(Matthew 5:9)
Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 6
Christianity declares men sinful on the ground that their forefather Adam had sinned and since men are begotten of him, they are sinful. We say that the Messiah was also of the generation of Adam through Eve and therefore, full of sin.
The Christians argue that man inherited sin from Adam, but that Jesus had no father and, therefore, did not inherit Adam’s sin. Our contention is that a heritage is transmitted from both the parents. If, for instance, the mother is syphilitic, the child is liable to carry the germs of the malady; or if, for instance, the mother is consumptive, the child may be affected by T.B. germs. Many a consumptive mother has been the source of the incidence of T.B. among her offspring. A study of conditions in the world shows that defects, whether moral, or physical or spiritual, existing in the parents, are liable to be transmitted to the children through heredity. It never happens that something may be transmitted through the father but not through the mother. Both the parents are concerned in heredity. When we examine the point from this stand, the conclusion is irresistible that Jesus, even though he had no father, did inherit Adam’s sin through his mother. Jesus can be declared free from hereditary sin, if it can be established that he was neither of the generation of Adam nor of Eve. If he was without both a father and a mother, we can certainly concede that he was not tainted with hereditary sin, or, when it is proved that Eve did not sin, Jesus may be deemed to be free from hereditary sin, as, it can then be argued that he was born of Eve who was sinless and not begotten of Adam who was sinful. But the truth is that even so, Jesus has no escape from sin. For, even if it is supposed that
Eve did not sin and it was Adam alone who sinned, we could say that he did not carry the taint of sin if he were born of Eve, but Jesus was born of a lady who was born thousands of years after Eve and was linked to her through thousands of chains. During this period, thousands of times sons of Adam had touched the daughters of Eve and it was thus after thousands of cycles that Mary was born. How could she ever be immune to the taint of Adam’s sin through these thousands of cycles? Had she been born directly of Eve and had Eve also been free from sin, it could without a doubt be claimed that since Eve was without sin and Mary was born of her directly, she did not carry sin. But she was not born directly of Eve, but was of the generation of those daughters of Eve who had been tainted with sin thousands of times and having thus inherited, the sin of Adam could not be the cause of Messiah’s sinlessness.
Again, it is incorrect to say that Eve was sinless. In fact, according to the Bible, she was a greater sinner than Adam, The Bible says: “Now the serpent was more subtile than any beast of the field which the Lord God had made. (It should be remembered that the serpent stands for Satan in the Bible). And he said unto the woman, Yea, hath god said, ye shall not eat of every tree of the garden.” (that is to say the Satan went to Eve and was very clever in that he did not say to her that he had learnt that God had forbidden them the fruit of a particular tree but instead he said,
“Yea, hath God said, ye shall not eat of every tree of the garden.” “And the woman said unto the serpent, we may eat of the fruit of the trees of the garden: But of the fruit of the tree which is in the midst of the garden, God hath said, Ye shall not eat of it, neither shall ye touch it, lest Ye die. And the serpent said unto the woman, Ye shall not surely die: For God doth know that in the day ye eat thereof, then your eyes shall be opened and ye shall be as gods, knowing good and evil. And when the woman saw that it was good for food and that it was pleasant to the eye, and a tree to be desired to make one wise, she took of the fruit thereof, and did eat, and gave also unto her husband with her; and he did eat. And the eyes of them both were opened, and they knew that they were naked: and they sewed fig leaves together, and made themselves aprons. And they heard the voice of the Lord God walking in the garden in the cool of the day; and Adam and his wife hid themselves from the presence of the Lord God amongst the trees of the garden. And the Lord God called unto Adam, and said unto him, Where art thou? And he said, I heard thy voice in the garden and I was afraid, because I was naked; and I hid myself. And he said, Who told thee that thou wast naked? Hast thou eaten of the tree, whereof I commanded thee that thou shouldst not eat? And the man said, the woman whom thou gavest to be with me, she gave me of the tree and I did eat. And the Lord God said unto the woman, what is this that thou hast done? And the woman said, the serpent beguiled me and I did eat.
And the Lord God said unto the serpent, because thou hast done this, thou art cursed above all cattle, and above every beast of the field; upon thy belly shalt thou go, and dust shalt thou eat all the days of thy life; And I will put enmity between thee and the woman, and between thy seed and her seed; it shall bruise thy head and thou shalt bruise his heel. Unto the woman he said, I will greatly multiply thy sorrow and thy conception; in sorrow thou shalt bring forth children and thy desire shall be to thy husband, and he shall rule over thee. And unto Adam he said: Because thou hast hearkened unto the voice of thy wife and hast eaten of the tree, of which I commanded thee saying, Thou shalt not eat of it; cursed is the ground for thy sake; in sorrow shalt thou eat of it all the days of thy life; Thorns also and thistles shall it bring forth to thee; and thou shalt eat the herb of the field; In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground; for out of it wast thou taken; for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.”(Genesis 3:1-19)
This is the story of Adam’s sin as narrated in the Bible. It is evident from this account that the Satan aimed at beguiling Adam, for, he knew that Adam was a threat to his dominion. Eve posed no such threat. His real aim, therefore, was to oust Adam from the garden. In other words, Adam was the original inmate of the garden, Eve being born on account of him and was in the garden because of him. The real objective of Satan was to deceive Adam. But he did not approach him; instead, he approached Eve and persuaded her to eat of the fruit, and Eve subsequently made Adam partake of it. Why it so happened is a question that engages our attention at this stage. Why did Satan first approach Eve though his real objective was to deceive Adam. The answer is that no doubt his real aim was to deceive Adam but he feared lest by making a direct approach, he should fail in his objective of imposing upon Adam; he, therefore, tackled Eve, knowing that she would be more amenable to his imposition and serve as an instrument in bringing Adam round.
It can be said that it is in the power of the Almighty Lord to create virtuous people from among the progeny of Eve. We agree to this view and believe that Allah has the power to create out of the generation of Eve people totally free from sin of every kind. But the theory of vicarious atonement is not based on the premise that it is in the power of God the Great to create or not to create sinless people among the progeny of Eve; it is, on the contrary, based on the assumption that man is sinful by birth and has inherited the seed of sin from Adam. So far as the question relates to the powers of Allah, we hold this belief even in respect of the generations of Adam, that there can be and there have been sinless men among them. Therefore, so far as it concerns the powers of God the Almighty, it is as much within His power to create sinless persons from among the progeny of the sinful Eve as from that of the sinning Adam. The Christians, however, hold that the progeny of a sinful person cannot be sinless. In the face of this belief, the question of the power of the Almighty God does not arise. But if they are prepared to say, while subscribing to the view that the Almighty has the power that the progeny of Eve can be sinless, we would then claim that God the Almighty has the power similarly to create a sinless progeny from the seed of Adam. In that case, there remains no urge to lay emphasis on hereditary sin nor any occasion for sacrificing the Son of God in atonement. In other words, the entire structure of vicarious atonement crashes down instantly. Christians should come along on the level and accept that God the Almighty has the power to create pious progeny of sinful parents.
But if they are prepared to concede that God has this power in respect of the progeny of Eve but are not willing to agree that He has similar power in respect of the seed of Adam, it would be an objectionable thing. The long and short of it is, whether God the Almighty has the power to create a pious generation. If He has the power to create a pious progeny of a sinning mother, He has the power similarly to create a sinless progeny of a sinful father. And if God has not the power to create a sinless progeny of a sinful father, we would have to conclude that He has no power to create a pious progeny of a sinful mother either. In short, if He can create a sinless generation of a sinning mother, He can also create a sinless generation of a sinful father and if He cannot create a pious generation of a sinful father, neither can He create a sinless generation of a sinful mother.
The point at issue, therefore, is that if Messiah can be born of a sinful mother, other pious people can also be so born; nay, others can be more pious than the Messiah, on account of their partaking of the properties of both the parents. I have already made a mention of a Padre of Lahore who later became the Principal of the Saharanpur Mission College. I have stated before, a part of the talk I had with him. Now I would relate the rest of it. Probably Mr. Wood was the name of that missionary. I asked him if he could tell me what would happen if cold and hot water were mixed together. He said that it would get tempered; the hot water losing some of its heat and the cold water losing some of its coldness, there would be a balancing state. I enquired of him if Satan had first approached Adam or Eve. He said that he first went to Eve. I asked if the objective of Satan was to harm Eve or to do harm to Adam. I then put it to him that if Adam was his target why did he not go to Adam straight? Where was the necessity to make an encircling movement on the way? He answered that he did not go to Adam direct thinking that Eve was weak and that he would be able to prevail upon her easily and then she would manage to mislead Adam on her own, without any further ado on his part. I said that since Eve was weaker than Adam and was the first to commit sin and was responsible for misleading Adam, how is it then that one born of Eve exclusively, was sinless.
I said that taking into consideration the case of hot and cold water mixture, if we took Adam for cold water and Eve for hot water, the progeny born of their mixture, would certainly not be as sinful as the progeny born of Eve alone, and that, therefore, the Messiah who was born of Eve was more sinful than others. He asked if gold was not mined from dust. I told him that that formed the whole crux of the problem in dispute between us—that if gold could be mined from dust, then he could freely call Adam a sinner but must simultaneously concede that his progeny could be sinless and not necessarily invariably sinful. When I tackled him in that manner, he said that gold was not mined from dust but that it was mined from gold, and since Adam was sinful his progeny must necessarily be sinful and could not be sinless, for, gold was mined from gold. I answered that in that case Eve’s son would have to be considered more sinful than others, for, she was more sinful than Adam inasmuch as she not only ate of the fruit of the tree herself but also made Adam eat it and thus became I doubly sinful. He lost his temper at that and said that gold was not quarried from a mine of dust and that the mine was of earth but that gold came out of it. I told him to keep the same in view in respect of Adam—that though he had sinned, there could be some of his generation who would be pious and free from every sinful tendencies.
Now the Christians have only one way of escape left and that is to assert that, in the case of the Messiah, the question of the sin of his parents cannot arise; that he was the Son of God and therefore free from every sin in his person; that, the question does not arise in his case that because of being of the children of Eve he was more sinful or less sinful than others, but that because of being the son of God he was free from sin. In other words, his being sinless was not due to his being born of his mother but because of his being the son of God. Our objection to it is that if there was no special philosophy underlying his being without a father, and because of his being the son of God, he was immune to the influence of his parents, even if he were to have a father, he would not imbibe his influence; and if the Messiah were to be born of a married woman and were to have a father, he would have all the same remained immune to the influence of Adam and Eve, for, his real status was that of the Son of God. When he had to be sinless in any case, why did then God commit a grave wrong in creating Jesus in a manner that has humiliated him in the whole world—all over people say that he was not born in wedlock. (We seek refuge with Allah against such belief). When he was to be immune to the influence of his father and also to that of his mother, where was the need for this controversy and why did God cause hurt to Mary and the Messiah by placing them under this calumny? When he was the Son of God and free, in his essence, of all sin, he should have been born of a mother and a father so that he would be sinless on the basis of his own merit and would be saved from the slander of illegitimacy.