Correspondence with Shaikh Muhammad Husain Batalawi

The Mirror of the Excellences of Islam, Part 6

His Statement: [You] avoided discussion and then issued a poster with various false allegations and lies.

My Statement: All these are your disgraceful lies which are emanating from your mouth uncontrollably because of your innate [evil] nature. Otherwise, those who carefully consider your writings and mine can decide for themselves whether making accusations, telling lies, or shirking discussion are a characteristic of my humble self or your own. Who would indulge in such crafty talk if not you as you are a Shaikh with some familiarity with the law, and are overly proud of your little learning? But take due note that the day is coming when God Almighty will Himself make manifest which of us two is the liar, the fabricator, and the disgraced and humiliated in the eyes of God Almighty, and whose honour is established by the Benevolent God with heavenly Signs. Be patient for a little while and witness the end.

His Statement: If you had even a trace of kindness and sympathy, you would have at once called me to your own place or paid me a visit when I opposed your claim of being the Promised Messiah.

My Statement: Dear Sir! Who had prevented you from coming to me? Were there guards at my door who stopped you? Were you used to asking permission before coming to see me in the past? Your father, even if ill and suffering from fever, used to come to me somehow from Batala; so, what new obstacle prevented you? And, since you were not going to abandon your innate meanness and jealousy, devilish nature, conceit, and pride in any circumstances, what sympathy or kindness could I show you by inviting you to my home? Moreover, I also thought it inadvisable to go to your home, for I had recognized the elements of pride and conceit in your nature. I thought it would be useful to first purge you entirely of these elements. There is, however, no improvement in your condition up till now. God knows what fury is filled within you.

Allah, glorified be His eminence, knows that I have endured your abuse with great patience. I was tormented [by you] vehemently and kept trying to stop you from this course. Even now, I can patiently tolerate your criticisms and accusations of apostasy and sinfulness, but at times I deal with your abuse with some harshness, merely with the intent that the evil substance which lies deep within your heart, as the result of a wrong conception of your priestly position and which has possessed you like an evil spirit, may be completely expelled.

Verily I say, and God Almighty knows, that I am honestly convinced that you are simply a rogue—utterly devoid of knowledge, understanding, and deliberation—and are a foolish man of dull intellect who has never traversed the paths of verities and true divine knowledge. Additionally, you are afflicted with undue pride and conceit that has nearly killed you [spiritually]. Until you become cognizant of your state of ignorance, and the worm of conceit is expelled from your head, you cannot reap any worldly benefit or the benefit of faith. Your greatest friend would be the one who remains engaged in the effort of proving your ignorance and pride to you. I do not know what it is that you are so proud of. A shameful innate nature, a dull understanding, superficial thinking and then such pride and conceit!

[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]

.—[We seek Allah’s protection from this ignorance, stupidity, shamelessness, pettiness, and misguidance].

And this thought of yours, my dear man, that I have now sent the letter by way of mischief so that the Muslims of Batala may become divided is merely due to your innately suspicious nature. I had not sent the letter to create dissension but merely out of sympathy for your woeful condition, lest you fall into the pit of degradation, and so that you might recognize the truth before you pass away. Creating dissension and mischief among Muslims is indeed your habit and is, in fact, your creed and method due to which you declared a Muslim to be a kafir [disbeliever], faithless, and dajjal [deceiver]; and deceiving the ulema you got them to issue edicts of disbelief. You also did a disservice to your preceptor Nadhir Husain, when he was nearing his death, by persuading him to pronounce the formula by which I was declared a kafir, thus casting the dust of disgrace on his piety in his old age.

You deserve ‘applause’ on this ‘manly performance’ of yours!

Nadhir Husain was advanced in years and was devoid of understanding like a child. It fell to you—to discharge the duties of being his disciple—by blackening his face in his old age when he was about to die, with such revolting black ink that he will probably take his blackened face with him to the grave. The court of God is not something to be taken lightly. He who calls a Muslim kafir will have to bear all the consequences which have been promised for the pronouncers of wanton edicts of disbelief by that Noble Messenger s (as) who so loved justice that, on one occasion, when he was approached to deal leniently with a thief he said with great displeasure, ‘By the Being who controls my life, even if Fatimah, daughter of Muhammad s (as) were to commit theft, her hand too would be cut off.’

His Statement: (In such case, I can come to Qadian) to expose your lies and fraud to the Muslims, but I am afraid that you will try to cause physical harm to my life.

My Statement: You cannot flee now through the means of any excuse or ruse. You have been presented with 10 curses and have been adjured in the name of Allah, glorified be His eminence, to settle the question of my truth or falsehood in accordance with the heavenly principle. If you are right in considering me to be a liar, then you will make yourself ready to oppose me as soon as you hear this from me. Otherwise, you will swallow all these curses and will seek to avoid the issue with absurd and half-baked excuses. And I do not wish to destroy you; there is only One who will destroy you if you do not desist and will safeguard His religion from this mischief of yours. There is no need for you to come to Qadian. If you are prepared to hold a test in accordance with the standard set by Allah and the Messenger s (as), I myself can come to Batala, Amritsar, or Lahore.

[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]

[So that the face of the one who is a liar may be blackened].

I now proceed to set out the response given by Shaikh Batalawi below.

And it is as follows:

Batala, District Gurdaspur, (1 January 1893). No.1

Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Kadian ! May God guide you and bring you to the right path!

سَلَٰمٌ عَلَىٰ
مَنِ ٱتَّبَعَ ٱلۡهُدَىٰٓ

[Peace be on those who follow the guidance.] I read your letter dated 31 December 1892 in amazement. I am not afraid of your bluster and bravado; on the contrary, I consider such fear to amount to shirk, and in response, I present the following verse from the Holy Qur’an:

Kadiani Sahib! I know that the Holy Qur’an and the former Scriptures, the religion of Islam and the former faiths, and the Prophet of the Last Age and the former Prophets are true and believe in their truth; consequently, it is essential for me to consider you to be a liar and to reject you; for, your beliefs, your teachings,

of this letter has written it with a kaf (ک) instead of a qaf (ق), hence this spelling. [Publisher]

and your manners and morals are contrary and opposed to the former books, faiths, and Prophets. Thus, believing in these books, faiths, and Prophets can only be true and correct if I regard your beliefs and teachings to be false and you to be misguided. The following verses are proof of this:

Apart from your false beliefs that are opposed to the faith of Islam and the former faiths, speaking lies and deception have become such an essential characteristic of yours, as if they are part and parcel of your innate nature. I do not have detailed knowledge of your life before the compilation of Barahin-e- Ahmadiyya but you have adopted lying and deceit since the time of the compilation of Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya, especially since [18]86 when you prophesied about the birth of a son according to a revelation and publicized other similar prophecies and, more specifically, since [18]90 when you published your claim to being the Promised Messiah—no writing, speech, letter, or book of yours has remained free from it. From this it can be inferred that in your earlier life, especially when you failed in the examination of legal attorney and during the prolonged period of being involved in litigation, this same must have been your condition.

·

10 of 10 left today