The Message (The Treatise Ummahatul-Mu’minin)

The Message or A Cry of Anguish, Part 2

Ninth condition for discourses and writings is to have no personal desire, and to solely dedicate one’s entire life to the service of faith. For experience shows that the heart finds it difficult to be devoted to two different tasks. For instance, one who is a civil servant and burdened with official responsibilities, if he attends to producing religious literature, then surely, apart from the dishonesty he would be committing in spending his work hours in other activities, he cannot equal the person who has dedicated his entire time solely for this purpose, to the extent that his whole life is exclusively devoted to this cause.

Tenth condition for verbal and written [debates] is possessing miraculous power or heavenly signs. Man depends on witnessing this power in order to find true enlightenment and attain complete satisfaction. This, in fact, is the final verdict given by God Almighty. Therefore, whoever confronts the enemies of Islam and wishes to render speechless and subdue those who deem the manifestation of wonders to be against the law of nature, or those that deny the marvels and miracles of our Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, must present those chosen servants of the Muhammadan Ummah that can display signs through their prayers.

Remember, heavenly signs are closely linked with religion, for a true religion it is necessary that those who display miracles are continuously born within it. The truthful are not only granted scriptural evidences by God Almighty, but the one who debates with the opponents purely for His sake is certainly also granted heavenly signs. Indeed these signs are conferred upon him so that the God of heaven makes him prevail with His own hand; and the one who is not bestowed signs by God Almighty, I fear, is a hidden disbeliever, since heavenly support did not descend for him in keeping with the promise in the Holy Qur’an.

These are the ten conditions that are essential for those intending to write a rebuttal, or enter into a verbal debate with any Christian opponent. Thus, one should be chosen to produce the refutation of the treatise Ummahatul-Mu’minin strictly on the basis of these conditions. The Christians have left no stone unturned in disseminating this treatise, and without caring for any legal accountability, they have sent a copy of the book to every respected Muslim without their demanding for it, and thus have injured the hearts of all the Muslims of British India. All this undertaking indicates that this is the last weapon they have deployed. The real motive behind the usage of extremely vulgar language in this treatise is to provoke the Muslims into petitioning the courts and sending memorials to the honourable Government so that they may not adopt the right action which in fact is the true and effective remedy for such fabricated accusations. Accordingly, I find that their ploy has worked. The only response the Muslims have come up with to this despicable and filthy book is to merely complain to the Government through a memorial. Regarding this book, Anjuman-e-Himayat-e-Islam Lahore deemed it appropriate only to protest before the Government. Alas, they never realised that this was precisely the motive of the Christian clergymen that the Muslims, by adopting this regressive approach, should be deprived of following the teaching of their Gracious Lord,

This sad and distressing thought shatters my heart that on one hand there is a book the publication of which, poisons the hearts of the ignorant and destroys an entire people, and on the other hand, those who take thousands of rupees from the Muslims in order to write a rebuttal to the enemies of faith, their sole strategy to counter this malicious campaign is to send a short memorial to the Government, thereby showing that they have done all that they possibly could. Notwithstanding the fact that they have repeatedly announced that the first and foremost objective of their organisation is to refute the objections that are levelled against Islam by the opponents from time to time. Hence, anyone that has ever come across the journal of Anjuman-e-Himayat-e- Islam Lahore will find this promise written at the outset. I do not say that this organisation deliberately evades their self-proclaimed promise. The fact is that the present organisation is utterly incompetent to address the extensive matters of faith or to dispel the evil suggestions and allegations that have been circulated by the Christians for the last sixty years with comprehensive study and research, or through some publication counter the toxic wind that is sweeping across the country. It would have been far better if this organisation had not associated itself with religious matters and restricted its understanding and reason to political affairs alone.

Seeing the issue of The Observer dated 6 May 1898 has only increased my disappointment since its editor, an advocate of the Anjuman, has stated in plain words that it would be completely unwise to write a rebuttal to the treatise Ummahatul-Mu’minin and should be content with the response by the Anjuman, that is, submitting a memorial to the Government. A perusal of The Observer clearly shows that it is not only the editor who holds this opinion but the Anjuman too has decided not to refute the treatise. Now let the wise ponder as to what kind of service these measures render to Islam. Even if the honourable Government were to mete out the harshest punishment to the one who has published such a book, how can it ever be an antidote to the poisonous effect of these fabrications on the hearts? Rather, in my opinion, this strategy will further spread an adverse effect among people.

I declare it again and again that if we wish to remove the ill-effects of the writings of the clergy from the hearts, then the path the Anjuman has adopted is surely not the true path to success. On the contrary, we should gather all these objections, and then produce a comprehensive reply to each and every one of them with extremely suitable and conclusive discourse. By doing so the hearts will be cleansed from these impure misconceptions, and the light of Islam will be made apparent to the world. I truly proclaim that in the present age, which is in peril by the misconceptions of the priests and philosophers, it is utterly impermissible that instead of presenting a sensible reply, we should strive solely to have them punished. It is true that our benevolent Government would not favour the priests if they were found guilty on some account. However, we would be gravely mistaken to think that our entire achievement was to have someone reprimanded by the Government. O naive and ignorant people! These evil suggestions continue to ruin the future progeny of the Muslims. Therefore, the first and foremost measure is for Muslims to come up with a rebuttal to the allegations which have corrupted, and continue to contaminate, thousands of hearts. Initially, the Christian priests had followed this very course of politeness and forgiveness.

Despite being confronted with harsh and abusive language in verbal debates, they never sent any memorial to the Government and patiently continued instilling their misconceptions into the hearts until this strategy resulted in thousands of new converts to Christianity in our country.

We are not opposed to the idea that the Government should be requested in a general manner to restrict debates and writings within certain limits, and to ban such unbridled freedom and foul language that might lead to unrest between peoples. Indeed we are the prime movers of this proposal. In our previous memorial, we had already outlined as to how and with which means this worthy objective can be achieved. Yet we are against such a memorial which is not presented in a general manner, and which stresses on punishing an individual whose main objections we have yet to answer. For, in keeping with the teaching of the Holy Qur’an, it was our duty to have set aside the vulgar language of a foulmouthed person and to have answered his principal objections as Allah the Almighty says,

In fact, it is quite dangerous and perilous if we leave the objections of a critic unaddressed, for in that case they will continue to spread like the germs of the plague, giving rise to thousands of doubts in the hearts of the people. Even if the Government somewhat punishes such an abusive person those doubts will not reduce. Observe, those who criticise Islam such as the author of Ummahatul-Mu’minin, Imaduddin and Safdar Ali, etc., the reason for their apostasy is that at the time they were not dealt with kindness and compassion, rather more often than not they were treated rudely and offensively; their misconceptions were not removed with tenderness. Therefore, these people, having been deprived of Islamic blessings, donned the cloak of apostasy. Presently, the majority of those who attack Islam comprise of people who became Christian in desperation due to the lack of attention they received from their fellow Muslims. Just open your eyes and see that the people who spew foul language they have not come from Europe, but are the very descendants of the native Muslims of this country who, by gradually alienating themselves from Islam and slowly being influenced by the Christian propaganda, have reached thus far. In fact, millions of hearts have been ruined and thousands of minds have been perverted. Therefore, the most vital and important thing for us to do is to cast a glance and see that people are becoming lepers, and poisonous plants of misconceptions have been sown and continue to take root in countless hearts. God Almighty encourages us throughout the Holy Qur’an that we should truly support the faith of Islam, and it is our responsibility that every single objection raised by the opponents should be answered with thorough research and detailed investigation, in order to fully satisfy the seekers of truth.

But here naturally a question arises: would it be sufficient to refute only those objections raised in the treatise Ummahatul- Mu’minin? In response, I emphatically present my counsel that this effort alone is completely inadequate to counter the current deadly wind. The example of this is that out of the many filthy drains, we clean just the one and consider this sufficient for purifying the air. Certainly not! In fact until we do not clean all the drains of the town and wash away the filth that has accumulated in different minds due to various kinds of objections, and until we do not publish proofs and convincing arguments that would completely eliminate the stench and replace it with the fragrance of pure Islamic teachings, till then, it is as though we have done nothing to save the lives of men.

Here, we need not mention that the propaganda of the priests has caused large-scale damage. They have sowed such poisonous seeds in our country that seriously threatens the spiritual life of this nation. If you reflect you will realise that this mischief continues to corrupt many minds, and alienates them from Islam. This mischief is of two kinds: (1) The first is that which I have just mentioned, namely the mischief caused by the toxic writings of the priests. (2) The second one has arisen out of the spread of modern natural sciences which have led many newly-educated people to take on the garb of atheism and heresy. They neither care for their beliefs nor their actions. They have taken libertarianism to the extreme. True sympathy for the nation and mankind does not at present consist of being satisfied with merely refuting a few points.

·

10 of 10 left today