-Seite 87 === chapter three
the role of the holy ghost
as So far, we have discussed the question of Jesus the so-called as ‘Son’ and also God the supposed literal ‘Father’ of Jesus . Yet there is a third person by the name of the ‘Holy Ghost’ who, according to Christian dogma, despite having a distinct individual personality, is still amalgamated and so completely and eternally fused with the ‘Father’ and the ‘Son’ that their merger creates singleness in three. Now we turn our attention to this question by enquiring whether the Holy Ghost has an ego separate from God as or Jesus , or do they share one single ego? Ego can be described here as the ultimate seat of consciousness which, in the final analysis, is indivisible and specific to each individual. The same ultimate awareness of one’s being as distinct from that of others gives birth to ‘I’, and ‘my’ and ‘mine’, as against ‘he’ and ‘his’ and ‘you’ and ‘yours’. Bringing into focus the three parts of Divinity, we must resolve whether the three have distinct egos of their own or not. If they do not have distinct separate egos, then to attribute to them personages would become inconceivable. Each person, however close he may be to another, has to enjoy a separate individual consciousness of his being. === PDF-Seite 88 === 60 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
The ‘official position’ of most churches is very clear and well defined, claiming that each of the three entities of God’s person- age had a distinctly separate personage ‘of its’ own. So it is not just ‘Three in One’, but rather it is three persons in one person. The as bitter encounter of Jesus with death and all its fateful conse- quences must have been equally shared by the Holy Ghost. So also, he should have been included in the sacrifice along with as as Jesus . Again, he must have suffered hell in the company of Jesus and God the Father. If not, then one cannot escape drawing the inevitable conclusion that not only were they three distinct and different persons, but also their emotions and faculties relating to head and heart must have been different, separate and insulated from those of each other. In trying to take further our vision of the Trinity we should attempt to visualize the fact of three persons merging together, or existing as merged together eternally as one. So far we have failed to see how they could have merged in their emotions and thought processes. The only option left, therefore, is a merger in the body. It re- minds us on a different scale of a hydra-headed monster, men- tioned in the Greek mythology, which possessed many heads that grew again when cut off. Of course, man cannot understand the true nature of God and how His attributes function, but it is very easy and simple to believe in one single entity without specific areas to which certain functions are attributed and confined, like head, heart and kidneys etc. But the scenario of separate individ- ual thoughts and feelings is certainly at variance with the afore- mentioned scenario of a single entity. It creates an image of God === PDF-Seite 89 === The Role of the Holy Ghost 61