The Transmigration of Souls Refuted and a Comparison between the Vedas & the Holy Qur’an
Early Writings, Part 2
The first is a propter quid demonstration, which is an argument that moves from cause to effect. See Surah Ra‘d, part 13:
That is, God is the Creator of everything, for He is One and Unique in His person and attributes, and He is One in the sense that He is also All-Powerful, i.e. He causes everything to remain under His control and thus He reigns over them. This argument proves to be valid, firstly, by a clear method which is evident through the minor premise that God is the One and All- Powerful, and its major premise is that anyone who is the One and All-Powerful would be the Creator of everything except His own person. Hence, the conclusion is that God is the Creator of all creation.
The first proposition that constitutes the minor premise can be validated thus that the principle that God is One and Unique is accepted not only by the opposing party but also by the entire world.
The second proposition which constitutes the major premise is that if God, on account of His being the One and Omnipotent, is not the Creator of everything excluding His own self and if the existence of all things is eternal like Him, then He cannot be the One, the Omnipotent Lord. The reason He cannot be the One in this case is that the very definition of the Oneness of God Almighty is that He has no partner whatsoever. Now, if God is not the Creator of the souls, this would constitute association of partners with God in two respects. First, if all the souls in their entirety are not His creation, then they would have to be accepted as being akin to Him and thus eternal like Him. Secondly, one will have to believe in their connection that like God, the True Lord, they too enjoy eternal existence which is not dependent on anything. This is the inherent definition of associating others with God, and to hold an associate with the Creator in respect of creation is evidently false in terms of rationality, for this would mean that there is a partner to the Creator, while the concept of a partner to the Creator is utterly impossible and unthinkable. Therefore, any premise which results in an impossibility is inherently flawed. What is more, a God with a partner cannot be the All-Powerful Lord either. For the attribute of being the All- Powerful Lord means that He has full command over everything, and rules and prevails over everything. As such, God cannot bring under His control such things that are not His creation—including the souls. The reason is that such things which, with respect to their persons, are eternal and are not His creation are by necessity independent of Him in respect of their existence, as they do not require any other cause for the substantiation of their personal existence. This, in other words, is the concept which is known as the concept of the ‘necessary being,’ who, in turn, is known in Persian as Khuda [God], i.e. the Self-Subsisting Lord.
Hence, if souls are akin to the Creator as ‘God’ and if they are
‘necessary beings’ like Him, it would rationally be impossible and unthinkable for them to be subordinate to Him. For one ‘necessary being’ cannot be in the control of another ‘necessary being’, as this would constitute circular logic and entail infinite regress. However, the current position, on which both parties are in agreement, is that all souls are being controlled by God and none are out of His control. This proves that they all have been brought into existence and have been created, and that none of them is God or the necessary being. Quod erat demonstrandum. The second is a quia demonstration, which is an argument that moves from effect to cause. Refer to Surah al-Furqan:
That is, He has no partner in His sovereignty. He is the Creator of everything and the evident proof of His being the Creator is that He has created everything according to a fixed measure beyond which a thing cannot overstep; rather it must stay within and remain confined to a fixed parameter. In the language of logic, we can say that each body and soul is limited and confined within a particular parameter. And, everything that is confined and restricted to a particular parameter is bound to be subject to a restrictor and confiner. Hence, the conclusion is that for each body and soul there is a restrictor and confiner.
Now, the proof of the first premise, i.e. all things are confined and working within a fixed parameter, is that rationality could suggest that there be greater qualities and characteristics in bodies and souls than those that are found in them at present. For instance, man has two eyes, and the human intellect may view it as a possibility that he might have had four: two on the front of the face and two at the back, so that he could see what was behind him just as he is able to observe what is in front of him. And, there is no doubt that to have four eyes instead of two would be far more beneficial and advantageous. Likewise, man does not have wings. It could have been possible that he too had wings like birds. Similarly, the human mind is confined within specific parameters of activity. Just as it cannot easily fathom hidden realities without the instruction of a teacher, and just as it cannot function properly if affected by an externally oppressing force such as madness or intoxication due to which it quickly begins to lose its abilities and faculties; similarly, it cannot easily perceive the infinitesimal particulars of a thing as the learned scholar and researcher Avicenna has explained in the seventh chapter of his book Remarks and Admonitions,1 even though it was rationally possible for man to have been preserved from such shortfalls and inadequacies. Therefore, the question is what is the underlying reason in man being deprived of a whole array of capabilities and merits which, as rationality suggests, he could have possibly possessed? Is it because someone else proposed these shortcomings for man or is it because man voluntarily proposed them for himself ? If someone says that man himself opted for them, this would surely be false, because no one prefers to be deficient. On the other hand, if someone says that it is because someone else has proposed them for him, then I would like to congratulate you, for this proves the existence of the Creator of souls and bodies. Quod erat demonstrandum.
The third argument is based on reductio ad absurdum. To elaborate, reductio ad absurdum is the kind of argument in which the credibility of a conclusion is proved by showing that the contradictory would be impossible. In the study of logic, this kind of argument is called absurdum because the term ‘absurdum’ implies a meaning of ‘falsity.’ Hence, under this method of argumentation, if the proposition that is put forth as being valid is not accepted to be true, then the conclusion will necessitate falsity. Here is an example of this kind of argument. Refer to Surah at-Tur, part 27:
Meaning, Have these people, who do not believe that God is their the Creator, come into being without anyone having created them, or are they their own creators, or are they the cause of all causes who created the heavens and earth, or are they in possession of infinite treasures of knowledge and wisdom by which they have come to know that they are eternally existent, or are they free and not subject to anyone’s control so that it should be held that when there is no one who stands above them as dominant and powerful, then how can there be a Being who might have created them? This verse puts forth profound argumentation whereby each premise of the five part argument in favour of the eternity of souls can be seen by the reader to have immediately negated itself. And, the profound points that have been made in the aforementioned verse are as follows:
Firstly, the concept of a non-existent coming into being without the agency of an agent is false because this would necessitate preference without the agency of a preferer. This is because to don the cloak of existence from nothingness requires a determining cause that would favour existence over non-existence. However, in this case, no credible reason for such a preference has been established. Therefore, without the agency of an active preferer, the occurrence of preference by itself is also impossible.
Secondly, it is impossible to be one’s own Creator, for this necessitates the existence of a thing prior to one’s own existence. The reason for this is that if it is accepted that the causative factor of everything is its own self, then the acceptance of such a notion would essentially require all things to be in existence prior to their own existence, and to exist before coming into existence is an impossibility.
Thirdly, if every entity was believed to be the cause of all causes and the creator of the universe in the likeness of God’s being, this would necessitate a plurality of Gods, and it has already been agreed that a plurality of Gods is not possible. Secondly, the said process would also result in a circular argument and necessitate an infinite regress, and that too is not possible.
Fourthly, it is impossible for man to encompass infinite knowledge by virtue of the argument that the being of man, if seen from the standpoint of other entities in external existence, is finite in its nature, and the infinite cannot be encompassed by the finite, for this would necessitate the limiting of that which is limitless.
Fifthly, it is not possible for a person to be independent and beyond the command of another. For the human self is in need of a perfecter for its own perfection. Hence, one who is in need of another cannot be independent. This would be contradiction in terms. Hence, while it is absolutely and categorically impossible for creation to come into being without a Creator, it must be admitted that all things as are confined within and restricted to a limit have been created by a Creator who is God Almighty.