Reply to Shaikh Muhammad Husain Batalawi’s Paper
The Mirror of the Excellences of Islam, Part 2
[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]
[may Allah the Exalted bless his grandeur, knowledge, and longevity, and may He enrich His servants with his grace and blessings of his light and illumination]—were to stand on one side to describe the insights of the Noble Qur’an, and Miyan Batalawi were to stand on the other side to describe some verities of Furqan-e-Hamid [the Praiseworthy Discrimination—the Holy Qur’an], I am certain as if I am seeing it right now, that in comparison with the aforesaid gentleman, this helpless, half-schooled mullah from Batala imprisoned by pride and arrogance will be left so humbled and so far behind that every sensible individual will be laughing at him.
I have always wondered why this hatib-ul-lail does not look inward at himself in spite of such baseless arrogance and manifest lies and why he so wickedly refers to scholars and learned people with disdain. It is easy to decide about his status as a maulawi and his corrupt delusions. The time for it, by the grace of God Almighty, is nigh. I will, insha’Allah [God willing], describe a complete set of criteria for settling this issue at the end of this discourse. I will now provide the necessary responses to several criticisms, and those are as follows:
His Statement—Is it incumbent upon the prophecies of even Prophets to be true or not? Page 26.
My response—The intent of the foolish critic for raising this question seems to be as if some prophecy of my humble self came out contrary to the actual events. Let it be clear, therefore, that this is easy to decide. It is incumbent upon the critic to arrange a meeting to present the ilham [revelation (i.e. prophecy)] of mine in which there is an error in the words of the ilham itself, not in any suspected or supposed interpretation. However, there must be some punishment for such a person to prevent him from hastening towards the filth of lying again and again.
His Statement—Can someone whose given prophecy comes true while another is false be a Mulham [recipient of Divine revelation] with respect to the truthful prophecy?
My response—O blind fool! By the grace of the Almighty, no prophecy of my humble self has turned out false to this day. On the contrary, nearly 3,000 have already come true, and they continue to come true. As for the error of interpretation, open [Sahih al-]Bukhari and ponder over the subject matter of
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[‘it occurred to me’]. And be fearful of becoming like those who turned apostate by seeing the errors of the interpretation of some prophecies.
His Statement—Can someone who tells lies, usurps the properties of others, etc., be called a Mulham, [recipient of Divine revelation], Wali [Friend (of Allah)], Muhaddath [recipient of Divine discourse], or the addressee of God, if any prophecy of his comes true?
My response—Ill-natured fabricators [of lies] like you levied the same objections against the Prophets. Abraham was accused of lying, Moses and Jesus were accused of misappropriation, and the innately blind Christians etc., of this age, make similar accusations against the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, alleging that the property of a certain caravan was looted without the state of war. Their books are filled with such accusations. If it is now asked that if someone shed the blood of thousands and looted wealth, how can he be a true Prophet? The answer to such a fool would be ‘because of his perfect [heavenly] refulgence which is not bestowed upon any except the righteous.’ A wise person would see the lustre of this refulgence and would understand the true import of these matters by his God-given wisdom. But the ignorant one will remain adamant upon his criticisms and will move straight towards Hell.
The essential truth is that the right of God Almighty supersedes all other rights. Every body, soul, and property belongs to Him alone. Thus, when a man becomes disobedient, his property reverts to the Real Owner. Then the Real Owner has the right to destroy the properties of the disobedient without the intermediation of the Messengers and convey their lives to utter nothingness or cause such awe-striking punishment to descend upon them through some Messenger. Both amount to the same thing. Similarly, there are thousands of matters like the acts of Khidr whose merit is revealed to the Prophets and the Muhaddathin [recipients of Divine discourse]. They are assigned to carry them out, and those who hasten to interfere in opposition to their tasks are the ones who are destroyed.
His Statement—Have you made a prophecy of the death of my humble self upon reaching the age of 52 years or not?
My response—I have certainly not made this prophecy about you. If anyone has attributed it to me, he certainly lied. It is sheer dishonesty and deceit on your part that without asking me or finding any such statement in my writings, you have accused me without any reason.
His Statement—Some of your followers drink alcohol. Has your chief helper and follower not consumed alcohol at your home?
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[May the curse of Allah be upon the liars]. Now prove who drank alcohol at my house and who drinks alcohol out of those who have taken my Bai‘at [Pledge of Allegiance]. I observe that people suddenly manifest a holy transformation in their behaviour after taking the Bai‘at. They are regular in Prayers, abstain from the forbidden, and give precedence to the Faith over worldly objects. The truly righteous are in no need of being called virtuous by anyone. God Almighty sees the hearts, and His seeing is sufficient.
Now, in accordance with my promise, I would like to lay down a criterion herewith that will amply demonstrate that my humble self enjoys the support of Allah and Mr Batalawi is a liar of the first degree, a dajjal [deceiver], and the leader of the haughty. That statement is the following.
Readers are aware, based on the continuous writings of Mr Batalawi, that he has called my humble self ignorant, foolish, and illiterate. Moreover, he has claimed that my humble self is, in reality, not a Mulham and a Muhaddath; but rather, is a rogue, a kadhdhab [great liar], and a dajjal. According to him, falsehood permeates me entirely. When some Signs were shown to him, he responded that sometimes God Almighty helps a false claimant as well, even though He knows that His help would become a testimony for the truthfulness of a false claimant. Nevertheless, He helps such a one, and enables such liars to use the arts of divination and foretelling to say something which is fulfilled. Thus, Mr Batalawi has rejected such Signs through his absurd statements. However, there is another criterion here which I describe below.
A spiritual Sign through which it will be proven whether or not my humble self is truthful and a recipient of help from God Almighty. And whether Shaikh Muhammad Husain Batalawi is true in declaring me a liar and dajjal, or whether he himself is a liar and dajjal