Cover Page
Christianity - A Journey from Facts to Fiction, Part 11
as as Jesus . They all believed that Jonah , miraculously or otherwise, survived for three days and nights in the belly of the fish and did not die in that period for a single moment. Of course, we have as our own reservations regarding this view. The story of Jonah as told to us in the Holy Qur’an does not mention anywhere that it as was for three days and nights that Jonah suffered his trials in the belly of the fish. However, we return to the case in point and try to bring to light the actual similarities which were predicted by as as Jesus Christ between Jonah and himself. Those similarities spoke clearly of spending three days and nights in extremely precarious circumstances and of a miraculous revival from near death, and as not of coming back to life from the dead. The same, Jesus claimed, would happen in his case.
Jesus’ Promise to the House of Israel as The second important piece of evidence is that Jesus told his people that the sheep of the House of Israel who dwelt in and around Judea were not the only sheep, and that he was sent by God not only to them but also to the other sheep of the same flock. Just as he had come to retrieve them he would also go and retrieve the others as well.
And I have other sheep, that are not of this fold; I must bring them also, and they will heed my voice. So there shall be one flock, one shepherd. (John 10:16)
Now according to common knowledge, between the time of his promise and Crucifixion, he never left the land of Judea for === PDF-Seite 100 === 72 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
as anywhere else. The question is, if Jesus ascended to heaven eternally, had the lost sheep of Israel also ascended earlier? The Christians believe that after having been taken down from the cross as dead, his soul returned to his body after three days or so and then he was seen climbing into the clouds and disappearing into the unknown recesses of the heavens, only to reach ulti- mately the throne of his Father and to sit on His right hand eternally from then on. If this is true then we will be faced with a very grave dilemma indeed. We shall have to choose between as two positions, one taken by Jesus himself and the other by his followers. The two positions are so uncompromising that accept- as ing one would certainly negate the other. If Jesus was right, as we believe he was, then before ascending to the heaven he should have remembered his own promise and sought some more time from ‘God the Father’ to tarry a bit longer on earth so that he could go to the countries where many of the Israeli tribes before him had gone and settled. He could not have ascended to the heavens without breaking his promise and trust, blemishing and irreparably damaging his perfect god, perfect man image. If, on the contrary, the Christian theologians are to be considered right as and it is accepted that Jesus actually forgot his commitment to the house of Israel and left straight for the heavens, then we must conclude with a heavy heart that the Christian theologians are right indeed but, alas, Christianity turns out to be false. Because if as Jesus is proved to be false, Christianity cannot be true. We believe that he was a true Prophet of God and could not have made a false promise. What he meant by the lost sheep was the ten tribes of Israel, who had earlier migrated from Judea and === PDF-Seite 101 === Crucifixion 73
had gone to remote eastern lands. His promise, therefore, was that he would not be killed on the cross but would be given a long life to pursue his mission and that he was a Prophet not just for the two Israeli tribes living around him, but for all the Israelites. Together, the above two pieces of evidence provide the positive as indication of what was to happen to Jesus Christ after the Cruci- fixion.
Events of the Crucifixion Another point relevant to this issue relates to the fixing of the date and time by Pilate for carrying out the Crucifixion. Even before he fixed the date and time we read of other things which, one should not be surprised to believe, might have played an impor- tant role regarding his final decision. First of all we know on the authority of the New Testament that Pilate’s wife was strongly as averse to her husband passing judgement against Jesus because of the influence of a dream she had the night before the trial of as Jesus . (Matt 27:19) She was so terrified by the effect of the dream, which led her to as believe that Jesus was absolutely innocent, that she thought it imperative to disturb the court proceedings to convey the message of the dream to her husband. Perhaps it was this urgent protesta- tion by his wife that led Pilate to make a show of absolving as himself of the responsibility of his condemnation of Jesus :
So when Pilate saw that he was gaining nothing, but rather that a riot was beginning, he took water and washed his hands before the === PDF-Seite 102 === 74 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
crowd, saying, "I am innocent of this man’s blood; see to it yourselves." (Matt 27:24)
This amounted to a confession on his part that as Jesus was indeed innocent and that the harsh judgement passed by him was under duress. It is quite clear from the New Testa- ment that the powerful Jewish community had colluded against as Jesus and was determined to have him punished. So any decision by Pilate contrary to Jewish wishes could have resulted in a grave law and order situation. This was Pilate’s compulsion which rendered him helpless and was displayed in the act of washing his hands. as Pilate had also made another attempt to save Jesus . He gave as the enraged crowds an option either to save Jesus’ life or that of a notorious criminal called Barabbas (Matt 27:16–17). This provides us with a significant clue to the state of Pilate’s mind at that time. as He was quite obviously against the idea of sentencing Jesus . It was in this psychological state that he fixed Friday afternoon to be the day and time of the execution. What actually happened was a clear indication that he did it on purpose because the Sabbath was not very far from Friday afternoon and he, as the custodian of law, knew better than anyone else that before the Sabbath began by as sunset, Jesus’ body would have to be taken down; and that is exactly what happened. What normally took three days and nights, approximately, to finally inflict a torturous death upon a as condemned man was subjected to Jesus for a few hours at the most Hardly enough, one is compelled to wonder, to actually kill as a man like Jesus , whom an austere life had toughened physically. === PDF-Seite 103 === Crucifixion 75
as Could this incident not be a key to the enigma of Jonah ? As it was a common practice for a condemned person to hang on the cross for three days and nights, this rings a bell indeed in one’s as as mind about the similitude between Jesus and Jonah , as men- as tioned earlier. Jonah is also supposed to have remained within the body of the fish for three days and three nights. Maybe he too was delivered alive by God’s design within three hours instead of as three days. So what happened in the case of Jesus becomes a as mirror reflecting and replaying the tragic drama of Jonah . Now we turn to the events during the Crucifixion. Even at the as last moment Jesus stood firm to his protestations: ‘Eli, Eli, la´ma sabach-tha´ni?’ How deeply tragic this is, and how painfully expressive of his disillusionment. This exclamation is subtly pointing at some earlier promise and assurance which God must have given him; otherwise, no sense whatsoever can be read in this exclamation. It is a denial both of his wish and willingness to carry, of his own volition, the load of other people’s sin and of the view that he was looking forward to that hour of death. Why this deep cry of anguish when the punishment was demanded by him in the first place? Why should he reproach God, or even pray as for deliverance? Jesus’ statement should be read in the context of what happened before. He was praying to God throughout to take the bitter cup off from him. We as Ahmadi Muslims believe that a pious and holy person as that Jesus was, made it impossible that God did not accept his prayer. He must have been told that the prayer had been ac- cepted. I do not believe that he gave up the ghost on the cross. With me there is no contradiction and everything is consistent. === PDF-Seite 104 === 76 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
His perceived death was only the impression of an observer who was neither a physician nor had any opportunity to medically examine him. An onlooker, watching with such anxiety and concern lest death should overtake his beloved master, merely observed the dropping of the tired head with chin resting against as the chest of Jesus . And ‘Lo’, he exclaimed, ‘He gave up the ghost’. But as we explained earlier, this is not a treatise to discuss the merits and authenticities of the Biblical account from the point of view of genuineness or otherwise, or to dispute any interpretations attributed to them. We are here only to critically examine the very logic and commonsense of Christian philosophy and dogma. The point which is conclusively established therefore as is that whether Jesus swooned or died, his painful surprise at what was about to happen strongly proves that he expected otherwise. If death it was that he sought then the surprise that he showed had no justification at all. Our interpretation as Ahmadi as Muslims is that Jesus was only surprised because he was given a promise of deliverance from the cross by God during his supplica- as tions the night before. But God had other plans: He caused Jesus to merely swoon so that the sentries on guard could be misled to believe that he had died and as such to release his body to Joseph of Arimathea, to be delivered to his kith and kin. The surprise as which we notice in the last words of Jesus Christ was also shared by Pilate himself: ‘Already dead’, is what he exclaimed when the incident of death was reported to him (Mark 15:44). He must have had a long experience with crucifixion during his tenure as Governor of Judea and could not have expressed his surprise unless he was convinced that it is unusual for death to overtake a === PDF-Seite 105 === Crucifixion 77
crucified person within the short period of only a few hours. Yet he had to accept the plea to release the body under mysterious circumstances. That is why he is forever accused of conspiracy. It is alleged that under the influence of his wife he saw to it that the as execution of Jesus took place at an hour very close to the hour of Sabbath. Secondly, he conceded to the request to release the body as despite doubtful reports of Jesus’ death. This decision of Pilate caused grave concern among the Jews who petitioned him and as expressed their doubts and suspicions regarding the death of Jesus (Matt 27:62–66). We also learn from the Bible that when his body was taken down his legs were not broken, whereas the legs of the two thieves, hanging along with him, were broken to make sure that as they died (John 19:31–32). This act of sparing Jesus would certainly have helped his revival from the coma. It cannot be ruled out altogether that the sentries had been instructed by some as emissaries of Pilate, not to break the legs of Jesus Christ . Perhaps this was done as a mark of respect for him and the innocent Christian community. According to the Bible, when his side was pierced blood and as water gushed out: But when they came to Jesus and found him already dead, they did not break his legs. Instead one of the as soldiers pierced Jesus’ side with a spear bringing a sudden flow of blood and water (John 19:33–34). If he was dead and his heart had stopped beating, such active bleeding as would cause the blood to rush out or gush out would be impossible. At most, coagulated blood and plasma could have passively seeped out. But that is not the picture which the New === PDF-Seite 106 === 78 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
Testament presents, it says that blood and water rushed out. As far as the mention of water is concerned it should not be surprising as for Jesus to have developed pleurisy during the extremely exact- ing and punishing hours of trial that he spent upon the cross. Also, the stress of the Crucifixion could have resulted in exudates from the pleura to collect likes bags of water, which is medically termed as wet pleurisy. This condition, which is otherwise dangerous and painful, seems to have turned into an advantage for as Jesus because when his side was pierced the swollen pleura could easily have played the role of a cushion protecting the chest organs from being directly penetrated by the spear. Water mixed with blood rushed out because of an active heart. Another piece of evidence is as follows. According to the Bibli- cal account, after the body was handed over to Joseph of Arimat- hea, it was immediately removed to a secret place of burial, a as sepulchre with enough room not only for Jesus but also for two of his attendants to sit and take care of him: Then the disciples as went back to their homes, but Mary stood outside the tomb crying. As she wept, she bent down over to look into the tomb as and saw two angels in white, seated where Jesus’ body had been (John 20:10–12). That is not all, we are informed in the New Testament that an ointment, which had been prepared in advance, was applied to as Jesus’ wounds (John 19:39–40). This ointment, prepared by the as disciples of Jesus , contained ingredients which have properties of healing wounds and subduing pain etc. Why was there all this fuss about going through the laborious exercise of collecting twelve rare ingredients to prepare an ointment at all? The prescription === PDF-Seite 107 === Crucifixion 79